Leighton Sheldon joins Jeremy and Graig Miller and we keep the trio together through the end of this part. We start with Strongsville chatter and a Savannah Bananas detour, then dive into the Messi vs Gretzky question. From there it is vintage talk in a frothy market, including being priced out of grails like 1914 and 1915 Cracker Jack Shoeless Joe Jackson, how to pivot without quitting, and why lowering grade expectations can unlock iconic cards. Leighton previews AuctionWire.ai for live auction discovery, and we swap stories about provenance, kid handwriting on the backs, and why value vintage boxes can hook new collectors. We wrap by agreeing the thrill of the hunt keeps the hobby fun, even when prices are tough.

Highlights

Strongsville vibes and first takes on Savannah Bananas cards

Messi vs Gretzky and how worldwide relevance intersects with hobby demand

When a grail runs away: consolidate, pivot, or lower the slab grade target

Cracker Jack Shoeless Joe, Jordan inserts, and strategies when pricing surges

AuctionWire.ai preview for tracking live auctions and fixed price marketplaces

Provenance and story value: writing on cards, original owner paths, loved copies

Value vintage boxes and easy entry points for new collectors

Part concludes with Jeremy, Graig, and Leighton still on the mics

Recorded: Saturday, September 13, 2025

Sponsor Note:  Go to ⁠hellofresh.com/cards10fm⁠ now to get 10 free meals plus a free item for life, one per box with active subscription free meals applied as a discount on the first box. New subscribers only, and it varies by plan.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices