
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Jeremy Lee and David Chase welcome Leighton Sheldon of Just Collect and Gary LeMaster of The Ballcard Show for a wide-ranging conversation about the sports card market, collector psychology, and the forces driving today's hobby.
Leighton offers his perspective on dealing with the emotional aftermath of selling treasured cards, and the guys tackle a hypothetical $5,000 vintage card buying challenge. The conversation then turns to eye appeal, grading, and whether traditional sales comps are becoming less relevant as collectors increasingly recognize exceptional cards within lower-grade holders.
Gary joins the discussion to explore the growing influence of repack companies on the sports card market. Are repackers providing essential liquidity and keeping dealers in business, or is the hobby becoming dangerously dependent on their buying power? And what happens if that demand begins to disappear?
Plus, the guys examine the differences between vintage and modern market activity, the risks of investing in active players, and the complicated relationship between collecting for enjoyment and collecting for financial gain.
Check out POPs & COMPs, Jeremy Lee's book exploring the truths, insights, and psychology behind the numbers that drive the sports card market.
Discover Hobby Spectrum and learn more about your collector identity.
Visit AuctionWire.ai and use promo code SCL to save 45% on your first year, just $100 for access to a powerful auction search platform.
Subscribe to Sports Cards Live on YouTube, follow the podcast on your favorite platform, and join the conversation!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Fresh off an unforgettable Toronto Sport Card Expo, Jeremy Lee joins David Chase to revisit the biggest sales of his collecting life, the emotional aftermath of letting go of treasured cards, and the unexpected acquisition that helped ease the pain.
What happens when your "not for sale" prices aren't high enough? Can record-setting sales still leave a collector with serious regrets? And how do you rebuild a collection when some of its most important pieces are suddenly gone?
Plus, Jeremy shares his Expo pickups, reflects on how his collecting philosophy may be evolving, and introduces a brand-new Sports Cards Live segment: Pump My Card! Jeremy and David have some fun with card valuations, population reports, and the fine art of pumping cards they already own.
It's a conversation about money, attachment, collector identity, changing tastes, and the complicated relationship between loving your cards and knowing when to let them go.
Check out POPs & COMPs, Jeremy Lee's book exploring the truths, insights, and psychology behind the numbers that drive the sports card market.
Discover Hobby Spectrum and learn more about your collector identity.
Visit AuctionWire.ai and use promo code SCL to save 45% on your first year, just $100 for access to a powerful auction search platform.
Subscribe to Sports Cards Live on YouTube, follow the podcast on your favorite platform, and join the conversation!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
BONUS EPISODE
After selling six significant cards from my personal collection at the Toronto Sport Card Expo, including my Leaf Jackie Robinson, Bowman Mickey Mantle, and Goudey Babe Ruth, I was left questioning more than just the decisions I'd made.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Welcome to Episode 6 of POPs & COMPs: The Author Reads!
I'm doing something I've never done before. I'm sitting down and reading my book, POPs & COMPs: Truths, Insights and Psychology Behind the Numbers that Drive the Sports Card Market, a few chapters at a time, and sharing it with you here on Sports Cards Live and across podcast platforms.
These are raw, one-take recordings. No professional narration, no fancy production, and probably a few stumbles along the way. Just me reading the book as I wrote it.
You don't need to own the book to follow along, and you don't need to watch the video. Just press play and listen.
In this sixth episode, I'll be reading five chapters:
Chapter 15: Alteration Detection Toolkit
Chapter 16: Slab Security and Anti-Counterfeit Measures
Chapter 17: Challenges of Thick Cards and Patches
Chapter 18: Sheet Cut Cards and Grading
Chapter 19: Hand Cut and Perforated Cards and Grading
We continue exploring some of the more technical and challenging aspects of card grading, from the tools and techniques used to detect alterations to the security measures designed to protect graded cards from counterfeiting and tampering. We also examine the unique challenges associated with grading thick memorabilia and patch cards, sheet-cut cards, and hand-cut or perforated issues. How should grading companies approach cards that don't fit neatly into traditional grading standards, and what should collectors understand about the risks and limitations involved?
POPs & COMPs was a passion project that became a published book, exploring the numbers, psychology, motivations, and behaviours that influence the sports card market and the people who participate in it.
I'm making these recordings available for free. My hope is that you'll enjoy listening, perhaps learn something, and come away thinking about the hobby a little differently.
If you enjoy the series and would like to support the work I'm doing through Sports Cards Live and in the hobby, please consider purchasing a physical copy of POPs & COMPs.
You can order a copy through Amazon, and if you see me at a card show, I'd be happy to sign it for you.
If you're in Canada and would prefer to purchase a signed copy directly from me, feel free to reach out by email and we can arrange it.
Of course, there's absolutely no obligation to buy anything. I'm happy to share the book this way, and I appreciate everyone who takes the time to listen.
Thanks for being part of the community, and I hope you enjoy the book!
Jeremy Lee
Sports Cards Live
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Welcome to Episode 5 of POPs & COMPs: The Author Reads!
I'm doing something I've never done before. I'm sitting down and reading my book, POPs & COMPs: Truths, Insights and Psychology Behind the Numbers that Drive the Sports Card Market, a few chapters at a time, and sharing it with you here on Sports Cards Live and across podcast platforms.
These are raw, one-take recordings. No professional narration, no fancy production, and probably a few stumbles along the way. Just me reading the book as I wrote it.
You don't need to own the book to follow along, and you don't need to watch the video. Just press play and listen.
In this fifth episode, I'll be reading three chapters:
Chapter 12: Population Control
Chapter 13: Grading is Not Always Correct
Chapter 14: Changing Grading Standards
We continue examining some of the more challenging aspects of third-party grading, including population control, the reality that grading companies don't always get it right, and the implications of grading standards that can change over time. How much confidence should collectors place in population reports and assigned grades, and what happens when the standards used to evaluate our cards evolve?
POPs & COMPs was a passion project that became a published book, exploring the numbers, psychology, motivations, and behaviours that influence the sports card market and the people who participate in it.
I'm making these recordings available for free. My hope is that you'll enjoy listening, perhaps learn something, and come away thinking about the hobby a little differently.
If you enjoy the series and would like to support the work I'm doing through Sports Cards Live and in the hobby, please consider purchasing a physical copy of POPs & COMPs.
You can order a copy through Amazon, and if you see me at a card show, I'd be happy to sign it for you.
If you're in Canada and would prefer to purchase a signed copy directly from me, feel free to reach out by email and we can arrange it.
Of course, there's absolutely no obligation to buy anything. I'm happy to share the book this way, and I appreciate everyone who takes the time to listen.
Thanks for being part of the community, and I hope you enjoy the book!
Jeremy Lee
Sports Cards Live
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Welcome to Episode 4 of POPs & COMPs: The Author Reads!
I'm doing something I've never done before. I'm sitting down and reading my book, POPs & COMPs: Truths, Insights and Psychology Behind the Numbers that Drive the Sports Card Market, a few chapters at a time, and sharing it with you here on Sports Cards Live and across podcast platforms.
These are raw, one-take recordings. No professional narration, no fancy production, and probably a few stumbles along the way. Just me reading the book as I wrote it.
You don't need to own the book to follow along, and you don't need to watch the video. Just press play and listen.
In this fourth episode, I'll be reading four chapters:
Chapter 8: What and Why to Grade
Chapter 9: Identification as a Responsibility of Grading Companies
Chapter 10: Qualifiers and Authentic Labels
Chapter 11: Transparency and the Black Box of Grading
We turn our attention to the grading process itself, exploring why collectors choose to grade their cards, the responsibilities grading companies have when identifying and authenticating them, and the role of qualifiers and authentic labels. We also examine one of the hobby's most persistent questions: how much transparency should collectors expect from grading companies, and what really goes on inside the black box of grading?
POPs & COMPs was a passion project that became a published book, exploring the numbers, psychology, motivations, and behaviours that influence the sports card market and the people who participate in it.
I'm making these recordings available for free. My hope is that you'll enjoy listening, perhaps learn something, and come away thinking about the hobby a little differently.
If you enjoy the series and would like to support the work I'm doing through Sports Cards Live and in the hobby, please consider purchasing a physical copy of POPs & COMPs.
You can order a copy through Amazon, and if you see me at a card show, I'd be happy to sign it for you.
If you're in Canada and would prefer to purchase a signed copy directly from me, feel free to reach out by email and we can arrange it.
Of course, there's absolutely no obligation to buy anything. I'm happy to share the book this way, and I appreciate everyone who takes the time to listen.
Thanks for being part of the community, and I hope you enjoy the book!
Jeremy Lee
Sports Cards Live
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Welcome to Episode 3 of POPs & COMPs: The Author Reads!
I'm doing something I've never done before. I'm sitting down and reading my book, POPs & COMPs: Truths, Insights and Psychology Behind the Numbers that Drive the Sports Card Market, a few chapters at a time, and sharing it with you here on Sports Cards Live and across podcast platforms.
These are raw, one-take recordings. No professional narration, no fancy production, and probably a few stumbles along the way. Just me reading the book as I wrote it.
You don't need to own the book to follow along, and you don't need to watch the video. Just press play and listen.
In this third episode, I'll be reading five chapters:
Chapter 3: Understanding Population Reports
Chapter 4: The Rise of Grading and the Future of Slabs
Chapter 5: Total Population versus Grade-Specific Pop
Chapter 6: Cross-Grader Pop Awareness
Chapter 7: Volume of Grading Through the Years
We continue our exploration of grading population data, looking at how grading has evolved, what population reports can and cannot tell us, and why understanding the differences between total populations, grade-specific populations, and populations across grading companies matters. We also examine how grading volumes have changed over time and what those trends might reveal about the hobby.
POPs & COMPs was a passion project that became a published book, exploring the numbers, psychology, motivations, and behaviours that influence the sports card market and the people who participate in it.
I'm making these recordings available for free. My hope is that you'll enjoy listening, perhaps learn something, and come away thinking about the hobby a little differently.
If you enjoy the series and would like to support the work I'm doing through Sports Cards Live and in the hobby, please consider purchasing a physical copy of POPs & COMPs.
You can order a copy through Amazon, and if you see me at a card show, I'd be happy to sign it for you.
If you're in Canada and would prefer to purchase a signed copy directly from me, feel free to reach out by email and we can arrange it.
Of course, there's absolutely no obligation to buy anything. I'm happy to share the book this way, and I appreciate everyone who takes the time to listen.
Thanks for being part of the community, and I hope you enjoy the book!
Jeremy Lee
Sports Cards Live
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Welcome to Episode 2 of POPs & COMPs: The Author Reads!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Welcome to Episode 1 of POPs & COMPs: The Author Reads!
I'm doing something I've never done before. I'm sitting down and reading my book, POPs & COMPs: Truths, Insights and Psychology Behind the Numbers that Drive the Sports Card Market, one chapter at a time, and sharing it with you here on Sports Cards Live and across podcast platforms.
These are raw, one-take recordings. No professional narration, no fancy production, and probably a few stumbles along the way. Just me reading the book as I wrote it.
You don't need to own the book to follow along, and you don't need to watch the video. Just press play and listen.
In this first episode, I'll read the front matter and Chapter 1.
POPs & COMPs was a passion project that became a published book, exploring the numbers, psychology, motivations, and behaviours that influence the sports card market and the people who participate in it.
I'm making these recordings available for free. My hope is that you'll enjoy listening, perhaps learn something, and come away thinking about the hobby a little differently.
If you enjoy the series and would like to support the work I'm doing through Sports Cards Live and in the hobby, please consider purchasing a physical copy of POPs & COMPs.
You can order a copy through Amazon, and if you see me at a card show, I'd be happy to sign it for you.
If you're in Canada and would prefer to purchase a signed copy directly from me, feel free to reach out by email and we can arrange it.
Of course, there's absolutely no obligation to buy anything. I'm happy to share the book this way, and I appreciate everyone who takes the time to listen.
Thanks for being part of the community, and I hope you enjoy the book!
Jeremy Lee
Sports Cards Live
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Is the sports card hobby changing for the better, or are corporate interests, gambling, and rising prices threatening the collecting experience?
In the final segment of this Halloween edition of Sports Cards Live, Jeremy Lee, David Chase, Joshua Adams, and Chris McGill tackle a provocative question about the direction of the hobby and whether its growing commercial interests are creating more winners than losers.
Joshua offers a particularly strong perspective on Fanatics, corporate consolidation, breaking, and the growing influence of gambling-style products. The panel explores whether these developments are pushing traditional collectors aside or simply creating new ways for people to participate in an expanding hobby.
The conversation turns to the future of local card shops, the importance of preserving the relationships and community they provide, and whether these businesses need to evolve to remain relevant in a changing marketplace.
Plus, the panel discusses card vaults versus physical ownership, the appeal of tangible collectibles in an increasingly digital world, and the distinction between the hobby as a personal passion and the hobby as a business.
As the episode comes to a close, the guys reflect on what it means to enjoy collecting on your own terms, regardless of how everyone else chooses to participate.
Check out POPs & COMPs, Jeremy Lee's book exploring the truths, insights, and psychology behind the numbers that drive the sports card market.
Discover AuctionWire.ai, where you can search auctions across the hobby in one place. Use promo code SCL for 45% off your first year, bringing the price to just $100.
Originally aired October 31, 2026, as part of Sports Cards Live Episode 334.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
From the publisher's feed
Ranked by our users in the last 21 days

122 Listeners

80 Listeners

99 Listeners

372 Listeners

118 Listeners

24 Listeners

173 Listeners

111 Listeners

1,036 Listeners

47 Listeners

35 Listeners

45 Listeners

35 Listeners

25 Listeners

11 Listeners