Sign up to save your podcasts
Or
Share Protestant Pastor Becomes Catholic: The Hard Truth Every Man Needs to Hear (w/ Keith Nester)
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Or
Protestant Pastor Becomes Catholic: The Hard Truth Every Man Needs to Hear (w/ Keith Nester)
Keith Nester spent more than two decades as a Protestant pastor. Preaching, leading, counseling, and absolutely certain he would never become Catholic. Yet his actual conversion story is long, often humorous, at times painful, and far deeper than a simple change of denomination. In this episode, John Heinen and Devin Schadt sit down with @KeithNester to uncover what really happened behind the scenes: the fears he carried, the pride he had to confront, the moments of grace that broke him open, and the unexpected ways God used marriage, suffering, and friendship to draw him home.
But this isn’t just a conversion story, the show quickly turns to truths every man needs to hear. Truths about how to lead, love, and live the faith with integrity. Keith shares the “hard truth” he believes all men must face: that authority without humility collapses, that evangelization begins long before words are spoken, but we still must speak, and that the quiet witness of fatherhood, sacrifice, and joy can transform more hearts than arguments ever will.
🟢 Join Catholic Gentleman+ for over 31 sessions of exclusive formation, daily saint quotes, and a brotherhood of men pursuing holiness: https://catholicgentlemanplus.com
YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@keithnester
Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/keithnestercatholic
Website - https://down2earthministry.org/
👉 25% OFF Devin’s new book The Rule: https://sophiainstitute.com/product/the-rule/
Use coupon code Gentleman25 for 25% off this Christmas Season.
SPONSOR - https://www.vocatiotravel.com
Video Producer - Pietro Damasceno
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
View all episodes
By John Heinen, Devin Schadt, Sam Guzman
4.7
437437 ratings
Keith Nester spent more than two decades as a Protestant pastor. Preaching, leading, counseling, and absolutely certain he would never become Catholic. Yet his actual conversion story is long, often humorous, at times painful, and far deeper than a simple change of denomination. In this episode, John Heinen and Devin Schadt sit down with @KeithNester to uncover what really happened behind the scenes: the fears he carried, the pride he had to confront, the moments of grace that broke him open, and the unexpected ways God used marriage, suffering, and friendship to draw him home.
But this isn’t just a conversion story, the show quickly turns to truths every man needs to hear. Truths about how to lead, love, and live the faith with integrity. Keith shares the “hard truth” he believes all men must face: that authority without humility collapses, that evangelization begins long before words are spoken, but we still must speak, and that the quiet witness of fatherhood, sacrifice, and joy can transform more hearts than arguments ever will.
🟢 Join Catholic Gentleman+ for over 31 sessions of exclusive formation, daily saint quotes, and a brotherhood of men pursuing holiness: https://catholicgentlemanplus.com
YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@keithnester
Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/keithnestercatholic
Website - https://down2earthministry.org/
👉 25% OFF Devin’s new book The Rule: https://sophiainstitute.com/product/the-rule/
Use coupon code Gentleman25 for 25% off this Christmas Season.
SPONSOR - https://www.vocatiotravel.com
Video Producer - Pietro Damasceno
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
More shows like The Catholic Gentleman
View all
Catholic Stuff You Should Know
13 Listeners
Bishop Barron’s Sunday Sermons - Catholic Preaching and Homilies
4,996 Listeners
The Word on Fire Show - Catholic Faith and Culture
5,739 Listeners
Dr Taylor Marshall Podcast
4,026 Listeners
Pints With Aquinas
6,738 Listeners
The Catholic Man Show
753 Listeners
The Fr. Mike Schmitz Catholic Podcast
7,680 Listeners
The Counsel of Trent
2,610 Listeners
The Catholic Talk Show
1,516 Listeners
Every Knee Shall Bow (Your Catholic Evangelization Podcast)
855 Listeners
The Road to Emmaus with Scott Hahn
960 Listeners
American Catholic History
912 Listeners
Godsplaining
1,278 Listeners
Catholic Saints
1,185 Listeners
Chris Stefanick Catholic Show
443 Listeners