The Detail

Scrutiny Week's scoreboard


Listen Later

What did we get out of Scrutiny Week? A look at what emerged from dozens of hours of questioning over the government's spending priorities

It was a week where government ministers couldn't dodge the spotlight, but plenty of them still managed to duck questions over their budget decisions

New Zealand politicians have survived the first ever Scrutiny Week, an innovation that clears the parliamentary decks and lets them eyeball each other over budget decisions.

Today on The Detail we call in Newsroom's senior political reporter Marc Daalder to tell us what we learned from the week where politicians had to turn up to be questioned on the finer details of the Budget, what their priorities are and where their thinking lies.

Some of it was a revelation - and not just because of the news that emerged such as the conservation minister Tama Potaka's hesitation over saving endangered species, or the thinking behind National's decision to reverse a Labour move over pay for disabled workers.

"We came out of this week learning quite a few things - the ministers who are across their portfolio and the ones who aren't," says Daalder.

With some it felt like they were winging their way through; some deferred questions to officials for operational or technical details; and others such as technology minister Judith Collins were very familiar with their areas.

Daalder says the majority of the questions are allocated to the opposition, which is able to push ministers and related officials in sustained lines of questioning to really figure out "what money's been spent, what are the impacts of cuts that have been made, and what are the next steps in key policy areas".

Some of those sessions were quite long, in contrast to Question Time that "really doesn't get anyone any answers", says Daalder.

"It's very performative, a lot of grandstanding ...(whereas) this takes place in select committee rooms, people are sitting down which helps, and the people that they're questioning are only a couple of metres away from them, looking at each other in the eyes and able to have more of a conversation.

"That's not to say there wasn't plenty of argy-bargy, there was plenty of that.

"But I think there were opportunities for real discussions, real questions and real answers which you don't get in Question Time."

Of course, some questions were too political and felt like point-scoring opportunities; others from National MPs were obvious 'patsy' questions and were a waste of time.

Newsroom made a point of covering as many of the hearings as possible, Daalder saying the new scrutiny is designed to hold politicians to account. …

Go to this episode on rnz.co.nz for more details

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The DetailBy RNZ

  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7

4.7

22 ratings


More shows like The Detail

View all
Nine To Noon by RNZ

Nine To Noon

21 Listeners

Saturday Morning by RNZ

Saturday Morning

41 Listeners

Sunday Morning by RNZ

Sunday Morning

9 Listeners

Business News by RNZ

Business News

8 Listeners

Focus on Politics by RNZ

Focus on Politics

10 Listeners

Mediawatch by RNZ

Mediawatch

12 Listeners

Parliament - Live Stream and Question Time by RNZ

Parliament - Live Stream and Question Time

3 Listeners

Pacific Waves by RNZ

Pacific Waves

12 Listeners

News in Pacific Languages by RNZ

News in Pacific Languages

1 Listeners

Tagata o te Moana by RNZ

Tagata o te Moana

1 Listeners

Gone By Lunchtime by The Spinoff

Gone By Lunchtime

27 Listeners

Black Sheep by RNZ

Black Sheep

75 Listeners

The House by RNZ

The House

1 Listeners

The Mike Hosking Breakfast by Newstalk ZB

The Mike Hosking Breakfast

57 Listeners

The Front Page by NZ Herald

The Front Page

15 Listeners

Rural News by RNZ

Rural News

1 Listeners

A Moment In Crime by NZME

A Moment In Crime

49 Listeners

 by Steven Holloway & Seamus Marten

89 Listeners

Shared Lunch by Sharesies

Shared Lunch

15 Listeners

Kiwi Yarns by Stuff | Brodie Kane Media

Kiwi Yarns

17 Listeners

When the Facts Change by The Spinoff

When the Facts Change

17 Listeners

World & Pacific News by RNZ

World & Pacific News

0 Listeners

ICYMI by RNZ

ICYMI

0 Listeners

RNZ News by RNZ

RNZ News

5 Listeners

30 with Guyon Espiner by RNZ

30 with Guyon Espiner

16 Listeners

Kim Hill Wants To Know by RNZ

Kim Hill Wants To Know

12 Listeners