Sutton Foster is a quiet force: The Broadway superstar has been nominated for six Tony Awards (she’s won two) and for the past six seasons she’s been starring on Younger, the beloved TV Land series that has her playing both a 40-something and a millennial. This week, Sutton sits down with Perrie to talk about what she wore when she auditioned for that show, her favorite musical of all time, her complicated path to motherhood, her new Gucci loafers, and how in some ways, caring less about what you wear to auditions can be an asset. 

For more on this episode, visit glamour.com/whatiworewhen.

Follow @suttonlenore on Instagram and @sfosternyc on Twitter, and watch Sutton as Liza Miller on Younger.