It's the mighty She Loves You this episode on Stuffology, the biggest-selling Beatles single of them all. Does the song deserve its totemic reputation? How does Brian Epstein factor into this? And when discussing production, just how pretentious can JG get? (hint: fairly!)

eMail: [email protected]

Twitter: @beatles_ology

JG's Writing: Judgementally Comments...

We flip the disc for our song choice this week and cover the B-side "Thank You Girl". Did the song deserve to be an A-side as originally intended? What was going on in the charts at this time? And why the diversion into Cliff Richard talk? (to be honest, the last of those questions may not be answered after listening). Thanks, Thank You Girl!

eMail: [email protected]

Twitter: @beatles_ology

JG's Writing: Judgementally Comments...

We leave Please Please Me behind and stroll into the world of non-album singles as JG and Andrew get to grips with The Beatles very first number one, "From Me To You". Does the song deserve its place as the very first of the band's to top the charts? How long will it take until Ringo gets mentioned?  And how good is the "song length to podcast episode length" ratio?

eMail: [email protected]

Twitter: @beatles_ology

JG's Writing: Judgementally Comments...

With each individual track now covered it's time to turn our attention to the album as a whole, as JG and Andrew discuss Please Please Me as a singular work rather than a broken-up series of tracks. How does the album stand up when considered as a whole? Just how much cultural context can be squeezed into one episode before they actually get round to talking about the album this episode is ostensibly about? Where will things go from here? Plus, most gloriously of all, we have the first discussion of The Rutles! You can't ask for more than that!

eMail: [email protected]

Twitter: @beatles_ology

JG's Writing: Judgementally Comments...

We make it to the end of Please Please Me this week with the totemic "Twist And Shout". Does the song deserve its mythical reputation? Is it the perfect capper to the album? And how many off-the-subject diversions can one episode manage to encapsulate?

Twitter: @beatles_ology

eMail: [email protected]

JG's Writing: Judgementally Comments...

We're nearly there! This episode sees the second-last track on Please Please Me covered, as JG and Andrew chat about "There's A Place". How does the song stand up? How are the harmonies? Can anyone find anything to say about this particular track? (glance at the running time for this episode and see if you can figure it out!)

eMail: [email protected]

Twitter: @beatles_ology

JG's Writing: Judgementally Comments...

As we shuffle gainfully (gainfully? Sure!) towards the end of the album we first get to sample "A Taste Of Honey". How does a ballad like this stack up against the rest of the album? What do liminal spaces have to do with anything? Why is Billy Dee Williams mentioned? And, perhaps most importantly of all, why do our Mexican and Swedish listeners get a shout-out?

eMail: [email protected]

Twitter: @beatles_ology

JG's Writing: Judgementally Comments...

It's George's turn at the old microphone stand with this Side Two ditty, "Do You Want To Know A Secret". How does he compare alongside messers Lennon and McCartney when it comes to vocals? Is everything being taken entirely seriously? And why did anyone think it was a good idea to mention the semiotic thickness of the text? These, and many fewer, questions are answered right here!

eMail: [email protected]

Twitter: @beatles_ology

JG's Writing: Judgementally Comments...

JG and Andrew continue through Side Two of Please Please Me with "Baby It's You". How does the second Shirelles cover go (and does the album really call for two of them)? How many sha-la-la-la-la's are strictly necessary? And just how seriously should those backing vocals be taken?

eMail: [email protected]

Twitter: @beatles_ology

JG's Blog: Judgementally Comments...

We reach the title track of the first album this time as JG and Andrew tackle "Please Please Me". Is the track mighty enough to deserve having the album named after it? How impressive is George Martin this time out? And can the conversation actually remain on track? (surprisingly, yes!).

Since this is posting on 25th December I would also be remiss if I didn't turn to face you, break the fourth wall and say, "Incidentally, a happy Christmas to all of you at home!"

eMail: [email protected]

Twitter: @beatles_ology

JG's Writing: Judgementally Comments...