It was Thursday, May 10, 2001 around 7:30 when the call came in to 911 operators in Manhattan, New York asking for help. 5 people had been shot in an apartment on the 6th floor above Carnegie Deli in Midtown Manhattan. All were shot in the back of the head while lying facedown on the ground, their hands duct taped behind their backs. This looked like an execution. But miraculously, two victims would survive the attack, and the story they had for police was shocking.

Sponsors:

Prose! Get 50% off your first subscription and FREE consultation at Prose.com/creepers

EarnIn Download EarnIn today in the Google Play or Apple App Store! ● When you download the EarnIn app type in creepers under PODCAST when you sign up

Sources:

Show: Homicide: New York

What Homicide: New York Left Out About the Carnegie Deli Case | Den of Geek

Suspect in Murders Above Deli Says He Lied in Police Tape - The New York Times

Ganja Woman - The Village Voice

A Fading Actress, a Pile of Drugs and 3 Slayings - The New York Times

Jurors get crime scene details in Carnegie Deli murder case

New Jersey Parolee Is Arrested in Killings of 3 Above Carnegie Deli - The New York Times

2 Convicted In Carnegie Deli Killings - CBS News

‘GOD, I’M BLEEDING’ – CARNEGIE VICTIM’S 911 CALL CHILLS MASSACRE JURY

Survivors' Call for Help Is Heard In Killings Over Carnegie Deli - The New York Times

What is a Medicolegal Death Investigator/Technician?

Dirty Dancing Actress Shot Execution Style in 2001 Carnegie Deli Murders

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices