The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

The Mets are reeling while Juan Soto is heating up, and Gregg Giannotti wonders if Soto truly cares about his team's performance as long as he is putting up his usual All-Star numbers. Plus, Craig Carton rips the Mets for officially becoming irrelevant in 2026, while Evan Roberts declares that Carlos Mendoza should have been fired on two separate occasions this past week.

Carton and Big Mac analyze the growing political tension within the New York Giants locker room involving Jaxson Dart and Abdul Carter. They also investigate the mystery surrounding Mitchell Robinson's broken pinky and evaluate the Giants' performance throughout the offseason.

Carton and Big Mac react to internal friction within the Giants organization following Abdul Carter's comments on Jaxson Dart's political rally appearance. They also question the secretive nature of Mitchell Robinson’s injury and delve into the challenges of mental health in professional sports. Craig Carton recounts a startling experience witnessing a police arrest in Paramus during a family outing.

02:06 - Mitchell Robinson Pinky Mystery

06:50 - Giants PR Management Critique

13:03 - NBA Mental Health Sensitivity

21:04 - Paramus Mall Police Takedown

27:39 - Abdul Carter Political Comments

34:18 - Locker Room Political Dynamics

40:22 - Giants Offseason Progress Grades

They analyze the public friction between Jaxson Dart and Abdul Carter regarding political statements and the mysterious circumstances surrounding Mitchell Robinson's hand injury. The discussion also covers a grading of the New York Giants' offseason performance and includes personal stories about medical emergencies and office etiquette. The segment concludes with a debate on whether athletes should use their platforms for political activism.

11:40 - Pizza Drama and Keto

20:09 - Medevac Operations and Aviation

27:20 - Dart and Carter's Political Clash

37:47 - Grading the Giants' Offseason

43:53 - Comas and Near-Death Hallucinations

52:41 - Carton Recounts His Arraignment

59:00 - Athletes, Politics, and Injury Rumors

Craig and Big Mac discuss the peculiar naming of Lil Wayne’s racing camel before welcoming Mark Schlereth to analyze John Harbaugh’s leadership style. They explore the controversy surrounding Jaxson Dart and Abdul Carter, along with the mysterious circumstances of Mitchell Robinson’s pinky surgery. Additionally, Craig shares a personal story about the unusual side effects of the medication Ropinirole.

01:55 - Lil Wayne's Camel

06:00 - Scuba Acronym Meaning

12:21 - Mitchell Robinson Injury

17:59 - Mark Schlereth Interview

21:27 - Locker Room Rifts

29:54 - Giants Culture Build

38:55 - Pinky Injury Rumors

42:53 - Ropinirole Side Effects

50:00 - Police & Trivia

55:39 - Best Acronyms Debate

Craig Carton discusses a potential recreational injury theory regarding Mitchell Robinson's broken pinky while avoiding explicit confirmation. The show also addresses recent social media tension between Giants teammates Jackson Dart and Abdul Carter over political differences.

01:20 - Contestant Introductions

02:36 - Manhattan Henge Discussion

03:10 - Game Topic Selection

04:19 - Famous Johns Game

09:03 - 90s Knicks Trivia

15:09 - Acronym vs Initialism

17:29 - Robinson's Pinky Mystery

23:00 - High School Presentation

27:55 - Yankees Weekend Outlook

33:11 - Mets Trade Deadline

34:56 - Giants Teammate Tension

Three-time Super Bowl champion Mark Schlereth joins The Carton Show to discuss the New York Giants' offseason, John Harbaugh's leadership style, and the much-discussed situation involving Jaxson Dart and Abdul Carter.

Schlereth shares insights from his exclusive interview with Harbaugh, explains why locker room culture can overcome political disagreements, and breaks down why the Giants' draft class and offseason additions have him optimistic about Big Blue's future.

Plus, Mark weighs in on Mitchell Robinson's mysterious pinky injury and reflects on his own long list of football injuries.

The laughs keep coming on WFAN's Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle bounce from Giants OTAs and the Jaxson Dart controversy to one of the funniest stories of the year!

Craig shares the unbelievable tale of accidentally sparring with an 83-year-old man at boxing training, while a caller recounts a chilling near-death experience that required a life-saving helicopter flight and a medically induced coma. The conversation also touches on athletes speaking out politically, Abdul Carter and Jaxson Dart's comments, bizarre mall police activity, and even Alvin & The Chipmunks!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the latest developments involving New York Giants rookies Abdul Carter and Jaxson Dart after both players addressed their widely discussed disagreement surrounding President Donald Trump.

A serious Giants discussion quickly turns into a full-blown pizza controversy on The Carton Show!