The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to explosive comments from New York Giants rookie Abdul Carter regarding teammate Jaxson Dart and his support of President Donald Trump.

Craig Carton describes being caught in the middle of a police takedown at the Westfield Garden State Plaza in Paramus. He and Big Mac then pivot to the New York Giants' decision to hold a press conference regarding recent political controversies involving players Jaxson Dart and Abdul Carter. Finally, they discuss Mitchell Robinson's injury and Carton's upcoming dinner with his son's girlfriend's family.

01:01 - Mall Police Encounter

06:12 - Giants PR Blunder

12:18 - Knicks Injury Update

19:06 - Phrase Ownership Debate

23:43 - Meeting The In-Laws

Carton and Big Mac critique the New York Giants for prolonging a controversy involving Abdul Carter and Jaxson Dart by holding an unnecessary press conference. They also discuss the mystery of Mitchell Robinson’s broken pinky, questioning why the Knicks are hiding the cause of the injury. Finally, they contrast this secrecy with Aaron Boone’s historical honesty regarding off-field accidents.

01:16 - Giants Press Conference News

02:46 - Giants PR Strategy Questioned

10:42 - Mitchell Robinson Injury Mystery

17:40 - Aaron Boone Injury Honesty

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down Gerrit Cole’s masterful performance in Kansas City and the New York Knicks’ historic path to the NBA Finals. They also interview comedian Chris DiStefano about his Knicks passion and analyze the latest salary cap proposals from MLB owners.

Craig and Big Mac breakdown Gerrit Cole's masterful start for the Yankees and examine why their rotation is currently the best in baseball. They also discuss the Knicks' historical rest advantage before the NBA Finals and react to a bizarre viral video of a one-handed woman being ticketed. Additionally, they hear from a caller married to the legendary private investigator Irwin Blye.

01:41 - Viral Traffic Stop Reaction

06:10 - Former Bank Robber Discussion

10:12 - Knicks Historical Rest Advantage

16:51 - Gerrit Cole Leads Rotation

21:10 - Jannik Sinner Betting Disaster

25:35 - Giants Team Meeting Drama

35:27 - Private Investigator Legend Story

Craigie and Big Mac analyze Gerrit Cole's impact on the Yankees' rotation and discuss the latest MLB salary cap proposal. Comedian Chris DiStefano joins to share his excitement for the Knicks' playoff run and his views on Brooklyn Nets fans. They also highlight the Garden of Dreams foundation and why certain celebrities are banned from Madison Square Garden.

01:20 - Gladys Knight Gambling Story

10:57 - The Stump Driving Debate

13:39 - Gerrit Cole Postseason Rotation

16:25 - MLB Salary Cap Proposal

25:21 - Knicks Garden Of Dreams

27:40 - Celebrities Banned From MSG

32:02 - Ben Stiller Movie Rankings

42:14 - Chris DiStefano Joins

52:57 - Tell The Truth Thursday

Craig and Big Mac analyze Gerrit Cole's dominant return to the Yankees and the incredible depth of their starting rotation. They also debate the difficult scheduling conflict between a Yankees game and the New York Knicks in the NBA Finals. The conversation covers the NBA's new anti-tanking rules and features a powerful caller story regarding a near-death experience.

02:00 - New York Sports Mojo

05:02 - Luis Gil's Dominance

10:02 - American League Outlook

14:20 - NBA Finals Scheduling Conflict

22:07 - Fox's New Broadcast Booth

27:03 - Bizarre Traffic Ticket Story

36:10 - Tell The Truth Thursday

40:24 - NBA Anti-Tanking Rules

48:06 - Near Death Experiences

Craig and Big Mac analyze the latest New York sports news, including the political controversy surrounding Jaxson Dart. They explore the ongoing MLB labor disputes regarding salary caps and the emotional response to reports about hockey player Claude Lemieux. The discussion also covers Gerrit Cole's return to the mound and a heated debate over whether the Yankees or the Knicks should be the city's championship priority.

01:50 - Gerrit Cole's Elite Return

06:39 - Giants Political Introduction Controversy

13:33 - Radio Career Path Banter

18:10 - Yankees vs Knicks Debate

31:08 - Viral Queens Dating Profile

41:48 - MLB Salary Cap Negotiations

17:27 - Fan Focus Sports Update

On this heated segment of the Carton Show on WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris “C-Mac” McMonigle dive into a fiery New York sports dilemma, would you rather see the Knicks win an NBA title or the Yankees add another World Series ring?

Caller Vinnie from Staten Island sparks a full-blown debate, dragging in A-Rod lunch jokes, fan loyalty, and the ultimate NYC sports hierarchy. Craig pushes the emotional weight of a Knicks championship, while C-Mac admits the temptation of Yankees glory—leading to a back-and-forth about fandom, legacy, and bragging rights across New York sports.