The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Craigie and Big Mac analyze Gerrit Cole's impact on the Yankees' rotation and discuss the latest MLB salary cap proposal. Comedian Chris DiStefano joins to share his excitement for the Knicks' playoff run and his views on Brooklyn Nets fans. They also highlight the Garden of Dreams foundation and why certain celebrities are banned from Madison Square Garden.

01:20 - Gladys Knight Gambling Story

10:57 - The Stump Driving Debate

13:39 - Gerrit Cole Postseason Rotation

16:25 - MLB Salary Cap Proposal

25:21 - Knicks Garden Of Dreams

27:40 - Celebrities Banned From MSG

32:02 - Ben Stiller Movie Rankings

42:14 - Chris DiStefano Joins

52:57 - Tell The Truth Thursday

Craig and Big Mac analyze Gerrit Cole's dominant return to the Yankees and the incredible depth of their starting rotation. They also debate the difficult scheduling conflict between a Yankees game and the New York Knicks in the NBA Finals. The conversation covers the NBA's new anti-tanking rules and features a powerful caller story regarding a near-death experience.

02:00 - New York Sports Mojo

05:02 - Luis Gil's Dominance

10:02 - American League Outlook

14:20 - NBA Finals Scheduling Conflict

22:07 - Fox's New Broadcast Booth

27:03 - Bizarre Traffic Ticket Story

36:10 - Tell The Truth Thursday

40:24 - NBA Anti-Tanking Rules

48:06 - Near Death Experiences

Craig and Big Mac analyze the latest New York sports news, including the political controversy surrounding Jaxson Dart. They explore the ongoing MLB labor disputes regarding salary caps and the emotional response to reports about hockey player Claude Lemieux. The discussion also covers Gerrit Cole's return to the mound and a heated debate over whether the Yankees or the Knicks should be the city's championship priority.

01:50 - Gerrit Cole's Elite Return

06:39 - Giants Political Introduction Controversy

13:33 - Radio Career Path Banter

18:10 - Yankees vs Knicks Debate

31:08 - Viral Queens Dating Profile

41:48 - MLB Salary Cap Negotiations

17:27 - Fan Focus Sports Update

On this heated segment of the Carton Show on WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris “C-Mac” McMonigle dive into a fiery New York sports dilemma, would you rather see the Knicks win an NBA title or the Yankees add another World Series ring?

Caller Vinnie from Staten Island sparks a full-blown debate, dragging in A-Rod lunch jokes, fan loyalty, and the ultimate NYC sports hierarchy. Craig pushes the emotional weight of a Knicks championship, while C-Mac admits the temptation of Yankees glory—leading to a back-and-forth about fandom, legacy, and bragging rights across New York sports.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the bizarre controversy surrounding Giants QB Jaxson Dart after reports surfaced that he had to “clear the air” with teammates following his Trump rally appearance.

The Knicks are headed toward the NBA Finals and New York is officially losing its mind! Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether Knicks Finals fever has officially surpassed Yankees baseball in NYC, including a hilarious scenario where fans might skip Yankees tickets to watch Game 1 of the Finals.

Comedian Chris Distefano joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on WFAN for an all-time chaotic interview ahead of the NBA Finals!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the New York Knicks donating hundreds of NBA Finals tickets to underprivileged kids through the Garden of Dreams Foundation before diving into a hilarious conversation about celebrity culture at Madison Square Garden.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go completely off the rails on WFAN! The guys dive into an unbelievable story about Gladys Knight allegedly gambling away millions in Las Vegas, debate whether the “Midnight Train to Georgia” background vocals are “choo choo” or “woo woo,” and compare the Pips to the Commodores after Lionel Richie went solo.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle deliver one of the most absurd and hilarious WFAN segments yet. 😂 The guys react to a shocking French Open betting collapse after Jannik Sinner blows a match while leading 6-3, 6-2, 5-1 due to heat stroke, costing one bettor over $50K! Also an unforgettable caller interactions, an all-time WFAN caller reveals she’s married to legendary private investigator Irwin Bly — and Craig immediately wants him on the show.