The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Carton and Big Mac recount a hilarious food-related prank by Boomer Esiason before diving into a caller's frustrations regarding Mikal Bridges and the Knicks' playoff performance. They debate the future of the coaching staff, specifically highlighting why Dan Hurley would be the ideal replacement if a change is made. The segment also covers Francisco Lindor's injury status and personal stories about staying awake during late-night drives.

01:00 - Boomer's Buffet Prank

02:47 - Driving Habits and Edibles

06:00 - Knicks Playoff Struggles Analysis

09:14 - Dan Hurley Coaching Debate

15:53 - Francisco Lindor Injury Update

C-Mac and the crew analyze a chaotic night where the Knicks, Mets, and Jets all competed during a sports "witching hour." They debate who deserves the "Gas Face" for the Knicks' loss, weighing Mikal Bridges’ scoreless performance against Jalen Brunson’s late-game hero ball.

01:00 - Tongans and Mormon Missions

03:08 - Football Finger Biting Story

05:31 - Sports Witching Hour Chaos

07:15 - Witching Hour Origin Debate

09:57 - Gas Face Friday Knicks Blame

Craig and the crew analyze the Knicks' postseason performance and the frustrating rotation decisions following a tough loss to the Hawks. They also discuss the Yankees' sweep of the Red Sox while sharing stories about Villanova legends and unusual cultural traditions.

01:41 - Knicks Game Four Odds

04:42 - Yankees Sweep Red Sox

08:09 - Villanova Stars Discussion

13:35 - Knicks Coaching Critique

19:28 - Tongan History Lesson

Craig and Big Mac criticize the New York Giants for allowing Steve Tisch to appear in the draft war room given his past scandals and connection to Jeffrey Epstein. They analyze the team's draft selections, including the decision to pass on Caleb Downs for an offensive lineman. The conversation wraps up with humorous anecdotes from their post-draft party and a debate about late-night food and drinks.

01:00 - Steve Tisch Draft Room Controversy

06:15 - NFL Selective Disciplinary Actions

13:32 - Giants Draft Strategy Analysis

16:35 - Strength of Samoan Linemen

18:24 - Post-Draft Party Recap

Craig Carton and Big Mac vent over the Knicks' collapse against the Hawks and Mikal Bridges' scoreless streak. They debate the local football teams' lack of talent before Carton shares an unbelievable story about playing chess with a Cincinnati drug dealer who once traded for a missile launcher.

01:11 - Late Night Podcast Banter

02:54 - Knicks Series Frustrations

09:49 - Giants and Jets Suck

16:16 - Madden Drug House Legends

25:04 - Prison Chess Missile Story

Carton and Big Mac dissect the New York Knicks' heartbreaking playoff loss, pointing to Mikal Bridges' scoring drought as a primary factor. They transition to the NFL, evaluating the Jets' decision to draft a tight end and the Giants' selection of Arvell Reese to bolster their defense while looking ahead at Jaxson Dart.

01:00 - Knicks Playoff Struggles

13:15 - Jets Draft Review

16:12 - Giants Draft Analysis

21:11 - Mets Sports Update

The WFAN crew hosts a special draft night event, featuring live analysis of the entire first round. Listen in for instant reactions to the flurry of moves made by the Jets and Giants as both New York franchises fight to return to prominence.

It’s the ultimate New York sports gut-punch. Join the crew for a chaotic, high-energy live reaction as they navigate a brutal 3-minute sequence that every New York fan fears. From the highs of the NFL Draft to the crushing lows of a Mets blown lead and a Knicks buzzer-beater disaster, this episode captures the raw, unedited agony of being a fan in the Big Apple.

WFAN reacts to the New York Giants selecting powerhouse linebacker Arvell Reese and offensive tackle Francis Mauigoa. Amidst the cheers and Evan’s vocal "meltdown," the crew also analyzes the Dallas Cowboys’ aggressive trade-up to secure star safety Caleb Downs.

The crew reacts to the New York Jets' selection of "safe" edge rusher David Bailey at No. 2 overall while debating a bizarre theory that new defensive coordinator Brian Duker is actually an AI creation. The discussion also highlights the growing dread among New York Giants fans over the potential high-round draft of Notre Dame running back Jeremiyah Love.