The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Craig Carton and Big Mac vent over the Knicks' collapse against the Hawks and Mikal Bridges' scoreless streak. They debate the local football teams' lack of talent before Carton shares an unbelievable story about playing chess with a Cincinnati drug dealer who once traded for a missile launcher.

01:11 - Late Night Podcast Banter

02:54 - Knicks Series Frustrations

09:49 - Giants and Jets Suck

16:16 - Madden Drug House Legends

25:04 - Prison Chess Missile Story

Carton and Big Mac dissect the New York Knicks' heartbreaking playoff loss, pointing to Mikal Bridges' scoring drought as a primary factor. They transition to the NFL, evaluating the Jets' decision to draft a tight end and the Giants' selection of Arvell Reese to bolster their defense while looking ahead at Jaxson Dart.

01:00 - Knicks Playoff Struggles

13:15 - Jets Draft Review

16:12 - Giants Draft Analysis

21:11 - Mets Sports Update

The WFAN crew hosts a special draft night event, featuring live analysis of the entire first round. Listen in for instant reactions to the flurry of moves made by the Jets and Giants as both New York franchises fight to return to prominence.

It’s the ultimate New York sports gut-punch. Join the crew for a chaotic, high-energy live reaction as they navigate a brutal 3-minute sequence that every New York fan fears. From the highs of the NFL Draft to the crushing lows of a Mets blown lead and a Knicks buzzer-beater disaster, this episode captures the raw, unedited agony of being a fan in the Big Apple.

WFAN reacts to the New York Giants selecting powerhouse linebacker Arvell Reese and offensive tackle Francis Mauigoa. Amidst the cheers and Evan’s vocal "meltdown," the crew also analyzes the Dallas Cowboys’ aggressive trade-up to secure star safety Caleb Downs.

The crew reacts to the New York Jets' selection of "safe" edge rusher David Bailey at No. 2 overall while debating a bizarre theory that new defensive coordinator Brian Duker is actually an AI creation. The discussion also highlights the growing dread among New York Giants fans over the potential high-round draft of Notre Dame running back Jeremiyah Love.

Craig and Big Mac react to explosive new photos of Mike Vrabel and Diana Russini emerging just hours before the NFL Draft kicks off. They weigh the impact on the New England Patriots, debate the Giants' draft strategy, and welcome Mark Schlereth to discuss top prospects.

01:50 - Vrabel Scandal Controversy

07:23 - NFL Draft Expectations

10:03 - Mets Snap Losing Streak

13:45 - Giants Draft Strategy

17:05 - Half Gallon Milk Challenge

19:05 - Knicks Playoff Preview

24:05 - Scandal Evidence Deep-Dive

27:35 - Yankee Stadium Food News

31:50 - Giants Trade Rumors

36:05 - The Shirt Slashing Poll

40:45 - Buffet Etiquette Rules

45:15 - Life Lessons from Grandpa

51:35 - Rob Moore Wu-Tang Mystery

56:20 - Mark Schlereth Interview

01:01:55 - Jeremiah Love Analysis

01:07:05 - Mark's Career Memories

01:12:10 - The Wheel: Trivia Game

01:18:50 - Spicy Jerky Challenge

Craig and Big Mac react to the viral photos of Mike Vrabel and Diana Russini that have forced the coach to skip the final day of the NFL Draft. They weigh the Giants' draft options while bracing for a potential first-round meltdown at the station's big reunion party. The discussion also covers the Mets' bittersweet victory and a high-stakes Knicks playoff preview.

01:20 - Russini and Vrabel Scandal

11:03 - Mets Win, Lindor Injured

14:11 - Giants Draft Strategy Debate

19:37 - Massive WFAN Reunion Preview

23:36 - Affair Timeline and Fallout

29:46 - Sports Bar Watching Tips

37:26 - Knicks Statement Game Prediction

44:28 - PR Mistakes and Career Fallout

Craig and Big Mac analyze potential trade-down scenarios for the New York Giants and Jets ahead of the NFL Draft. They pivot into a lengthy debate regarding Chris McMonigle's choice of attire and the fallout from the Dianna Russini and Mike Vrabel reporting scandal. The segment wraps up with breaking news about Francisco Lindor heading to the injured list.

01:20 - NFL Draft Trade Talk

04:50 - Members Only Shirt Debate

10:54 - Giants Draft Board Analysis

15:52 - Auntie Anne's Pretzel Pass

20:45 - Buffet Etiquette And Lessons

25:15 - Russini-Vrabel Ethics Controversy

32:30 - Patriots Coaching Future Scenarios

38:20 - Pete's Haircut And Scoring

48:34 - Francisco Lindor Injury News

Mark Schlereth joins to evaluate top NFL prospects and share his own draft day memories from the University of Idaho. They analyze the devastating news regarding Francisco Lindor’s significant calf strain and the impact it has on the New York Mets' season. The conversation also features a debate over childhood drinks and the fallout from the Mike Vrabel and Diana Russini scandals.

01:20 - Rob Moore Mystery

07:59 - Diana Russini Controversy

12:52 - Yankees Sweep Sox

16:24 - Giants Draft Debate

22:48 - Shirley Temple Debate

26:30 - Mark Schlereth Interview

43:33 - Lindor Injury News