The Innovators Studio with Phil McKinney

The Failure of Innovation Journalism


Listen Later

Innovation journalism is one of the essential types of journalism in the modern world. Journalists must explain and communicate these changes when innovations and ideas emerge to the public. Innovation journalism is currently in a state of crisis, as science and technology reporters only make up a small percentage of reporters in American newspapers. Despite this fact, according to a Pew Research Center survey, more than half of Americans say they want more news about science and technology. To truly understand and grapple with our changing world, we need journalists willing to provide real insight into emerging innovations.

The Problem: Lack of Innovation Understanding

Journalists and media platforms often sensationalize innovations to increase traffic while showing prejudice towards ones they don't like. Sensationalism can distort public understanding of potentially transformative innovations, promote misinformation, and distort policymaking. Innovation journalism should be about exploring the implications of innovations and ideas while shining a light on the people making them happen.

Theranos: An Innovation Journalism Failure

The media hailed Theranos as an exciting new technology that could revolutionize the blood testing industry. Theranos' CEO, Elizabeth Holmes, was often described as the "youngest self-made billionaire," Time Magazine referred to her as "The next Steve Jobs." Eventually, The Wall Street Journal revealed that Theranos was misleading investors and patients about its technology.

Forced to shut down, Elizabeth Holmes was convicted on multiple counts of fraud. The lesson from the Theranos story is that innovation journalism needs to be more than just positive coverage of new technologies. It needs to be willing to ask tough questions and investigate claims made.

Guidelines of Good Innovation Journalism

Here are eight guidelines of good innovation journalism discussed in the podcast:

  1. Avoid Hype
  2. Seek Diverse Perspectives
  3. Consider the Implications
  4. Go Beyond the Press Release
  5. Verify The Claims
  6. Be Transparent About Your Sources
  7. Disclose Conflicts of Interest
  8. Label Opinions as Such
The Future of Innovation Journalism

If innovation journalism is to have a future, it must do several things.

  1. It must move away from its current focus on gadgetry and startups.
  2. It must embrace its role as a critical and informative force in society.
  3. It must also provide context and analysis, not just hype.
  4. It must ask hard questions and hold those in power accountable.

Only then will it be able to fulfill its potential truly. Otherwise, it risks becoming nothing more than a buzzword or an empty promise. Having accurate, transparent, and unbiased reporting on innovation can empower individuals, organizations, governments, and society to bring about positive change.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Innovators Studio with Phil McKinneyBy Phil McKinney

  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6

4.6

74 ratings


More shows like The Innovators Studio with Phil McKinney

View all
TED Talks Daily by TED

TED Talks Daily

11,165 Listeners

Motley Fool Money by The Motley Fool

Motley Fool Money

3,243 Listeners

Masters in Business by Bloomberg

Masters in Business

2,171 Listeners

Coaching for Leaders by Dave Stachowiak

Coaching for Leaders

1,477 Listeners

Pivot by New York Magazine

Pivot

9,755 Listeners

WSJ Tech News Briefing by The Wall Street Journal

WSJ Tech News Briefing

1,652 Listeners

The a16z Show by Andreessen Horowitz

The a16z Show

1,109 Listeners

HBR IdeaCast by Harvard Business Review

HBR IdeaCast

153 Listeners

Founders by David Senra

Founders

2,219 Listeners

Azeem Azhar's Exponential View by Azeem Azhar

Azeem Azhar's Exponential View

616 Listeners

Masters of Scale by WaitWhat

Masters of Scale

3,989 Listeners

Y Combinator Startup Podcast by Y Combinator

Y Combinator Startup Podcast

232 Listeners

Guy Kawasaki's Remarkable People by Guy Kawasaki

Guy Kawasaki's Remarkable People

651 Listeners

Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques by Matt Abrahams, Think Fast Talk Smart

Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques

826 Listeners

HBR On Leadership by Harvard Business Review

HBR On Leadership

168 Listeners