
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Alright gang, buckle up—because this case gets weird.
In January 1897, a young bride named Zona Heaster Shue was found dead in her rural West Virginia home. The local doctor took one look and said "heart trouble." Her husband Erasmus—who went by "Trout," which should've been everyone's first red flag—played the grieving widower perfectly. Case closed, right?
Not so fast.
Zona's mother, Mary Jane Heaster, wasn't buying it. Something about her new son-in-law just didn't sit right. So she did what any determined mother would do: she prayed for answers. For four straight weeks. And then, according to her actual sworn testimony in an actual courtroom, her daughter's ghost showed up. Four nights in a row. With receipts.
The spirit allegedly revealed that Trout had flown into a rage because dinner didn't include meat—and snapped her neck over it.
Now here's where it gets really interesting. Mary Jane took these ghostly details to prosecutor John Alfred Preston, and somehow convinced him to dig deeper. Literally. When they exhumed Zona's body, the autopsy found exactly what the ghost described: broken neck, crushed windpipe, finger marks on the throat.
Trout Shue was arrested, and what followed was one of the most bizarre trials in American legal history—the only known murder case where spectral testimony helped secure a conviction.
Jinkies.
Sources & Further Reading:
West Virginia Encyclopedia - Greenbrier Ghost
Greenbrier County Tourism - The Greenbrier Ghost
Historical Marker Database - Greenbrier Ghost
By Shane L. Waters, Joshua Waters, Kim Morrow4.2
135135 ratings
Alright gang, buckle up—because this case gets weird.
In January 1897, a young bride named Zona Heaster Shue was found dead in her rural West Virginia home. The local doctor took one look and said "heart trouble." Her husband Erasmus—who went by "Trout," which should've been everyone's first red flag—played the grieving widower perfectly. Case closed, right?
Not so fast.
Zona's mother, Mary Jane Heaster, wasn't buying it. Something about her new son-in-law just didn't sit right. So she did what any determined mother would do: she prayed for answers. For four straight weeks. And then, according to her actual sworn testimony in an actual courtroom, her daughter's ghost showed up. Four nights in a row. With receipts.
The spirit allegedly revealed that Trout had flown into a rage because dinner didn't include meat—and snapped her neck over it.
Now here's where it gets really interesting. Mary Jane took these ghostly details to prosecutor John Alfred Preston, and somehow convinced him to dig deeper. Literally. When they exhumed Zona's body, the autopsy found exactly what the ghost described: broken neck, crushed windpipe, finger marks on the throat.
Trout Shue was arrested, and what followed was one of the most bizarre trials in American legal history—the only known murder case where spectral testimony helped secure a conviction.
Jinkies.
Sources & Further Reading:
West Virginia Encyclopedia - Greenbrier Ghost
Greenbrier County Tourism - The Greenbrier Ghost
Historical Marker Database - Greenbrier Ghost

17,277 Listeners

34,486 Listeners

4,802 Listeners

960 Listeners

1,331 Listeners

6,705 Listeners

1,704 Listeners

138 Listeners

3,434 Listeners

99,457 Listeners

2,859 Listeners

2,901 Listeners

5,067 Listeners

762 Listeners

744 Listeners

272 Listeners

317 Listeners

86 Listeners

3,135 Listeners

75 Listeners

26 Listeners

61 Listeners

22 Listeners

2 Listeners

8 Listeners

3 Listeners

11 Listeners