The Litigation Psychology Podcast

The Litigation Psychology Podcast - Episode 269 - Analyzing the Path to a Recent Defense Verdict


Listen Later

Trial attorney Shane O’Dell from Naman Howell joins Bill Kanasky, Jr., Ph.D. to break down a recent case that resulted in a complete defense verdict. The case involved a homeowner being sued after a contractor’s assistant, hired informally from a parking lot, fell through an attic floor while replacing water heaters, sustaining serious injuries. Shane explains how initial assumptions about homeowner liability posed a major challenge, as jurors often believe that property owners are automatically responsible for any accidents on their premises.

Shane and Bill walk through how narrative strategy played a crucial role in the defense. Rather than opening with a sympathetic focus on the defendant, they shifted the “cognitive lens” of the jury by starting the story from the perspective of the contractor and the assistant. This reframing emphasized poor decisions made by others, redirecting initial juror blame away from the homeowner. Shane credits this approach, along with targeted voir dire questions about juror assumptions on property liability, as key to shaping juror perception from the outset. He also discusses how medical damages were dropped last-minute by the plaintiff to focus solely on non-economic damages - a move designed to avoid anchoring jurors with a high medical figure.

Shane and Bill also explore the tactical complexities faced during trial, including a non-suit of a co-defendant mid-trial and the withdrawal of damages claims just before key cross-examination, forcing rapid adjustments. Shane shares how maintaining flexibility and staying focused on the evolving trial landscape helped the defense team stay effective. Finally, the two discuss the emotional impact of a defense verdict for the client, the importance of involving young attorneys in trial work, and why mentorship, trial exposure, and civility with opposing counsel are essential for a sustainable legal career.

Watch the video of this episode:  https://www.courtroomsciences.com/r/X6E

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Litigation Psychology PodcastBy litpsych

  • 4.5
  • 4.5
  • 4.5
  • 4.5
  • 4.5

4.5

26 ratings


More shows like The Litigation Psychology Podcast

View all
WSJ What’s News by The Wall Street Journal

WSJ What’s News

4,362 Listeners

The Political Scene | The New Yorker by WNYC Studios and The New Yorker

The Political Scene | The New Yorker

3,954 Listeners

WSJ Opinion: Potomac Watch by Paul Gigot, The Wall Street Journal

WSJ Opinion: Potomac Watch

2,818 Listeners

Hidden Brain by Hidden Brain, Shankar Vedantam

Hidden Brain

43,483 Listeners

Pod Save America by Crooked Media

Pod Save America

86,750 Listeners

The Daily by The New York Times

The Daily

111,917 Listeners

Trial Lawyer Nation by Michael Cowen

Trial Lawyer Nation

186 Listeners

Strict Scrutiny by Crooked Media

Strict Scrutiny

5,687 Listeners

Politics War Room with James Carville & Al Hunt by Politicon

Politics War Room with James Carville & Al Hunt

4,047 Listeners

The Jury Is Out by TJIO

The Jury Is Out

28 Listeners

People I (Mostly) Admire by Freakonomics Radio + Stitcher

People I (Mostly) Admire

2,135 Listeners

The Ezra Klein Show by New York Times Opinion

The Ezra Klein Show

15,335 Listeners

The Lincoln Project by The Lincoln Project

The Lincoln Project

9,031 Listeners

The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart by Comedy Central

The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart

10,613 Listeners

Trial Lawyers University by Dan Ambrose, Trial Lawyers University

Trial Lawyers University

18 Listeners