When 18 year old Michelle O'Keefe was found murdered in her brand new blue Mustang, police were quick to hone in on their suspect: Raymond Jennings, a security guard working at the park and ride where her car was parked. The only problem with their theory was that none of the evidence seemed to point at Raymond. Every new stone they unturned seemed to all point away from their suspect. Despite this, police were certain they had their man.

Sources:

Who Killed Michelle O’Keefe? Teen Found Dead in Blue Mustang | Mystery | Investigation Discovery

Michelle Therese O'Keefe, 18 - The Homicide Report

Read details about the new evidence in the murder of Michelle O'Keefe - DocumentCloud

Who’s Who in The Girl in the Blue Mustang

Unmaking a Murderer? Covering the Raymond Jennings Case

Judge Throws Out Murder Conviction of Man Who Served 11 Years Behind Bars in Notorious Palmdale Killing of Teenager Michelle O’Keefe | KTLA

The Psychic Defective Revisited: Years Later, Sylvia Browne’s Accuracy Remains Dismal | Skeptical Inquirer

After a man convicted of murdering a woman goes free, questions linger over why he was charged in first place - Los Angeles Times

Dateline Originals| Season 11: The Girl in the Blue Mustang

Sponsors:

Prose! Get 50% off your first subscription and FREE consultation at Prose.com/creepers

EarnIn Download EarnIn today in the Google Play or Apple App Store! ● When you download the EarnIn app type in creepers under PODCAST when you sign up

Acorns Head to acorns.com/creepers or download the Acorns app to start saving and investing for your future today! 

Masterclass Get 15% off any annual membership at Masterclass.com/Creepers 

Mint Mobile Get your 3 month unlimited wireless plan for just $15 a month at mintmoble.com/CREEPERS

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices