The Detail

The Waitangi Tribunal's losing battle


Listen Later

What is the point of the Waitangi Tribunal if it doesn't have the power to stop a government that appears to be acting against the interests of Māori?

A fight is brewing between the government and the Waitangi Tribunal over scrapping the Māori Health Authority - but we already know who's won.

The government has gazumped the Waitangi Tribunal over its bill to get rid of the newly established Māori Health Authority - Te Aka Whai Ora.

Prime Minister Christopher Luxon announced yesterday it would act to dissolve the Authority this week.

The Tribunal can't comment on matters before Parliament, so even if it gets its urgent inquiry into the matter going swiftly, its findings won't be released before the deed is done.

But even if it had managed its urgent inquiry - would it have made any difference to the government's path?

It doesn't actually have to take any notice of the Tribunal's decisions or recommendations.

The Authority was created under Labour in the wake of another Waitangi Tribunal inquiry, WAI 2575, which found there was a need for a greater focus on Māori health equity, and that the primary health care funding model disadvantaged Māori patients.

It said the Crown had breached its Treaty obligations to design and administer a system that addressed those inequities.

One of its recommendations was the establishment of an independent Māori health authority. It was described at the time as a gamechanger for Māori.

All three parties in the new government campaigned on scrapping it.

The claim over Te Aka Whai Ora was lodged by Māori health advocates Lady Tureiti Moxon and Janice Kuka and was granted urgency.

Today on The Detail we look at the powers of the Waitangi Tribunal, the laws governing it, and what part it plays in our political debate.

We talk to Carwyn Jones (Ngāti Kahungunu), the kaihautū (director) at Te Whare Whakatupu Mātauranga at Te Wānanga o Raukawa in Ōtaki. He teaches Māori laws and philosophy.

He used to work for the Waitangi Tribunal Unit (its administration and support team), so is in a perfect position to give co-host Tom Kitchin a rundown on what the Tribunal is, and how it was set up.

"Even where the government chooses to ignore the Tribunal's findings or recommendations," he says, (it) "allows for the evidence to be put around Treaty breaches and for that to be made public, and it can provide through some of its reports a kind of persuasive political argument. The Tribunal itself is not political but it provides the kind of evidence-base, and the Treaty analysis that might allow others to pick that up and try and use it to generate some political pressure on the government."…

Go to this episode on rnz.co.nz for more details

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The DetailBy RNZ

  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7

4.7

22 ratings


More shows like The Detail

View all
Nine To Noon by RNZ

Nine To Noon

20 Listeners

Saturday Morning by RNZ

Saturday Morning

42 Listeners

Sunday Morning by RNZ

Sunday Morning

12 Listeners

Business News by RNZ

Business News

7 Listeners

Focus on Politics by RNZ

Focus on Politics

11 Listeners

Mediawatch by RNZ

Mediawatch

14 Listeners

Parliament - Live Stream and Question Time by RNZ

Parliament - Live Stream and Question Time

3 Listeners

Pacific Waves by RNZ

Pacific Waves

12 Listeners

News in Pacific Languages by RNZ

News in Pacific Languages

1 Listeners

Tagata o te Moana by RNZ

Tagata o te Moana

1 Listeners

Gone By Lunchtime by The Spinoff

Gone By Lunchtime

24 Listeners

The House by RNZ

The House

1 Listeners

The Mike Hosking Breakfast by Newstalk ZB

The Mike Hosking Breakfast

52 Listeners

The Front Page by NZ Herald

The Front Page

13 Listeners

Rural News by RNZ

Rural News

1 Listeners

Between Two Beers Podcast by Steven Holloway & Seamus Marten

Between Two Beers Podcast

119 Listeners

Shared Lunch by Sharesies

Shared Lunch

12 Listeners

Kiwi Yarns by Stuff | Brodie Kane Media

Kiwi Yarns

24 Listeners

When the Facts Change by The Spinoff

When the Facts Change

9 Listeners

World & Pacific News by RNZ

World & Pacific News

0 Listeners

Grey Areas with Petra Bagust by rova | Love It Media

Grey Areas with Petra Bagust

22 Listeners

ICYMI by RNZ

ICYMI

0 Listeners

RNZ News by RNZ

RNZ News

3 Listeners

The Little Things by NZ Herald

The Little Things

7 Listeners

30 with Guyon Espiner by RNZ

30 with Guyon Espiner

7 Listeners

Making Cents by Frances Cook

Making Cents

12 Listeners