We’re in the most intense stretch of the Christian story, moving from the table to the tomb! Peter Walsh, Elizabeth Garnsey, and John Kennedy unpack the shock of Maundy Thursday’s foot washing, the raw exposure of Good Friday, the silence of Holy Saturday, and the strange, luminous hope of Easter’s first light. Along the way, they wrestle with power and love, guilt and transformation, and what it really means to be human in the shadow of the cross.

Holy Land clips from this episode:
The Upper Room
Gethsemane

Questions for Further Discussion

Themes and Application

1. What does Jesus’ act of foot washing reveal about the nature of God and leadership in the Christian life? How does it challenge our assumptions about power and status? 
2. What does it mean to say that the crucifixion is both a revelation of God and a mirror held up to humanity? 
3. What role does silence play in the Triduum, especially on Holy Saturday? How might embracing silence deepen faith or awareness of God? 

Personal Reflection

1. When have you struggled to “stay awake” in a moment that required presence, courage, or faithfulness? What does that reveal about your own spiritual life? 
2. How do you personally respond to suffering—your own or others’? Does the cross offer you more consolation, challenge, or both? 
3. What does “It is finished” mean to you—completion, surrender, victory, or something else? 

Broader Spiritual Considerations 

1. The podcast suggests that Jesus came not to create a new religion but a new humanity. How do you respond to that idea? 
2. How can the cross function as both consolation (God with us in suffering) and challenge (calling us to transformation)? 
3. What is the significance of the resurrection being a real, historical claim versus a symbolic or spiritual truth? How does that affect belief and practice? 

Learn more about St. Mark's at https://www.stmarksnewcanaan.org