On the morning of Sunday July 20th, 2025, a fishing trip off the coast of Anna Maria Island turned into a nightmare. Douglas Scot Naeher, 60, allegedly attempted to murder his wife during an escalating boat confrontation roughly 33 miles offshore from Bean Point. With no one close enough to hear her scream, she fought back. This case is an incredible story of survival and the determination to live.

Join the MacArthur's for the unfiltered, unedited, and unhinged discussion on this case. These are the conversations we used to have after we hit stop. Only now we keep recording. The banter is about to get a little more interesting and even more dysfunctional. Listen at your own risk.

*Skip the foreplay- around the 11:00 marker. This is a guesstimation due to ad placement. Gotta make that coin!

In 1991, 22-year-old security guard Bryan Ruff vanished from his post at a Utah mine called The Kennecott Copper Mine. Eighteen months later his body was found- shot and buried in the desert. It would take over a decade, a second murder, and a forensic breakthrough to link a suspect to the crime. Was Bryan murdered by someone close to home? Or was Bryan hiding a secret that would eventually cost him his life? Listen and find out.

Meet our podcast friend Debby, who weekly takes us into the classroom as she discusses a true crime case or topic. True Crime University concentrates on the psychology of criminal behavior and offender profiling.

Warning: Adult language and content; listener discretion is advised.

Season 3, Episode 10: Lesson- Gender and Crime

In this short lesson we discuss the differences between males and females in crime and criminal behavior.

From haunted hospitals and outlaw theatres to growling desert domes, Arizona is crawling with ghosts who never got the memo to move on. In this episode Melissa dives into the top 10 most haunted locations across the desert state. You'll laugh, you'll scream, and you definitely won't be checking into room 242.

Meet our friends Sarah and Megan. The amazing and hilarious hosts of It's Always the Husband.

This episode is one of Sarah's favorite Forensic Files ever, called Slippery Motives. when an "elite runner" takes his wife on a business vacation, all hell breaks loose. Towel racks, inappropriate sexual advances at funerals, piss-poor burials, The Book of Who Cares, and prosecutors with hot buns make this episode a delight. We hope you hate Ed Post as much as we do! If you do, please rate us 5 stars on Apple Podcasts! Don't forget to subscribe! Theme song by Jaime Nelson

When 33-year-old Katlyn Harp vanished after a final phone call with her sister, her disappearance raised more questions than answers. days later, her body was found sealed inside a green metal box- hidden in the woods. Her husband, Vincent Harp is now charged with her murder. In this episode Melissa unpacks the chilling investigation, digital clues, and the sister who wouldn't stop searching.

Also, Melissa gives an update on the case out of Australia. The Death Cap Mushroom Murders. The verdict is in. Was Erin Patterson found guilty? Or did the jury believe it was all an accident?

*Remember, opinions are like buttholes; everybody has one and they all stink!

Join us for the unfiltered and unedited discussion on the case. These are the conversations we used to have after we hit stop. Only now we keep recording. The banter is about to get a little more interesting and even more dysfunctional. Listen at your own risk.

**Skip the foreplay around the 10:00 mark. This is a rough guesstimation due to ad placement.

Two women. Two vans. Two violent endings.

In this episode, Melissa tells Daniel the haunting similarities between the chilling case of Emily Ferlazzo and the high-profile murder of Gabby Petito. Young women who set out on road trips with the men they loved... and never made it home.

Gabby's disappearance in 2021 launched a nationwide manhunt, viral TikTok's and headlines around the world. Just 2 months later, Emily Ferlazzo was killed in an eerily similar scenario: a van trip turned fatal and a shocking confession.

What do these cases have in common? And how many more stories like this never make the news?

Meet our friends Neil and Megan from Mortal Musings. Coming all the way at you from across the pond. Another true crime couple for you to adore.

In today's episode we are discussing Omaima Nelson and the extremely brutal murder of Bill Nelson. This is a case that involves compassion for the difficulties that Omaima faced in her life, without attempting to diminish the severity of the crime. Our oddity is the story of Florida man's ferocious sneezes.