Total Conundrum

At just seven years old, Steven Stayner was taken while walking home from school—beginning a seven-year nightmare that would shock the nation.

But this isn’t just a story about abduction.

It’s a story about survival… resilience… and a decision that would turn a victim into a hero.

In this episode, we follow Steven’s journey from captivity to escape—and the incredible moment where, instead of running alone, he chose to save another child.

But survival doesn’t mean everything goes back to normal…

We also explore what happened after he returned home—the emotional aftermath, the struggles he faced, and how his story impacted not just him, but his entire family.

This is one of the most powerful and heartbreaking true crime stories we’ve ever covered.

And it’s only half of the Stayner story.

Enjoyed the episode? Show us some love!

Submit a story at https://www.totalconundrum.com/contact

Watch & Listen Everywhere:

Follow Us for More Creepy Content:

Want to be featured as a sponsor? Email: [email protected]

If you’re into true crime, the supernatural, and the unexplained… you’re in the right place.

What happens when you invite experienced paranormal investigators onto your show… and then the power suddenly goes out during the recording?

Enjoyed the episode? Show us some love!

Submit a story at https://www.totalconundrum.com/contact

Special Guests: Rob Gutro — Paranormal Investigator / Author / Medium

Website: https://robgutro.com

Special Guests: Monique Too Soon — Paranormal Investigator / Researcher

Watch & Listen Everywhere:

Follow Us for More Creepy Content:

Want to be featured as a sponsor? Email: [email protected]

Today we sit down with the incomparable Kelly Blackheart — also known as Kelly Zabielski — whose journey is nothing short of fearless, hilarious, and wildly inspiring.

Kelly has lived multiple lives: from playing collegiate volleyball to working in renewable-energy finance, to acting in commercials and appearing on MTV… all before pivoting hard into comedy and podcasting.

She walks us through her time producing and appearing on The Jim Jefferies Podcast, working behind the scenes on I Don’t Know About That with Jim Jefferies, and hosting her longtime show The Unsolicited Podcast.

We also dive into her deeply personal journey as an egg donor, helping families grow and discovering new parts of herself along the way.

And of course — we talk about her newest creative adventure:

This episode is full of big laughs, real talk, and the kind of heartfelt detours that make Kelly who she is. Buckle up, Conundrum Crew — this one’s a ride.

Enjoyed the episode? Show us some love!

Submit a story at https://www.totalconundrum.com/contact

Watch & Listen Everywhere:

Follow Us for More Creepy Content:

Want to be featured as a sponsor? Email: [email protected]

Be sure to check out Kelly’s incredible work and her new show with DJ Qualls!

This week on Total Conundrum, we sit down with Minnesota author Patrick W. Marsh, creator of The Greenland Diaries series and a master of monsters both real and symbolic.

We dive into:

If you love dark fantasy, indie authors, or the weird, wild mysteries of the Midwest… this one’s for you, Conundrum Crew.

Enjoyed the episode? Show us some love!

Submit a story at https://www.totalconundrum.com/contact

Watch & Listen Everywhere:

Follow Us for More Creepy Content:

Want to be featured as a sponsor? Email: [email protected]

Special Guest: Patrick W. Marsh — Minnesota Author & Creator of The Greenland Diaries

Be sure to check out Patrick’s incredible monster-filled worlds and his ongoing book series!

Tonight, we’re taking you straight into one of the most haunted houses in America — The Oman House, perched just steps from the infamous Sharon Tate murder site on Cielo Drive. We’re joined by paranormal investigator and homeowner David Oman, who’s spent over two decades documenting and living among intense supernatural phenomena.

David spills behind-the-scenes secrets from shows like Ghost Adventures, Ghost Hunters, and Paranormal Witness. From full-body apparitions and ghostly footsteps to energy spikes and unexplained voices — he’s seen it all. And now, so will you.

Pull up a seat at the séance table, Conundrum Crew — this one’s got ghost tech, Hollywood gossip, and bone-chilling banter.

Enjoyed the episode? Show us some love!

Like, comment, and share with your weirdest friend.

Submit a story at https://www.totalconundrum.com/contact

Watch & Listen Everywhere:

Follow Us for More Creepy Content:

Want to be featured as a sponsor? Email: [email protected]

In this transformative episode of Total Conundrum, we welcome Deborah Roque—a medium, healer, and the visionary behind Paranormal Paradigma. With over 20 years in education and a lifetime of spiritual experiences, Deborah shares how she transitioned from academia to spirit work, what it’s like to collaborate with Spirit Guides, and how we can all begin to shift our understanding of the paranormal from fear to empowerment.

She dives deep into the process of mediumship, the emotional impact of healing sessions, and the universal patterns she sees in spiritual awakening. Whether you’re a believer, a skeptic, or somewhere in between, this episode will open your mind and maybe even your heart.

Grief, guidance, and ghostly connections await.

Enjoyed the episode? Show us some love!

Submit a story at https://www.totalconundrum.com/contact

Watch & Listen Everywhere:

Follow Us for More Creepy Content:

Want to be featured as a sponsor? Email: [email protected]

Grab your favorite salt rounds and a flask of vampire blood, Conundrum Crew — because this week, Jeremy and Traci sit down with the legendary Ty Olsson!

You know him as Benny Lafitte from Supernatural, Niko Zimmer from The 100, and the unforgettable Original Dragon from Dragon Tales (yes, seriously — that’s range!).

Ty opens up about life behind the camera, hilarious on-set moments, the wild world of conventions, and how his fans have become one big extended family. You’ll laugh, you’ll feel all the fandom feels, and maybe even question whether Benny really deserved a better ending .

If you’re part of the SPN Family, a sci-fi junkie, or just love a good behind-the-scenes story told with humor and heart — this episode’s for you.

So, sit back, grab your holy water (or whiskey — we don’t judge), and join us as we go from Supernatural to The 100 and beyond with the one and only Ty Olsson!

Submit a story at https://www.totalconundrum.com/contact

Watch & Listen Everywhere:

Follow Us for More Creepy Content:

Want to be featured as a sponsor? Email: [email protected]

In this chilling and heartwarming episode of Total Conundrum, Jeremy and Traci welcome Rob Gutro — medium, paranormal researcher, and author of several books on spirits and the afterlife. Rob has a unique gift: he communicates not only with human spirits, but also with pets who’ve crossed over.

GUEST INFORMATION

In this extra-special crossover, we’re teaming up with T.W.A.T.S. (The Wisconsin Apparition Tracking Society) and our paranormal podcast friends over at I Scream You Scream to bring you a chilling and hilarious deep dive into one of America’s first documented spirit possession cases — the infamous Roff House in Watseka, Illinois.

We unpack the eerie legacy of Lurancy Vennum and Mary Roff, chat about our time inside the haunted home, and hear firsthand accounts from T.W.A.T.S. and I Scream, You Scream Podcast’s unforgettable investigation. Plus: audio evidence, spine-tingling moments, and, of course, signature banter and belly laughs.

If you love haunted history, real ghost investigations, and podcasters who aren’t afraid to scream a little — this one’s for you.

Follow Us for More Creepy Content:

GUEST INFORMATION

Be sure to check out T.W.A.T.S.’ chilling investigation of the Roff House, and explore even more haunted hilarity with I Scream You Scream!

CALL-TO-ACTION

Submit a story at https://www.totalconundrum.com/contact

SPONSORS / AFFILIATE LINKS