Total Conundrum

This week, we’re teaming up with our creepy-cool neighbor from Wisconsin — Star from Creepy Shit Podcast! She’s joining us to share her favorite kind of nightmare fuel: the chilling history and hauntings of Poveglia Island, Italy’s most cursed speck of land.

We dive into the dark past of plague pits, tortured souls, and paranormal investigations that went very, very wrong. Star brings her signature storytelling, chilling details, and killer vibes to this haunted collab.

Plus! We play a few rounds of Paranormal Would You Rather and learn more about how Star became the queen of creepy content.

Enjoyed the episode? Show us some love!

Watch & Listen Everywhere:

Follow Us for More Creepy Content:

Want to be featured as a sponsor? Email: [email protected]

What do Al Capone’s ghost, a raincoat raft, and a haunted prison hospital have in common?

They’re all part of the chilling history of Alcatraz—“The Rock.”

Join Traci & Jeremy as they dive into the eerie past and lingering paranormal of America’s most infamous prison. From failed escapes and ghost banjos to cold spots in solitary confinement, this episode delivers hardcore history with haunted hilarity.

We’re talking real inmate stories, the Battle of Alcatraz, and ghost-hunting evidence that’ll make you question what’s still lurking behind those bars.

Riots. Ghosts. Great escapes.

Enjoyed the episode? Show us some love!

Submit a story at https://www.totalconundrum.com/contact

Watch & Listen Everywhere:

Follow Us for More Creepy Content:

Want to be featured as a sponsor? Email: [email protected]

In 1982, a wave of terror swept across Chicago—not with a gun or a knife, but with something found in nearly every medicine cabinet: Tylenol. In this emotionally charged deep-dive, Traci and Jeremy walk through the heartbreaking, minute-by-minute unfolding of the Tylenol murders.

Enjoyed the episode? Show us some love!

Submit a story at https://www.totalconundrum.com/contact

Watch & Listen Everywhere:

Join us as we talk with Dave from Midwest Spirit Seekers — one of the most passionate and experienced paranormal investigators in the Midwest! In this episode, we explore haunted locations, discuss the most effective paranormal equipment, and hear about some truly spine-tingling experiences.

Dave opens up about the realities of ghost hunting, from eerie voices caught on tape to mysterious shadows caught on camera. We also dig into what it really takes to be a modern spirit seeker — and share plenty of laughs along the way.

Don’t forget to like, subscribe, and hit the bell so you never miss an episode!

Listen now and tell us: Do you believe?

Watch & Listen Everywhere:

Follow Us for More Creepy Content:

#MidwestSpiritSeekers #ParanormalPodcast #GhostHunting #TotalConundrum

In 1903, the quiet little town of Van Meter, Iowa, got a visit from something strange — an eight-foot, bat-winged, bulletproof, sulfur-smelling nightmare with a glowing horn. And no, this isn’t a rejected Marvel villain.

Jeremy and Traci dig into one of Iowa’s strangest cryptid tales — The Van Meter Visitor. From eyewitness accounts and old newspaper articles, to modern investigations, DNA tests on fur, and Expedition X’s field work — this story has it all. Was it a cryptid? An alien? A prehistoric throwback? Or just a big mosquito that took CrossFit too seriously?

Grab your pitchforks, your popcorn, and maybe some Febreze, because this one is equal parts creepy and hilarious.

CALL-TO-ACTION

Follow Us for More Creepy Content:

Contact: [email protected]

Description:

In this episode, Jeremy and Traci dig deep into the haunting details of the case — from the chilling surveillance footage and mysterious LinkedIn messages to the long list of theories and suspects. Was this a targeted attack? A personal grudge? A stalker? Or a meticulously planned professional hit?

We break down the evidence, explore theories, and share updates on the investigation — including the $150,000 reward still on the table. This case is as puzzling as it is tragic, and nearly a decade later, it remains unsolved.

Listen in as we discuss:

Join the Conundrum Crew:

If you have credible information:

Submit a story at https://www.totalconundrum.com/contact

#MissyBevers #TrueCrimePodcast #ColdCase #UnsolvedMystery #TotalConundrumPodcast #JusticeForMissy #TrueCrimeCommunity #PodcastEpisode

Description:

No adults saw it. But the kids’ stories matched — right down to the smallest details. Harvard psychiatrist Dr. John Mack flew in to investigate, and what he found would make even hardened skeptics pause.

In this episode of Total Conundrum, Jeremy and Traci dig deep into one of the most compelling mass UFO encounters in history — from the strange landing and telepathic messages to the decades-later interviews that prove these witnesses never forgot what they saw.

What We Cover:

Join the Conundrum Crew as we revisit a case that asks: What happens when the only witnesses are children — and they all agree on what they saw?

Watch & Listen Everywhere:

Follow Us for More Creepy Content:

Submit a story at https://www.totalconundrum.com/contact

He was just eight years old when he killed for the first time… and no one noticed.

In this episode of Total Conundrum, Jeremy and Traci unravel the disturbing life of Carroll Edward Cole, a serial killer whose crimes went undetected for decades—despite confessions, hospital warnings, and chilling early behavior. From his traumatic childhood and early acts of violence, to the series of murders he claimed were part of a “moral mission,” Cole’s story is one of systemic failure, shocking misdiagnoses, and missed opportunities.

In this episode:

Stick around to the end for a tease of next week’s episode: The Ariel School UFO Incident, one of the most credible mass alien sightings ever recorded.

Got a weird hometown mystery? Visit us at totalconundrum.com or message us on socials—we love creepy listener stories!

In this chilling deep dive, Jeremy and Traci unravel one of America’s strangest and most documented cases of spirit possession: the story of Lurancy Vennum and Mary Roff, known as the Watseka Wonder.

We journey through the quiet streets of 19th-century Watseka, Illinois, into the lives of two families connected by tragedy, belief, and the beyond. From Lurancy’s terrifying seizures and trance states to the eerie return of Mary Roff’s spirit — and the emotional testing that convinced a grieving family they had their daughter back.

We also explore the haunting legacy of the Roff House itself, now an Airbnb where guests continue to report chilling encounters. Plus, modern investigations, séances, and what it means to be “possessed” — both then and now.

Are these echoes of grief, spiritual miracles… or something darker still lingering in the hallways?

Love this eerie journey?

Episode Title: The Butcher of Plainfield: Ed Gein’s Twisted Legacy – with John from Dairyland Frights

Episode Description:

This week on Total Conundrum, we’re digging up one of the darkest and most disturbing tales in true crime history: the story of Ed Gein — the real-life inspiration behind horror icons like Norman Bates, Leatherface, and Buffalo Bill. Joining us is John from Dairyland Frights, Wisconsin’s own master of the macabre, to walk us through the chilling case of the infamous “Butcher of Plainfield.”

Together, we unravel the twisted secrets buried in Gein’s farmhouse, explore the psychological torment that drove his grotesque acts, and take a fresh look at the crimes that shocked a nation. John brings his unique storytelling flair and bone-chilling detail to help us peel back the skin of the legend—quite literally.

Warning: This episode isn’t for the faint of heart. But if you love true crime, horror history, and a touch of the supernatural, you’re in for one gruesome ride.

#EdGein #TrueCrimePodcast #HorrorInspiredByTruth #DairylandFrights #TotalConundrum #SerialKillers #TrueCrimeCommunity #ButcherOfPlainfield #HorrorOrigins #PodcastCollab #CreepyHistory #TrueCrimeObsessed #GraveRobber #Psycho #TexasChainsawMassacre