Sign up to save your podcasts
Or
Share Total Conundrum
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Or
Total Conundrum
Total Conundrum episodes
- Episode 56 - Wanted for 18 Years: Unmasking John List
He left the lights on, the radio playing hymns, and walked out of his New Jersey mansion like nothing happened. But inside that house? A scene so disturbing it shocked the nation.
In this killer crossover with ZachSolved Mysteries, we unravel the chilling story of John List — the devout Lutheran who methodically murdered his entire family, disappeared without a trace, and evaded capture for nearly two decades by assuming a brand-new identity.We cover:The premeditated planningThe crime scene detailsHow he stayed hidden for 18 yearsHis “new life” as Bob ClarkThe America’s Most Wanted breakthroughHis trial and twisted justification…and all the weird, wild twists in between.Total Conundrum meets ZachSolved Mysteries — it’s double the danger, double the dark humor, and double the detective work. Let’s get into it.Be sure to like, follow, and subscribe so you don’t miss future collabs, crimes, or cursed content.Got theories or a spooky hometown story? Drop it at totalconundrum.com or hit us up on the socials.#JohnList#TrueCrimePodcast#SolvedMysteries#TotalConundrum#TrueCrimeCommunity#FamilyAnnihilator#ColdCaseSolved#CrimeDocumentary#PodcastCollab#TrueCrimeYouTube#UnsolvedMystery#DarkHistory#TrueCrimeObsessed#CrimeStories#KillerNextDoor1 hr 48 min - Episode 55 - The Haunting of Fox Hollow Farm | Serial Killer Meets Haunted House
What happens when a suburban dad turns serial killer… and his house refuses to forget?
Welcome to Fox Hollow Farm — part true crime, part paranormal nightmare.In this spine-chilling episode of Total Conundrum, Traci and Jeremy dive into the dual life of Herb Baumeister, a respected businessman who hid a dark secret behind the doors of his Indiana mansion. From mannequins by the pool to ghost voices and wet footprints, this isn’t just another murder case — it’s a lingering haunting.
We cover:
Herb’s disturbing double lifeThe I-70 Strangler connectionThe one man who escaped — Tony HarrisThe paranormal aftermath (Ghost Adventures & beyond)Ongoing discoveries of human remains — as recent as 2024Real horror. Real hauntings. With your favorite dark-humor duo to guide you through it.
Subscribe, rate, and review to support the show!
Got a haunted story or episode idea? Hit us up at https://totalconundrum.comDon’t forget to like & smash that notification bell so you never miss a creepy drop!
Watch & Listen Everywhere:
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@TotalConundrumPatreon: https://www.patreon.com/TotalConundrum1Bonfire Merch: https://www.bonfire.com/store/total-conundrum/Follow Us for More Creepy Content:
Website: https://totalconundrum.com/Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/total_conundrum/Twitter/X: https://x.com/Total_ConundrumFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/TotalConundrumTikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@totalconundrumHashtags:
#FoxHollowFarm #HerbBaumeister #TrueCrimePodcast #HauntedHouse #ParanormalPodcast #I70Strangler #GhostAdventures #CreepyMannequins #HauntedIndiana #TotalConundrum42 min - Episode 54 - THE BELL WITCH – AMERICA’S MOST TERRIFYING HAUNTING
A ghost that talks. A curse that kills. A legend that refuses to die.
In this episode, we dive deep into the terrifying true story of the Bell Witch—the entity that haunted a Tennessee family in the early 1800s, whispered their secrets, attacked them in their sleep, and may have even murdered John Bell Sr.
We cover:
The eerie beginnings – How the Bell family became America’s most haunted household.The ghost that spoke – A spirit that didn’t just haunt… it had a voice.A deadly curse? – Did the Bell Witch really kill John Bell?Andrew Jackson vs. the Witch – The U.S. President who fled the farm in terror.The haunted cave – Why visitors today STILL report strange encounters.And, of course, the chilling Kate Batts connection. Was she the vengeful spirit? Or was the Bell Witch something even darker?
Listen now… if you dare.
Tag a friend who’d never survive this haunting.#BellWitch #HauntedHistory #GhostStories #Podcast #Paranormal #TrueCrime #Supernatural #Horror
Watch & Listen Everywhere:YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@TotalConundrumPatreon: https://www.patreon.com/TotalConundrum1Bonfire Merch: https://www.bonfire.com/store/total-conundrum/Follow Us for More Creepy Content:
Website: https://totalconundrum.com/Instagram: @Total_ConundrumTwitter/X: @Total_ConundrumFacebook: @TotalConundrum37 min - Episode 53 - Cry Little Sister No More: G Tom Mac Unplugged & Unfiltered
“Vampire Anthems & Rock Operas with G Tom Mac”
Episode Summary:In this electrifying episode of Total Conundrum, we’re joined by the legendary G Tom Mac—the voice, the mind, and the creative force behind Cry Little Sister, the haunting anthem that defined The Lost Boys. But his story doesn’t stop there. From working with KISS and Roger Daltrey to being sampled by Eminem on a Grammy-winning album, Gerard McMahon’s career is a genre-defying ride through rock, soul, and cinematic sound.
We talk about:
• His early self-taught days on guitar and piano• The story behind Cry Little Sister and its lasting legacy• Writing “Is That You?” for KISS—and the wild Duluth inspiration behind it• Collaborating with Corey Haim and creating Vamp Radio• His Lost Boys rock opera prequel and the upcoming musical Don’t You Forget About Me• The upcoming documentary How Did I Get Here• What it’s like to have his work covered by artists like Marilyn Manson and CHVRCHESThis episode is packed with behind-the-scenes stories, inspiration, and vampire vibes you don’t want to miss.
• Official Website – GTomMac.com• Spotify Artist Page• YouTube Channel• Instagram• Twitter / X• Apple Music• A Lost Boys Story – Musical PageWatch & Listen Everywhere:
YouTube: Subscribe HerePatreon: Support & Get Exclusive ContentBonfire Merch: Grab Your Conundrum Crew Gear!Follow Us for More Creepy Content:
Website: https://totalconundrum.com/Instagram: @Total_ConundrumTwitter/X: @Total_ConundrumFacebook: @TotalConundrum1 hr 7 min - Episode 52 - The Lost Boy: Jamison Newlander Talks Blood, Bites & Behind-the-Scenes
Total Conundrum x Jamison Newlander: The Frog Brother Files
Episode Summary:
This week, we sit down with the iconic Jamison Newlander, better known as Alan Frog from the cult classic The Lost Boys! Jamison gives us a peek behind the scenes of vampire hunting in the ‘80s, what it was like working alongside the Coreys, and how the film continues to influence fans and pop culture nearly 40 years later.But Jamison is far more than a Frog Brother. He’s a multi-talented actor, director, playwright, and creator with a wicked sense of humor. We dive into his creative process, his passion projects (including his award-winning play Remember This), and his ghost-hunting adventures with Corey Feldman featured on Corey’s YouTube channel.
Oh yeah—we totally asked if he’d go ghost hunting with us. You know we had to.
In This Episode:
• Behind the scenes of The Lost Boys and becoming a cult horror icon• Reuniting with Corey Feldman for conventions and spooky explorations• Jamison’s journey into writing, filmmaking, and theater• His hilarious encounters with fans, vampires, and the paranormal• A discussion on legacy, creativity, and chasing weirdness with purposeBonus Moments You’ll Love:
• Jamison on ghost hunting and whether he’d join the Total Conundrum crew for a paranormal investigation• His new project – Lost Locations, revisiting filming locations in Santa Cruise• His other YouTube adventures—equal parts spooky, funny, and insightfulFollow Jamison Newlander:
• Website: https://www.jamisonnewlander.com• YouTube: The Jamison Newlander Channel• Instagram: @jamisonnewlander• Facebook: Jamison Newlander• Twitter/X: @JamisonNewland• Linktree: Linktree• The Frog Sisters Audition Tape: The Frog Sisters Audition Tape• The Frog Bros Ghost Hunting Adventure: The Frog Bros Ghost HuntDon’t Forget to Subscribe!
Leave us a review, follow us on socials, and check out our YouTube for video content and bonus reels from this episode.Total Conundrum—your one-stop shop for all things weird, wicked, and wildly entertaining.2 hr 36 min - Episode 51 - Sarah Goode: A Night Out Turned Nightmare
Episode Description:
In the quiet town of Medford, New York, 21-year-old Sarah Goode was a devoted young mother, full of laughter, promise, and love. When she disappeared after a night out in June of 2014, her friends and family knew something was wrong. What followed was a desperate search, a devastating discovery, and a heartbreaking trial that would expose a predator hiding in plain sight.
In this emotional and powerful episode of Total Conundrum, we tell Sarah’s story—not just the crime, but her life, her legacy, and the people who continue to honor her. From childhood memories and her deep bond with her daughter Jocelyn, to the haunting forensic trail that led to her killer, this is a case that will stay with you long after the episode ends.
Inside this episode, we cover:
Sarah’s early life, motherhood, and deep bond with best friend Nicole Lucas
The night she disappeared and the panic that followedThe shocking discovery of her car—and what police found nearbyThe forensic evidence that brought justiceThe courtroom showdown and the judge’s chilling wordsThe complicated aftermath of Dante Taylor’s prison death and lawsuitA heartfelt tribute to Sarah’s legacy and the loved ones who still fight for her memoryThis episode was recommended by listener Summer Rain. Thank you for helping us share Sarah’s story with care and compassion.
Watch & Listen Everywhere:YouTube: Subscribe Here
Patreon: Support & Get Exclusive ContentBonfire Merch: Grab Your Conundrum Crew Gear!Follow Us for More Creepy Content:
Website: https://totalconundrum.com/
Instagram: @Total_ConundrumTwitter/X: @Total_ConundrumFacebook: @TotalConundrum#SarahGoode #TotalConundrum #JusticeForSarah #TrueCrimePodcast #MedfordNY #DanteTaylor #TrueCrimeCommunity #RememberHerName #ConundrumCrew40 min - Episode 50 - Island of the Dolls
Episode Description:
Deep in the ancient canals of Xochimilco, Mexico, lies a place unlike any other. Trees filled with hundreds—if not thousands—of decaying, glassy-eyed dolls sway in the breeze. Their cracked faces stare into nothing… or maybe right into your soul.
This isn’t the set of a horror film. It’s real. And the story behind it is even more disturbing.
In this episode of Total Conundrum, we take you to the infamous Island of the Dolls, where legend and reality collide. Who was Don Julián Santana? What really happened to the little girl he believed drowned near his island? And how did this isolated man’s obsession turn into one of the creepiest destinations in the world?
Inside this episode, we cover:
The mysterious origin story of the Island and the girl who supposedly drowned
Don Julián’s reclusive life and his descent into paranoia—or spiritual duty?The chilling collection of dolls he hung to appease spiritsParanormal activity reported by tourists and investigatorsA visit from the Ghost Adventures team and their creepy findingsWhy this island became a cultural icon and haunted tourist hotspotBonus segments like Haunted Yelp Reviews, Red Flags: Paranormal Edition, and a special appearance by Winkers McCreepsFrom true legend to terrifying lore, this is a journey you won’t forget.
Some spirits move on. Others hang around… suspended from trees.
Watch & Listen Everywhere:
YouTube: Subscribe Here
Patreon: Support & Get Exclusive ContentBonfire Merch: Grab Your Conundrum Crew Gear!Follow Us for More Creepy Content:
Website: https://totalconundrum.com/
Instagram: @Total_ConundrumTwitter/X: @Total_ConundrumFacebook: @TotalConundrum#IslandOfTheDolls #TotalConundrum #HauntedDolls #ParanormalPodcast #CreepyTravel #XochimilcoHaunting #GhostAdventures #WinkersMcCreeps #Episode50 #TrueCrimeAndCreeps46 min - Episode 49 - The Denver Spiderman: Theodore Edward Coneys’ Secret Life of Horror
Episode Description:
You’ve heard of Spider-Man—but this isn’t a story about a hero. This is the disturbing true tale of Theodore Edward Coneys, a man who became known as “The Denver Spiderman” after committing a grisly murder and secretly living in his victim’s attic for months without detection.Why did he do it? How did no one know he was there? And how did this urban legend come to life in 1940s Denver?In this episode, we unravel the bizarre and bone-chilling case of a man who hid in the shadows—literally—and became part of one of Denver’s most infamous crimes.Inside this episode, we cover:
The troubled early life of Theodore Coneys and how illness and isolation shaped himThe shocking murder of Philip Peters in his own homeHow Coneys lived undetected in a tiny attic crawlspace for five weeksThe investigation, the strange occurrences that baffled police, and how he was finally caughtThe public reaction and how the case became an urban legend and media sensationWhy Coneys became known as “The Spider Man of Denver” and how this case still haunts true crime historySometimes, the real horror isn’t what’s outside your home—it’s what’s hiding inside.Watch & Listen Everywhere:
YouTube: Subscribe HerePatreon: Support & Get Exclusive ContentBonfire Merch: Grab Your Conundrum Crew Gear!Follow Us for More Creepy Content:
Website: https://totalconundrum.com/Instagram: @Total_ConundrumTwitter/X: @Total_ConundrumFacebook: @TotalConundrum#DenverSpiderman #TotalConundrum #TrueCrimePodcast #AtticMurder #CreepyCrimes #WeirdHistory #KillerInTheHouse #UrbanLegends #SpiderManOfDenver #RealCrimeStories
42 min - Episode 48 - Waverly Hills Sanatorium: The Most Haunted Place in America
Episode Description:
Step inside the decaying halls of Waverly Hills Sanatorium, one of the most infamous haunted locations in America. From its origins as a state-of-the-art tuberculosis hospital to the dark urban legends that grew after its closure, Waverly Hills has a history steeped in suffering, death, and mystery.What really went on inside those walls? Are the spirits of former patients still lingering? And what about the Creeper, the Body Chute, and the nurse of Room 502?In this episode, we take you deep into the true history and paranormal stories of Waverly Hills—from tragic medical treatments to modern-day ghost hunts.Inside this episode, we cover:
The origins of Waverly Hills and the town it was built inThe rise of tuberculosis (The White Plague) and why Waverly was neededGruesome and experimental medical treatments used on patientsThe story behind the Body Chute (Death Tunnel)Infamous ghost stories: Room 502, The Creeper, Timmy & the Rolling BallParanormal investigations, EVPs, and pop culture influenceThe urban legends before Waverly—missing settlers, ghostly figures, and cursed landHaunted history has never been this chilling. Listen now—if you dare.Watch & Listen Everywhere:
YouTube: Subscribe HerePatreon: Support & Get Exclusive ContentBonfire Merch: Grab Your Conundrum Crew Gear!Follow Us for More Creepy Content:
Website: https://totalconundrum.com/Instagram: @Total_ConundrumTwitter/X: @Total_ConundrumFacebook: @TotalConundrum#WaverlyHills #HauntedHistory #TotalConundrum #GhostStories #TrueHaunting #ParanormalPodcast #CreeperWaverly #BodyChute #GhostHunting #SpookySeason48 min - Episode 47 - Harold Shipman: The Doctor of Death
Harold Shipman: The Doctor of Death
Episode Description:
He took an oath to heal—but instead, he became one of the most prolific serial killers in history. In this chilling episode, we explore the life and crimes of Dr. Harold Shipman, a trusted family physician who used his position to silently murder over 200 patients.How did he get away with it for so long? What drove him to commit such calculated and methodical crimes? And how did he finally get caught?Join us as we uncover the disturbing reality behind the man known as ‘Doctor Death’, and dive into one of the most shocking cases of medical betrayal the world has ever seen.Inside this episode, we cover:
Shipman’s early life and how he rose to medical prominenceHis method of murder and how he exploited his patients’ trustThe staggering number of victims and how the true count may never be knownHow he evaded suspicion for decades, even gaining respect in his communityThe investigation that finally brought his crimes to lightHis trial, conviction, and the shocking way his life endedThe lasting impact on the UK’s medical system and legal changes in the wake of his crimesWhen your doctor is your killer… it changes everything.Watch & Listen Everywhere:
YouTube: Subscribe HerePatreon: Support & Get Exclusive ContentBonfire Merch: Grab Your Conundrum Crew Gear!Follow Us for More Creepy Content:
Website: https://totalconundrum.com/Instagram: @Total_ConundrumTwitter/X: @Total_ConundrumFacebook: @TotalConundrum#HaroldShipman #DoctorDeath #TotalConundrum #TrueCrimePodcast #SerialKillers #MedicalMurders #TrustBetrayed #TrueCrimeCommunity #ShipmanCase #ChillingCrimes38 min
About Total Conundrum
From the publisher's feed
If you dig the twisted, admire the outlandish, are enamored by the unusual, you’re in the right place. True Crime, the Supernatural, the Unexplained, now you’re speaking our language. If you agree,…
join us, as we dive into the darker side ( you know, because it’s more fun over here ). Welcome to Total Conundrum.