True Terror on Tap

True Terror on Tap

By Joseph Behill, Gabriel Behill, Michael BehillTrue Crime
Download on the App Store

True Terror on Tap episodes

  • New Year’s Nightmare: The Disappearance of Sheryl Sheppard

    Send us a text

    A new year—a fresh start, a clean slate. It’s a time of celebration, reflection, and resolutions. For many of us, it’s a night to dress up, go out, and toast to brighter days ahead. There’s something magical about New Year’s Eve: the countdown, the fireworks, the feeling that anything is possible.

    It’s a chance to live in the moment. The thrill of the night, the excitement of being with friends, the fleeting promise of new beginnings. And for one woman in Hamilton, Ontario, New Year’s Eve in 1997 seemed to mark the start of something beautiful. A proposal of love, and a ring that was meant to symbolize forever.”

    For 29-year-old Sheryl Sheppard, that night wasn’t the beginning of a fairy tale—it was the prologue to a nightmare. Just two days after she said ‘yes’ to the man who promised her forever, she vanished without a trace.

    What happened to Sheryl in the first days of 1998 remains a mystery that has haunted her family, her community, and an entire nation. A night of celebration turned into decades of unanswered questions.As the clock strikes midnight this year, you might feel that pull—to go out, celebrate, and lose yourself in the celebration of a fresh start. But maybe… just maybe, you might want to skip the New Year’s Eve parties and stay safe. This is True Terror on Tap!

    https://www.instagram.com/trueterrorontap/

    57 min
  • Unmasking the Dark Spirit of Christmas

    Send us a text

    Dive into the chilling world of Krampus, the half-goat, half-demon enforcer of holiday morality. In this episode of True Terror on Tap, we journey through the centuries-old folklore of the Alpine region to uncover the pagan roots, symbolic elements, and terrifying traditions surrounding this dark counterpart to Saint Nicholas. From the eerie rituals of Krampusnacht to the raucous energy of Krampuslauf parades, we explore how Krampus has evolved into a cultural icon blending fear and festivity.

    Discover how this ancient legend ties to fertility rites, the winter solstice, and Christian morality, and learn about Krampus’s modern resurgence in pop culture and festivals worldwide. Whether you’re intrigued by his role as a moral enforcer or just love a good scare, this episode promises to reveal the shadowy allure of one of Christmas’s most fascinating figures.

    Perfect for folklore enthusiasts, horror fans, and anyone looking to add a dark twist to their holiday season!

    https://www.instagram.com/trueterrorontap/

    50 min
  • Turtle Island Talk 10

    Send us a text

    Merch store- https://indigenoustales.threadless.com/
    Email us at [email protected]
    Also check out our Instagram -https://www.instagram.com/indigenous_tales/
    And our TikTok -https://www.tiktok.com/@indigenous_tales
    Amanda Bland Dallas area Bakery
    instagram - https://www.instagram.com/cupidsweetsbakes/
    Cupid Sweets- https://www.facebook.com/cupidsweets

    40 min
  • The Curious Case of Natalia Grace

    Send us a text

    In April 2010, a family from Indiana opened their home to a young girl, believing they were offering her a second chance at life. Natalia Grace was six years old, according to her paperwork—a Ukrainian orphan with a rare form of dwarfism. At first glance, she was tiny and vulnerable—the perfect match for what the Barnett family had hoped for in an adoption.

     But the story that followed would become a nightmare

    Within months of welcoming Natalia into their home, Kristine and Michael Barnett began to question everything about her. Was she really six years old, as her Ukrainian birth certificate claimed? Or was she much older—perhaps even a grown woman masquerading as a child? What started as a hopeful adoption spiraled into allegations of deceit, violence, and abandonment, culminating in one of the most bizarre legal cases in recent history. So get comfortable, take a listen, and brace yourself—the truth is darker than you think. This is True Terror on Tap.


    https://www.instagram.com/trueterrorontap/

    52 min
  • The Curious Case of Natalia Grace

    Send us a text

    In April 2010, a family from Indiana opened their home to a young girl, believing they were offering her a second chance at life. Natalia Grace was six years old, according to her paperwork—a Ukrainian orphan with a rare form of dwarfism. At first glance, she was tiny and vulnerable—the perfect match for what the Barnett family had hoped for in an adoption.

     But the story that followed would become a nightmare

    Within months of welcoming Natalia into their home, Kristine and Michael Barnett began to question everything about her. Was she really six years old, as her Ukrainian birth certificate claimed? Or was she much older—perhaps even a grown woman masquerading as a child? What started as a hopeful adoption spiraled into allegations of deceit, violence, and abandonment, culminating in one of the most bizarre legal cases in recent history. So get comfortable, take a listen, and brace yourself—the truth is darker than you think. This is True Terror on Tap.


    https://www.instagram.com/trueterrorontap/

    52 min
  • Winter Solstice Tales Native Traditions

    Send us a text

    In this special winter solstice episode, we dive into traditions surrounding the longest night of the year. Across Native cultures, the solstice is more than an astronomical event—it's a time for renewal, gratitude, and storytelling. We'll share chilling yet inspiring tales like the story of Manabush and his brother, the origin of tobacco, and how a spirit bear blessed a man. These stories carry lessons of survival, balance, and respect for the natural world, passed down through generations.

    Prepare to immerse yourself in a world where frost giants roam, the spirits of animals guide us, and ancient ceremonies honor the cycles of the Earth. Grab a warm drink, sit by the fire, and let these haunting and enlightening stories remind you of the deep connections between people, nature, and the cosmos.

    You will be remembered by the tracks you leave, and Stay close to the Great Spirit.

    Merch store- https://indigenoustales.threadless.com/
    Email us at [email protected]
    Also check out our Instagram -https://www.instagram.com/indigenous_tales/
    And our TikTok -https://www.tiktok.com/@indigenous_tales
    Amanda Bland Dallas area Bakery
    instagram - https://www.instagram.com/cupidsweetsbakes/
    Cupid Sweets- https://www.facebook.com/cupidsweets

    49 min
  • Vampires

    Send us a text

    Somewhere out there, beneath the pale light of the moon, something moves. It’s silent, patient, and ancient. It’s been watching us for centuries, slipping through the cracks of our stories, our fears, and our nightmares.

    You tell yourself it’s just folklore. An ancient explanation for death and disease, nothing more. But why, then, do the stories never go away? Why do they creep into every culture, every time, every dark corner of human history? Maybe it’s because myths aren’t born from nothing. Maybe it’s because, deep down, we know… they’ve always been with us."

     So tonight, as the shadows gather, we ask: Are they just stories? Or are they still out there, walking among us? "So lock your doors, keep your windows shut, and whatever you do, never invite a stranger in—no matter how charming they might seem. This is True Terror on Tap!


    https://www.instagram.com/trueterrorontap/

    50 min
  • Vampires

    Send us a text

    Somewhere out there, beneath the pale light of the moon, something moves. It’s silent, patient, and ancient. It’s been watching us for centuries, slipping through the cracks of our stories, our fears, and our nightmares.

    You tell yourself it’s just folklore. An ancient explanation for death and disease, nothing more. But why, then, do the stories never go away? Why do they creep into every culture, every time, every dark corner of human history? Maybe it’s because myths aren’t born from nothing. Maybe it’s because, deep down, we know… they’ve always been with us."

     So tonight, as the shadows gather, we ask: Are they just stories? Or are they still out there, walking among us? "So lock your doors, keep your windows shut, and whatever you do, never invite a stranger in—no matter how charming they might seem. This is True Terror on Tap!


    https://www.instagram.com/trueterrorontap/

    50 min
  • Residential Schools: Stories of Endurance and Survival

    Send us a text

    In our last episode, we go into the horrific origins of residential schools, institutions designed to forcibly assimilate Indigenous children by erasing their identities, culture, and language—a chilling attempt to “kill the Indian in the child.”

    This episode continues the story, focusing on the personal experiences of survivors who endured unimaginable abuse, trauma, and loss in these so-called schools. We’ll explore their daily lives, the horrors they faced, and the resilience that helped them survive.

    Please note: this episode contains graphic and distressing accounts of abuse and death. Listener discretion is strongly advised.

    Join us as we confront this painful history, honoring the voices of those who lived through it and working toward understanding, healing, and reconciliation.

    Merch store- https://indigenoustales.threadless.com/
    Email us at [email protected]
    Also check out our Instagram -https://www.instagram.com/indigenous_tales/
    And our TikTok -https://www.tiktok.com/@indigenous_tales
    Amanda Bland Dallas area Bakery
    instagram - https://www.instagram.com/cupidsweetsbakes/
    Cupid Sweets- https://www.facebook.com/cupidsweets

    54 min
  • True Terror on Tap Unexplained Mysteries

    Send us a text

    This week, we didn’t want to leave you without an episode, so we’re sharing an episode from our other podcast on the Behill Network, True Terror on Tap. We’ll be back next week with a brand-new show. Thanks for listening, and enjoy!

    In this chilling episode of True Terror on Tap, host Joseph delves into the eerie, unexplained mysteries that defy logic and haunt the imagination. From the depths of Mel’s Hole—a supposed bottomless pit in rural Washington with inexplicable properties—to Seattle’s enigmatic Mystery Soda Machine that dispensed rare drinks and vanished as suddenly as it appeared, these tales push the boundaries of the known. The exploration continues with the relentless and puzzling phenomenon known as "The Hum"—a low-frequency noise heard worldwide, driving some listeners to the brink of madness—and culminates with the haunting saga of the Circleville Letters, where anonymous threats tore apart a small Ohio town. This episode invites you to dim the lights, question reality, and embrace the unknown. Prepare yourself; some mysteries refuse to be explained.

    So Lock your doors, grab a taco, and prepare yourself—this is True Terror on Tap


    Merch store- https://indigenoustales.threadless.com/
    Email us at [email protected]
    Also check out our Instagram -https://www.instagram.com/indigenous_tales/
    And our TikTok -https://www.tiktok.com/@indigenous_tales
    Amanda Bland Dallas area Bakery
    instagram - https://www.instagram.com/cupidsweetsbakes/
    Cupid Sweets- https://www.facebook.com/cupidsweets

    52 min

About True Terror on Tap

From the publisher's feed

Welcome to True Terror on Tap, the ultimate podcast for fans of the eerie and the macabre. Join us as we delve into the chilling realms of true crime, horror, creepypasta, lore, myth, and the…

More shows like True Terror on Tap

Lore by Aaron Mahnke

Lore

45,251 Listeners

Unexplained by iHeartPodcasts

Unexplained

7,725 Listeners

The Paranormal Podcast by Jim Harold

The Paranormal Podcast

4,761 Listeners

Unexplained Encounters by Eeriecast Network

Unexplained Encounters

5,145 Listeners

Let's Not Meet: A True Horror Podcast by Cryptic County

Let's Not Meet: A True Horror Podcast

8,972 Listeners

Morbid by Ash Kelley & Alaina Urquhart

Morbid

102,182 Listeners

The Night Owl: True Ghost Stories by The Night Owl: True Ghost Stories

The Night Owl: True Ghost Stories

3,052 Listeners

Ghosted! by Roz Hernandez by Exactly Right and iHeartPodcasts

Ghosted! by Roz Hernandez

3,332 Listeners

Scared To Death by Dan Cummins, Lynze Cummins

Scared To Death

14,041 Listeners

Radio Rental by Tenderfoot TV & Audacy

Radio Rental

32,927 Listeners

Strange and Unexplained with Daisy Eagan by Strange and Unexplained with Daisy Eagan

Strange and Unexplained with Daisy Eagan

10,078 Listeners

Odd Trails: True Paranormal Stories by Brandon Lanier

Odd Trails: True Paranormal Stories

1,601 Listeners

MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories by Ballen Studios

MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories

29,006 Listeners

Heart Starts Pounding: Horrors, Hauntings and Mysteries by Heart Starts Pounding

Heart Starts Pounding: Horrors, Hauntings and Mysteries

5,024 Listeners

Rattled & Shook by Tenderfoot TV & Audacy

Rattled & Shook

1,404 Listeners