We Are Not Saved

Nietzsche said that God is Dead, and that people had not reckoned with with the consequences of that. Additionally he and other's predicted that people could not be good in the absence of religion. This has proved to be incorrect, there are plenty of atheists who are good people. But how has civilization fared. Is it possible that Nietzsche and the rest were just premature in their pessimism? That the current culture war is so fierce because we don't have a common set of values to negotiate around?

Moderation is an underrated value. To achieve it we need to not merely push for moderation, we need to push back against whichever side which has become too extreme. This is the pendulum, and it swings back and forth. If we value moderation we seek to keep it as close to the center as possible, while also avoiding violent swings from side to side. Doing so requires arguing for both sides of an issue depending on which is ascendant.

It's my monthly review of the books I read. In this episode I cover:

1. Savage Worlds: Adventure Edition By: Shane Lacy Hensley
2. Adrift: Seventy-Six Days Lost at Sea By: Steven Callahan
3. Novacene: The Coming Age of Hyperintelligence By: James Lovelock
4. Bronze Age Mindset By: Bronze Age Pervert
5. Why Are The Prices So Damn High? By: Eric Helland, Alex Tabarrok
6. An Introduction to the Book of Abraham (Religious) by: John Gee
7. The Lies of Locke Lamora (Gentleman Bastard #1) By: Scott Lynch
8. No More Mr Nice Guy: A Proven Plan for Getting What You Want in Love, Sex, and Life By: Robert A. Glover
9. Deep Survival: Who Lives, Who Dies, and Why By: Laurence Gonzales

I have heard some people, even in the comments of my this podcast, claim that we shouldn't worry about the current level of political unrest because there's nowhere for the violence to start. That we don't see the sort of large scale violence we once saw in the past. I think they're wrong I think there will be bloodshed, and the question this episode looks to answer is where does it start?

I recently read American Carnage, the story of the development of the Republican Civil War and the events which led to the current political crisis. While reading it I was struck by a question, not why is this happening now, but rather why isn't it always this way?

I think I have the answer to that question and it involves nationalism, wars, immigration and most of all the sayings of the Pashtun.

From the perspective of our system of government there are a lot of deviations currently going on. Many of them are being normalized. In the based we could correct deviations by means of amending the Constitution, but that no longer seems possible. Meaning we have largely decided to normalize them and hope that they're improvements, or at least not the kind of thing that is going to make the entire structure crash. As you might imagine I have my doubts that this is even possible.

This is the monthly episode where I review all the books I read over the past month. This time I'm mixing it up by doing very short reviews of some while doing longer reviews of the others. Here's a list of the books I mention:

1. Extremes by Various
2. The Lazy Dungeon Master by Michael Shea
3. Blood Song by Anthony Ryan
4. The Last American Man by Elizabeth Gilbert
5. Return of the Lazy Dungeon Master by Michael Shea
6. Once Upon a Time in Russia by Ben Mezrich
7. The Iliad by Homer
8. Don't Sleep There are Snakes by Daniel Everett
9. American Carnage by Tim Alberta

All more enlightened forms of government require certain institutions and customs in order to function. Democratic capitalism doesn't work without strong contract enforcement and low corruption for example. Is it possible that there are institutions and customs yet (or about) to be discovered and implemented which would make communism work. If so would that be enough to "save" humanity? Perhaps, but there's a lot of things working against that idea as well.

I recently read an article titled How I Almost Destroyed a £50 million War Plane and The Normalisation of Deviance. In this post I examine the idea of deviance and what it means to normalize it. The article most examined it from the perspective of smaller systems, but I'm interested in what it looks like if we take the concept and apply it to society as a whole.

Following up on a previous post I discuss the possible rise of a new civic religion, starting with some stories about how what people feel comfortable signaling support for has changed.

Historically replacing one religion with another civic or otherwise has been accompanied by bloodshed and no small amount of violence. Will this time be similar?