Megan and Jeni are revisiting While You Were Sleeping, the cozy ’90s rom-com that’s secretly way more unhinged than you remember. They’re breaking down Sandra Bullock’s early career, the famous actors who were almost cast, and the creepier version of this movie that almost happened (but we’re glad it didn’t!)

Follow us on social!

Instagram: ⁠@whatwerewatchingpod⁠ 

TikTok: @whatwerewatchingpod

~This is a throwback episode that was originally recorded in December 2023.~ 

The best way to spread Christmas cheer? Singing loud for all to hear! Or, maybe, listening to a podcast about everyone’s favorite Christmas movie, Elf! The girls discuss who almost played Buddy The Elf, Jon Favreau’s role in making the movie iconic, and how they always forget about blonde Zooey Deschanel! They also cover alllll the behind the scenes facts, like which scene was filmed in one take, how Zooey Deschanel’s singing talent was added into the script, and the original (much darker?!) script.

Follow us on social!

Instagram: ⁠@whatwerewatchingpod⁠ 

TikTok: @whatwerewatchingpod

Megan and Jeni are heading back to 2001 to revisit one of the most iconic episodes of Lizzie McGuire: the Aaron Carter Christmas special that sparked a real-life teen love triangle and the infamous Hilary Duff vs. Lindsay Lohan feud. They’re breaking down Aaron Carter’s rise to early-2000s superstardom, his complicated life, and Hilary Duff’s career evolution (including her brand-new single and upcoming album era). Plus, a full recap of the episode that made every tween believe they, too, might one day get kissed under mistletoe by a pop star.

Follow us on social!

Instagram: ⁠@whatwerewatchingpod⁠ 

TikTok: @whatwerewatchingpod

Megan and Jeni unwrap the holiday chaos of Four Christmases! From Vince Vaughn and Reese Witherspoon’s supposed on-set feud to the history of Reese’s production companies, her dating era at the time of filming, and what was really going on behind the scenes of this 2008 Christmas classic. They break down the movie’s funniest moments, the wild family dynamics, and the rumors about why certain scenes were cut (👀).

Follow us on social!

Instagram: ⁠@whatwerewatchingpod⁠ 

TikTok: @whatwerewatchingpod

Megan and Jeni are sharing their ultimate holiday and winter watch list. They break down their must-see cozy picks, the movies and shows that deserve a spot in your seasonal rotation, and what new releases to keep an eye on this winter. Plus, a surprise live reaction to Hilary Duff’s new single that neither of them were emotionally prepared for. Grab a blanket, make some hot chocolate, and settle in.

Follow us on social!

Instagram: ⁠@whatwerewatchingpod⁠ 

TikTok: @whatwerewatchingpod

This is a throwback episode that was originally recorded in November 2024.

It’s the perfect time to watch Dan in Real Life, the coziest fall movie that gives Thanksgiving vibes! Megan and Jeni are joined by friend of the pod, Julie Dumas Rose, who is (quite possibly) Dan in Real Life’s #1 fan. Julie drops all the fun facts about the real life movie sets, and the girls discuss the cast (especially the star, Steve Carell!)

Follow Julie on social!

Instagram: @__julesrose__

Tiktok: @__julesrose__

Follow us on social!

Instagram: ⁠@whatwerewatchingpod⁠ 

TikTok: @whatwerewatchingpod  

Megan and Jeni dive into the Nickelodeon stars we grew up watching – where they ended up, who surprised them, and which former child actor is now a pastor (!). From All That to Zoey 101, they’re catching up with Kenan Thompson, Drake Bell, Jennette McCurdy, Keke Palmer, Ariana Grande, and more. They also dig into the darker side of kids’ TV, accusations against Dan Schneider, and how many of these stars are now writing memoirs, hosting podcasts, or exposing the industry that raised them. It’s a nostalgic deep dive with plenty of shock factors, wild career pivots, and all the Nickelodeon tea you wanna know.

Follow us on social!

Instagram: ⁠@whatwerewatchingpod⁠ 

TikTok: @whatwerewatchingpod

Megan and Jeni volunteer as tribute to rewatch The Hunger Games! They’re talking about Jennifer Lawrence’s career trajectory, what Josh Hutcherson is up to now, and the Liam and Miley saga. They also recap your fave parts of the movie, and unpack why the director didn’t come back for the rest of the franchise.

Follow us on social!

Instagram: ⁠@whatwerewatchingpod⁠ 
TikTok: @whatwerewatchingpod

Megan and Jeni share their thoughts on Love Is Blind Season 9. Find out who shocked them, who gave them the ick, and Jeni’s unexpected personal connection to the season. They break down the love triangles, the Edmond of it all, and Jordan and Sparkle Megan’s post-show lives.  Plus, a chat about men in sandals (who let the dogs out?)

Follow us on social!

Instagram: ⁠@whatwerewatchingpod⁠ 
TikTok: @whatwerewatchingpod

Happy Halloween! Megan and Jeni are heading back to 1996 to rewatch the Sabrina the Teenage Witch TV pilot (the one with all the pineapples). They’re talking about Sabrina’s comic book origins, comparing the 90s sitcom to Netflix’s darker Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, and breaking down Melissa Joan Hart’s career.

Follow us on social!

Instagram: ⁠@whatwerewatchingpod⁠ 

TikTok: @whatwerewatchingpod