Episode 63: Scott Spillman (Executive Director of Mudsock Youth Athletics)
🎙 In this episode: I sit down with Scott Spillman, executive director of Mudsock Youth Athletics in Fishers, Indiana. We unpack what happens when an entire town decides youth sports should be about community first instead of chasing wins and dollars. From volunteers powering the system, to Marvel-movie moments of survival, to a Jeff Goldblum reference you won’t forget, this one is a blueprint for what rec sports can look like when everyone rows in the same direction.
How Fishers brought
all of its recreational sports together under one organization — and why that’s so rare.
🔹 Taming the Wild Wild West
Scott’s take on how Mudsock counters the fractured, for-profit, “our kids, our money” model dominating youth sports.
Why the true backbone of the program isn’t facilities or funding, but an army of people donating their time.
🔹 Community Over Championships
The mission: raise kids, not just athletes. Winning takes a backseat to belonging.
🔹 Partnerships That Matter
How aligning with the city and school district changed the game, especially when field space is scarce.
🔹 A Marvel Movie Plotline
The pivotal forks in the road that could have gone wrong… and the right moves that kept things thriving.
🔹 Do Kids Really Need Turf?
A candid look at the “state-of-the-art facility” arms race and whether it prices kids out of the game.
Scott’s theory on why this model thrives in Indiana, complete with a
Mean Girls nod: “We aren’t trying to make fetch happen.”
Maybe it isn’t money at all… maybe it’s people investing
themselves instead of just writing bigger checks.
Scott’s concern that the biggest threat may be inside the community itself: image, ego, and money.
“Youth sports is Jeff Goldblum in Jurassic Park” — just because we
can doesn’t mean we always
should.🔹 A Classroom, Not a Cage Match
Scott’s vision: treat youth sports like school. If we want
every student to learn, why don’t we want
every kid to succeed in sports?