Sign up to save your podcasts
Or
Share 100% Renewables Does Not Necessarily Mean Carbon-Free
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Or
100% Renewables Does Not Necessarily Mean Carbon-Free
Hundreds of companies around the world have committed to use 100% renewable energy in order to fight climate change. But a new study from Stanford University points out that 100% renewable energy does not necessarily mean 100% carbon-free energy.
The problem is that the carbon content of electricity can vary a lot
over the course of a day in many locations.
Using yearly averages can overstate the carbon reductions associated
with a particular power source, in some cases by significant amounts.
Suppose a California company purchases or generates enough solar power
to match 100% or more of their electricity use over the course of the
year. In reality, it may generate far
more electricity than it uses during the afternoon and sell the excess. Then, at nighttime, it purchases power from
the grid, which would be far more carbon-intensive if it involves the burning
of fossil fuels.
But in Britain, for example, the situation is very different. With a high reliance on wind power, grid
carbon intensity is actually lower at night.
So very different consumption patterns over the course of a day would be
less carbon-intensive.
If sufficient energy storage capacity can be implemented into the grid
as well as suitable long-range transmission, these time-based fluctuations in
the electricity supply could be ironed out.
Until such time, electricity consumers need to evaluate the environmental
benefits of their renewable strategies on an hourly basis rather than using
averages. And the best strategies are
entirely dependent upon the characteristics of the specific grid they interact
with. The need for this kind of analysis
will only grow as renewable generation expands.
Transparent, precise and meaningful carbon accounting is necessary.
**********
Web Links
100% renewables doesn’t equal zero-carbon energy, and the difference is growing
Photo, posted January 29, 2013, courtesy of U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service via Flickr.
Earth Wise is a production of WAMC Northeast Public Radio.
View all episodes
By Randy Simon
4.7
1515 ratings
Hundreds of companies around the world have committed to use 100% renewable energy in order to fight climate change. But a new study from Stanford University points out that 100% renewable energy does not necessarily mean 100% carbon-free energy.
The problem is that the carbon content of electricity can vary a lot
over the course of a day in many locations.
Using yearly averages can overstate the carbon reductions associated
with a particular power source, in some cases by significant amounts.
Suppose a California company purchases or generates enough solar power
to match 100% or more of their electricity use over the course of the
year. In reality, it may generate far
more electricity than it uses during the afternoon and sell the excess. Then, at nighttime, it purchases power from
the grid, which would be far more carbon-intensive if it involves the burning
of fossil fuels.
But in Britain, for example, the situation is very different. With a high reliance on wind power, grid
carbon intensity is actually lower at night.
So very different consumption patterns over the course of a day would be
less carbon-intensive.
If sufficient energy storage capacity can be implemented into the grid
as well as suitable long-range transmission, these time-based fluctuations in
the electricity supply could be ironed out.
Until such time, electricity consumers need to evaluate the environmental
benefits of their renewable strategies on an hourly basis rather than using
averages. And the best strategies are
entirely dependent upon the characteristics of the specific grid they interact
with. The need for this kind of analysis
will only grow as renewable generation expands.
Transparent, precise and meaningful carbon accounting is necessary.
**********
Web Links
100% renewables doesn’t equal zero-carbon energy, and the difference is growing
Photo, posted January 29, 2013, courtesy of U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service via Flickr.
Earth Wise is a production of WAMC Northeast Public Radio.
More shows like Earth Wise
View all
Stuff You Should Know
78,636 Listeners
Freakonomics Radio
32,100 Listeners
Planet Money
30,666 Listeners
Hidden Brain
43,528 Listeners
Wait Wait... Don't Tell Me!
38,856 Listeners
Living on Earth
466 Listeners
Science Quickly
1,396 Listeners
Nature Podcast
766 Listeners
BirdNote Daily
1,255 Listeners
The Academic Minute
29 Listeners
Science Magazine Podcast
821 Listeners
Science Friday
6,435 Listeners
The Book Show
33 Listeners
Everything Explained
20 Listeners
The Daily
111,948 Listeners
The Media Project
39 Listeners
The Roundtable
159 Listeners
51 Percent
14 Listeners
A New York Minute in History
50 Listeners
The Capitol Connection
22 Listeners
The Legislative Gazette
11 Listeners
Short Wave
6,564 Listeners
The Ezra Klein Show
15,950 Listeners
The Atlas Obscura Podcast
1,736 Listeners