Beyond the Box

#6: Beyond the Badge - When Abandonment Turns Into Inspiration


Listen Later

A cardboard box in a frigid apartment hallway during a winter storm became the unlikely beginning of an extraordinary full-circle story. Matthew, abandoned as a newborn just days before Christmas in 2000, has defied incredible odds to become a South Bend police officer—the very department that investigated his abandonment. Detective Gene Eyster vividly remembers that night: two feet of snow, temperatures around 15 degrees, and bitter winds. He rushed to the scene and nicknamed the infant “Baby Jesus” because of the timing and circumstances, eventually tracking down Matthew’s parents after three intense days of investigation.

For twenty years afterward, Gene often found himself reflecting on the fate of “Baby Jesus,” driving past the apartment complex regularly and wondering what had become of him. Questions lingered in his mind, unresolved and poignant: Had their paths unknowingly crossed? Was the child still living nearby? Then, a chance conversation between Matthew and a fellow officer revealed the astonishing connection—“Baby Jesus” had grown up to wear the same uniform and patrol the same streets where he’d been found.

Their reunion was deeply healing, especially for Gene, who had recently lost his own adult son. The striking similarities between Matthew and Gene’s late son—same height, build, even facial hair—felt almost providential. For Matthew, meeting Gene brought closure and insight into his earliest days, offering answers he’d sought his entire life.

This remarkable reunion highlights the vital importance of Monica Kelsey’s mission with Safe Haven Baby Boxes, providing desperate parents with anonymous and safe ways to surrender their infants. With 59 babies safely surrendered in baby boxes nationwide and over 200 through legal handoffs, each child now has the opportunity to craft their own extraordinary life story—just as Matthew has done.

shbb.org


Find Safe Haven Baby Boxes on:

TikTok

Instagram

Youtube

X

Facebook


Find Monica Kelsey on:

TikTok

Instagram

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Beyond the BoxBy Monica Kelsey

  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5

5

4 ratings


More shows like Beyond the Box

View all
20/20 by ABC News

20/20

11,676 Listeners

ADOPTION NOW by April Fallon

ADOPTION NOW

152 Listeners

Coffee Convos with Kail Lowry and Lindsie Chrisley by PodcastOne

Coffee Convos with Kail Lowry and Lindsie Chrisley

22,308 Listeners

Crime Junkie by audiochuck

Crime Junkie

365,253 Listeners

IDIOT with Laura Clery by Laura Clery & Studio71

IDIOT with Laura Clery

891 Listeners

I Want to Put a Baby in You! by I Want To Put A Baby In You

I Want to Put a Baby in You!

82 Listeners

The Australian Surrogacy Podcast by Sarah Jefford

The Australian Surrogacy Podcast

2 Listeners

Dateline NBC by NBC News

Dateline NBC

47,979 Listeners

Dumb Blonde by Dumb Blonde Productions

Dumb Blonde

8,279 Listeners

Karma & Chaos with Kail Lowry & Becky Hayter by PodcastOne

Karma & Chaos with Kail Lowry & Becky Hayter

8,826 Listeners

Predators I’ve Caught with Chris Hansen by Chris Hansen

Predators I’ve Caught with Chris Hansen

1,436 Listeners

The Southern Tea by PodcastOne

The Southern Tea

4,043 Listeners

The Embryo Adoption Podcast by National Embryo Donation Center

The Embryo Adoption Podcast

35 Listeners

Barely Famous by PodcastOne

Barely Famous

5,648 Listeners

Not Gonna Lie with Kylie Kelce by Wave Originals

Not Gonna Lie with Kylie Kelce

9,624 Listeners