Based on a True Story

BASED ON A TRUE STORY (BOATS EP. 390) — Captain Michael "Mak" Makatura joins us to break down the historical accuracy of Top Gun (1986). Drawing from his own experience in Central Europe during the Cold War, Mak explains what the movie gets right about fighter pilot culture, competition, and danger — including a real-world parallel to Goose's tragic death. The conversation also covers his book The Fightin' Tenth: Cold War to Desert Storm, chronicling the experiences of the 10th Tactical Fighter Squadron from the Cold War through Operation Desert Storm.

Guest Links

• The Fightin' Tenth: Cold War to Desert Storm: https://thefightintenth.com/truestory

Chapters

0:00 Intro & Overall Accuracy Grade

3:16 The MiG-28 & Real Soviet Encounters

6:10 Cold War Training & Border Standoffs

11:10 Pilot Competition & Friendly Rivalry

14:00 Goose's Death: The Reality of Jet Wash

19:19 Relationships & Moving to Real-World Missions

27:12 Rule Bending, Buzzing the Tower & The Fightin' Tenth

Support My Work

• Join the BOATS community: https://links.boatspodcast.com/community
• Become a BOATS Producer (name in credits + ad-free episodes): https://links.boatspodcast.com/producers
• Support my sponsors: https://links.boatspodcast.com/advertisers
• Email me: [email protected]

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

BASED ON A TRUE STORY (BOATS EP. 389) — Are you a baseball fan? Today we're digging into some baseball history as it was depicted in the 1976 movie "The Bingo Long Traveling All-Stars & Motor Kings." Learn about the history of barnstorming baseball teams with Ben Railton, Professor of American Studies at Fitchburg State University. We'll discuss how the movie's characters mirror real legends like Satchel Paige, Josh Gibson, and Jackie Robinson. Ben is the host of the podcast Baseball, Bigotry and the Battle for America and author of Of Thee I Sing: Race and American Patriotism.

Guest Links

• Black and White and Read: https://links.boatspodcast.com/389guest
• Ben Railton's Podcast: https://links.boatspodcast.com/389podcast
• Of Thee I Sing: The Contested History of American Patriotism: https://links.boatspodcast.com/389book

Chapters

0:00 Intro & Movie Synopsis

3:45 Guest Introduction & Historical Accuracy Grade

7:22 Characters & Real-Life Parallels

10:13 Negro Leagues & Barnstorming Context

17:05 Owner Violence & Labor Activism

20:41 Performance, The Invite Pitch & House of David

32:51 Hardships & The Climactic Game

42:40 Jackie Robinson & End of an Era

49:19 Wrap Up & Two Truths and a Lie

Support My Work

• Join the BOATS community: https://links.boatspodcast.com/community
• Become a BOATS Producer (name in credits + ad-free episodes): https://links.boatspodcast.com/producers
• Support my sponsors: https://links.boatspodcast.com/advertisers
• Email me: [email protected]

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

BASED ON A TRUE STORY (BOATS EP. 388) — Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey (2026) brings Homer’s epic journey to the screen as we follow Matt Damon’s Odysseus from the Trojan War through monsters, sirens, and a long road home. In this episode, we'll learn from author and former documentary filmmaker Neil Laird about the historical accuracy of the movie and how well it ties into Homer’s Odyssey.

Guest Links

• Prime Time Troy: https://links.boatspodcast.com/388troy
• Prime Time Pompeii: https://links.boatspodcast.com/388pompeii
• Prime Time Travelers: https://links.boatspodcast.com/388travelers
• Neil Laird's Website: https://links.boatspodcast.com/388guest

Chapters

0:00 Letter grade & Homer’s Odyssey

3:30 Troy (2004) vs The Odyssey (2026)

9:30 Monsters, cyclopses and mythical beasts

14:30 Circe’s island and men turned to pigs

19:30 Hades, Achilles and war guilt

23:30 Sirens, Scylla, Charybdis and hard choices

37:30 Calypso, lost years and the long road home

Support my work

• Join the BOATS community: https://links.boatspodcast.com/community
• Become a BOATS Producer (name in credits + ad-free episodes): https://links.boatspodcast.com/producers
• Support my sponsors: https://links.boatspodcast.com/advertisers
• Email me: [email protected]

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

BASED ON A TRUE STORY (BOATS EP. 387) — How accurate is the 1990 movie Memphis Belle? Military historian Joshua Donohue returns to Based on a True Story to break down what the movie gets right, where Hollywood takes liberties, and what the real crew of the Memphis Belle actually experienced during World War II.

Guest Links

• Josh's YouTube = https://links.boatspodcast.com/387guest
• Josh's Wake Island Article = https://links.boatspodcast.com/387wakearticle
• Josh's Pearl Harbor Article = https://links.boatspodcast.com/387ewaarticle

Other Mentions

• Find where to watch the movie = https://links.boatspodcast.com/387movie
• Memphis Belle Unveiling = https://links.boatspodcast.com/387unveiling
• The Man Who Flew the Memphis Belle by Robert Morgan and Ron Powers = https://links.boatspodcast.com/387themanwhoflew
• Memphis Belle Documentary = https://links.boatspodcast.com/387documentary
• Memphis Belle - Air Force Fact Sheet = https://links.boatspodcast.com/387factsheet
• The Memphis Belle Museum Exhibit = https://links.boatspodcast.com/387museumexhibit

Chapters

0:00 Intro and accuracy grade

2:13 Other bomber movies and context

12:37 The real Memphis Belle missions

22:15 Hollywood vs the real 25th mission

32:20 How lead bombers and formations worked

43:46 Bombing runs, smoke, and the Norden

52:13 Midair dangers and ball turret stories

1:15:02 The 1944 documentary and legacy

1:21:53 Josh's Bataan book project

Support My Work

• Join the BOATS community: https://links.boatspodcast.com/community
• Become a BOATS Producer (name in credits + ad-free episodes): https://links.boatspodcast.com/producers
• Support my sponsors: https://links.boatspodcast.com/advertisers
• Email me: [email protected]

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

What really happened to Sir John Franklin’s doomed Arctic expedition, and how much of AMC’s The Terror is grounded in the historical record? Today we're joined by Rich Napolitano, host of Shipwrecks and Sea Dogs, to compare the TV series with the real story of HMS Erebus and HMS Terror, from the search for the Northwest Passage to the evidence historians have uncovered about the crew’s fate.

Links

• Shipwrecks and Sea Dogs
• Lost Franklin Expedition w/NEW UPDATES
• Dr. John Rae
• The Terror (TV Series)

Chapters

0:00 Intro to The Terror

2:12 Two Truths and a Lie

4:08 Meet Rich Napolitano

7:22 The Real Franklin Expedition

20:06 Stuck in the Arctic Ice

33:42 Food, Disease, and Survival

47:41 The Terror’s Supernatural Twist

59:18 How the Expedition Ended

Support My Work

• Join the BOATS community: https://links.boatspodcast.com/community
• Become a BOATS Producer (name in credits + ad-free episodes): https://links.boatspodcast.com/producers
• Support my sponsors: https://links.boatspodcast.com/advertisers
• Email me: [email protected]

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

BASED ON A TRUE STORY (BOATS EP. 385) — Have you ever wondered how much of The Legend of Bagger Vance is rooted in history? Steven Pressfield, author of the 1995 novel that inspired the 2000 film, joins Based on a True Story to unpack the story’s connections to the Bhagavad Gita, the real-life golfing legends Bobby Jones and Walter Hagen, and the choices Hollywood made when bringing the book to the screen. They also explore Steven’s approach to writing historical fiction and his latest novel, The Arcadian.

Guest Links

• The Legend of Bagger Vance by Steven Pressfield
• The Arcadian by Steven Pressfield
• Steven Pressfield's Website

Chapters

0:00 Intro and movie synopsis

2:43 Meet Steven Pressfield

5:35 Is Bagger Vance based on history?

11:32 Bobby Jones, Walter Hagen, and real golf history

18:07 The missing 10 years after World War I

27:18 What the movie changed from the book

40:02 Writing historical fiction with Steven Pressfield

52:06 The Arcadian and final thoughts

Support my work

• Join the BOATS community: https://links.boatspodcast.com/community
• Become a BOATS Producer (name in credits + ad-free episodes): https://links.boatspodcast.com/producers
• Support my sponsors: https://links.boatspodcast.com/advertisers
• Email me: [email protected]

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

BASED ON A TRUE STORY (BOATS EP. 384) — Quentin Tarantino's Once Upon a Time in Hollywood tells a tale of alternative history. In this episode, we'll separate the film’s fairy-tale storytelling from the real history behind the Manson murders, Sharon Tate, Bruce Lee, Steve McQueen, and the Hollywood of 1969.

Listen to All the Right Movies

John's podcast breaks down the history of Hollywood, one film at a time. Check out All the Right Movies to learn all about the work that went into making movies, how much of it works, and more.

More from All the Right Movies

• Find all the episodes: https://alltherightmovies.com/
• All the Right Movies episode for Once Upon a Time in Hollywood: https://www.patreon.com/posts/atrm-classic-111-152929056
• Facts about the movie: https://alltherightmovies.com/feature/45-interesting-and-golden-age-facts-about-once-upon-a-time-in-hollywood/

Mentioned in the Episode

• John Neal Phillips on 1967's Bonnie and Clyde: https://links.boatspodcast.com/195

Chapters

0:00 Intro and historical accuracy

4:15 Tarantino’s fairy-tale approach

11:25 Rick, Cliff, and Sharon Tate

18:40 Hollywood in the late 1960s

28:30 Steve McQueen and The Great Escape

36:20 Bruce Lee, Sharon Tate, and Spahn Ranch

49:10 The Manson Family and Cielo Drive

58:45 The film’s alternate ending

1:04:20 Final thoughts and ATRM

Support my work

• Join the BOATS community: https://links.boatspodcast.com/community
• Become a BOATS Producer (name in credits + ad-free episodes): https://links.boatspodcast.com/producers
• Support my sponsors: https://links.boatspodcast.com/advertisers
• Email me: [email protected]

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

BASED ON A TRUE STORY (BOATS EP. 383) — Did the Oppenheimer movie get the Manhattan Project right? Today, we'll dig into the film's portrayal of the project. From the Los Alamos we see in the movie to what we don't see in the movie such as Oak Ridge's massive factories, Hanford's plutonium production, and more that you don't ever see in the movie.

Get Alice's book

Alice Lovejoy is the author of Tales of Militant Chemistry, film scholar, and a professor at the University of Minnesota. She'll join us today to unravel the true story behind the Manhattan Project in the movie.

Find more of Alice's work

• Army Film and the Avant Garde
• Remapping Cold War Media
• Visit Alice's website
• Follow Alice on Bluesky
• Follow Alice on Instagram

Listen to the other BOATS episode on Oppenheimer

Chapters

00:00 Manhattan Project Overview

04:50 Uranium vs. Plutonium Bombs

09:45 Scale of the Project

15:28 Einstein's Role

20:42 Trinity Test Depiction

25:04 Radiation Concerns

30:51 Project's End & Legacy

33:52 Post-War Impacts

Support my work

• Join the BOATS community: https://links.boatspodcast.com/community
• Become a BOATS Producer (name in credits + ad-free episodes): https://links.boatspodcast.com/producers
• Support my sponsors: https://links.boatspodcast.com/advertisers
• Email me: [email protected]

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

BASED ON A TRUE STORY (BOATS EP. 382) — Join me in this throwback style BOATS episode without any guests. It'll just be you and I learning about the true story behind 2023's Oppenheimer. Was the poisoned apple scene real? How well was the Trinity Test portrayed on screen? What does the movie leave out from Oppenheimer's life? If you've seen the movie and wondered what really happened, this episode is your guided tour through the history behind the film.

Chapters

0:00 Intro, synopsis & Two Truths and a Lie

3:30 Prometheus myth and poisoned apple story

10:15 Oppenheimer’s education in Europe and early career

18:40 Relationships with Jean Tatlock and Kitty Oppenheimer

28:20 FBI surveillance, communism fears, and the Manhattan Project scale

39:10 Trinity Test, “I am become Death,” and bombing Japan

51:00 Meeting President Truman and the Strauss feud

1:01:30 Oppenheimer’s fall, later life, and modern reevaluation

1:08:00 Two Truths and a Lie answers & closing

Resources

• American Prometheus
• Tales of Militant Chemistry
• 109 East Palace
• Robert Oppenheimer: A Life Inside the Center
• J. Robert Oppenheimer: A Life
• An Atomic Love Story: The Extraordinary Women in Robert Oppenheimer's Life
• The Ruin of J. Robert Oppenheimer

If your podcast app doesn't support clickable links, you can also find all the links at https://links.boatspodcast.com/382

Support My Work

• Join the BOATS community: https://links.boatspodcast.com/community
• Become a BOATS Producer (name in credits + ad-free episodes): https://links.boatspodcast.com/producers
• Support my sponsors: https://links.boatspodcast.com/advertisers
• Email me: [email protected]

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

BASED ON A TRUE STORY (BOATS EP. 381) — My love of history started with the legend of King Arthur. While there are many King Arthur movies to pick from, today we'll learn about the one that marketed itself as being more historically accurate than the others.

Dorsey Armstrong on The Great Courses Plus

Historian Dorsey Armstrong breaks down the historical accuracy of the 2004 film King Arthur. Learn the true story behind the legends of Arthur, Guinevere, Merlin, the Round Table, and more.

Chapters

0:00 Intro

2:30 Movie's Historical Claims

5:10 Sarmatians and Lancelot

10:45 Merlin's Real History

15:20 Woads, Picts, and Round Table

22:00 Christianity and Pelagius

28:15 Final Mission and Freedom

34:50 Guinevere and Ice Battle

40:30 Battle of Badon Hill

45:15 Sword in the Stone

49:00 Legend Surprises

53:30 BOATS Update for 2026 and Outro

Support My Work

• Join the BOATS community: https://links.boatspodcast.com/community
• Become a BOATS Producer (name in credits + ad-free episodes): https://links.boatspodcast.com/producers
• Support my sponsors: https://links.boatspodcast.com/advertisers
• Email me: [email protected]

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.