Medicine and Science from The BMJ

Cancer screening: when does testing go too far?


Listen Later

The heated debate on prostate cancer screening boils down to one question: should men be routinely screened?

Two recent position statements from the UK’s national screening committee published in the BMJ show that screening decisions are steeped in complexity. 

The benefits of screening may be easier to grasp, but the harms of overdiagnosis and overtreatment are given less attention. Can we close the divide between the public and academic discourse?

 

Guest: Sian Taylor-Phillips is professor of population health at the University of Warwick and a member of the UK national screening committee.

 

Further Reading:

  • UK National Screening Committee position statement on surrogate outcomes in cancer screening trials
  • Prostate cancer screening: Committee rejects calls for mass testing programme despite pressure
  • More interviews from the BMJ on our Youtube channel.

    ...more
    View all episodesView all episodes
    Download on the App Store

    Medicine and Science from The BMJBy The BMJ

    • 4.5
    • 4.5
    • 4.5
    • 4.5
    • 4.5

    4.5

    32 ratings


    More shows like Medicine and Science from The BMJ

    View all
    More or Less by BBC Radio 4

    More or Less

    884 Listeners

    Woman's Hour by BBC Radio 4

    Woman's Hour

    377 Listeners

    JAMA Clinical Reviews by JAMA Network

    JAMA Clinical Reviews

    505 Listeners

    BJSM Podcast by BMJ Group

    BJSM Podcast

    50 Listeners

    Health Check by BBC World Service

    Health Check

    92 Listeners

    DTB Podcast by BMJ Group

    DTB Podcast

    4 Listeners

    Gut Podcast by BMJ Group

    Gut Podcast

    8 Listeners

    Sharp Scratch by The BMJ

    Sharp Scratch

    7 Listeners

    ADC Podcast by BMJ Group

    ADC Podcast

    3 Listeners

    Thorax Podcast by BMJ Group

    Thorax Podcast

    1 Listeners

    STI Podcast by BMJ Group

    STI Podcast

    3 Listeners

    JNNP Podcast by BMJ Group

    JNNP Podcast

    9 Listeners

    Heart Podcast by BMJ Group

    Heart Podcast

    39 Listeners

    JNIS Podcast by BMJ Group

    JNIS Podcast

    14 Listeners

    EBN Podcast by BMJ Group

    EBN Podcast

    1 Listeners

    Practical Neurology Podcast by BMJ Group

    Practical Neurology Podcast

    54 Listeners

    FG Podcast by BMJ Group

    FG Podcast

    0 Listeners

    Medical Humanities Podcast by BMJ Group

    Medical Humanities Podcast

    6 Listeners

    Lupus Science and Medicine Podcast by BMJ Group

    Lupus Science and Medicine Podcast

    16 Listeners

    The Resus Room by Simon Laing, Rob Fenwick & James Yates

    The Resus Room

    100 Listeners

    Health Report by ABC Australia

    Health Report

    142 Listeners

    The Week Unwrapped - with Olly Mann by The Week Unwrapped

    The Week Unwrapped - with Olly Mann

    82 Listeners

    RMD Open Podcast by BMJ Group

    RMD Open Podcast

    3 Listeners

    BMJ Best Practice Podcast by BMJ Group

    BMJ Best Practice Podcast

    25 Listeners

    The Doctor's Kitchen Podcast by Dr Rupy Aujla

    The Doctor's Kitchen Podcast

    584 Listeners

    Feel Better, Live More with Dr Rangan Chatterjee by Dr Rangan Chatterjee: GP & Author

    Feel Better, Live More with Dr Rangan Chatterjee

    3,812 Listeners

    Zero to Finals Medical Revision Podcast by Thomas Watchman

    Zero to Finals Medical Revision Podcast

    144 Listeners

    IJGC Podcast by BMJ Group

    IJGC Podcast

    23 Listeners

    Life Changing by BBC Radio 4

    Life Changing

    110 Listeners

    ZOE Science & Nutrition by ZOE

    ZOE Science & Nutrition

    2,060 Listeners

    BMJ Future Health Podcast by BMJ Publishing Group

    BMJ Future Health Podcast

    0 Listeners

    What's Up Docs? by BBC Radio 4

    What's Up Docs?

    103 Listeners

    Complex with Kimberley Wilson by BBC Sounds

    Complex with Kimberley Wilson

    19 Listeners