Thought for the Day

Canon Angela Tilby


Listen Later

Good morning. One of the clichés of the media industry is that the public have a ‘right to know’ especially when things go wrong. It’s often true. Think of the post office scandal or the recent investigations into some of our privatised water companies. It’s important for the public to know when rules are being broken and when there’s manifest injustice.

But the right to know must be balanced by prudence. On issues of security or defence, or when vital decisions are waiting, secrecy can be important. The whole point of a democratic system is that it’s for us to choose who we trust, who we allow to keep secrets on our behalf. And all this is fine of course, until it goes wrong.
In recent days many files relating to Peter Mandelson have been made public. We’ve learnt of indiscreet remarks between him and the then Work and Pensions Secretary, Pat McFadden. There are scathing comments about the Prime Minister and other leading politicians which were never meant to see the light of day, and come across now as disloyal. Reading them I can’t help but suspect part of this was simply letting off steam. Politicians have a right, as we all do, to trust that casual remarks sometimes made in frustration won’t go any further. But of course they sometimes do and in the days of smart phones this trust is coming to seem naïve. Perhaps these days we could reflect that Jesus’ prophecy: ‘What you have said in the dark will be heard in the light, and what you have whispered in an inner chamber will be proclaimed on the housetops’.
This is very challenging. Who hasn’t said something disparaging behind someone’s back and then interacted with them as if they’d never spoken? Hypocrisy is part of the human condition. And Jesus himself warns against it. ‘Let your yea be yea and your no be no’.
That leaves it up to us to make judgments about who we trust and why, who we can safely let off steam to and who it is better to avoid. The public’s right to know has to be balanced by common sense, because in the case of secrecy, context is all: another journalistic cliché of course. But it’s true. And perhaps we should extend our sympathy to those who carry the burden of secrecy on our behalf. Not everything is a plot. Not everything said in private actually matters that much, though its exposure can be deeply embarrassing.
Jesus told his disciples to be innocent as doves but I don’t think he was telling them to take everything at face value. In the same sentence he had advised them to be as wise as serpents.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Thought for the DayBy BBC Radio 4

  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6

4.6

56 ratings


More shows like Thought for the Day

View all
Global News Podcast by BBC World Service

Global News Podcast

7,639 Listeners

From Our Own Correspondent by BBC Radio 4

From Our Own Correspondent

375 Listeners

More or Less by BBC Radio 4

More or Less

876 Listeners

Newshour by BBC World Service

Newshour

1,046 Listeners

The Reith Lectures by BBC Radio 4

The Reith Lectures

156 Listeners

In Our Time by BBC Radio 4

In Our Time

5,520 Listeners

The Documentary Podcast by BBC World Service

The Documentary Podcast

1,799 Listeners

In Our Time: History by BBC Radio 4

In Our Time: History

1,878 Listeners

6 Minute English by BBC Radio

6 Minute English

1,763 Listeners

Learning English Conversations by BBC Radio

Learning English Conversations

1,049 Listeners

The Infinite Monkey Cage by BBC Radio 4

The Infinite Monkey Cage

1,920 Listeners

Desert Island Discs by BBC Radio 4

Desert Island Discs

1,979 Listeners

Great Lives by BBC Radio 4

Great Lives

488 Listeners

Profile by BBC Radio 4

Profile

108 Listeners

Last Word by BBC Radio 4

Last Word

46 Listeners

The Week in Westminster by BBC Radio 4

The Week in Westminster

30 Listeners

BBC Inside Science by BBC Radio 4

BBC Inside Science

407 Listeners

Thinking Allowed by BBC Radio 4

Thinking Allowed

305 Listeners

Moral Maze by BBC Radio 4

Moral Maze

61 Listeners

The Audio Long Read by The Guardian

The Audio Long Read

849 Listeners

Start the Week by BBC Radio 4

Start the Week

164 Listeners

The Briefing Room by BBC Radio 4

The Briefing Room

58 Listeners

Political Thinking with Nick Robinson by BBC Radio 4

Political Thinking with Nick Robinson

114 Listeners

You're Dead to Me by BBC Radio 4

You're Dead to Me

3,177 Listeners

The Bomb by BBC World Service

The Bomb

1,002 Listeners