Karen Suarez: Decision Authority, The Make-or-Break Factor for Product Owners

Read the full Show Notes and search through the world's largest audio library on Agile and Scrum directly on the Scrum Master Toolbox Podcast website: http://bit.ly/SMTP_ShowNotes.

The Great Product Owner: Clear Vision That Inspires Action

Karen describes an exemplary Product Owner who deeply understood both their product and market. This PO maintained a perfect balance of being firm in their vision while remaining open and curious to input. What made this PO particularly effective was their ability to communicate a clear, compelling vision that motivated the team. They defined key results in ways that were easily understood and actionable for team members. Most importantly, they trusted the development team with solution design rather than prescribing how features should be implemented, creating an environment where the team felt both guided and empowered.

The Bad Product Owner: Committee Decisions and Never-Ending Backlogs

Karen identifies two common anti-patterns in the Product Owner role. The first is when the PO isn't truly empowered to make decisions because the company hesitates to give this responsibility to a single person. In these cases, the PO becomes merely a proxy for a committee, with solutions predetermined elsewhere. The second anti-pattern is the PO who cannot say "no," allowing backlogs to grow unmanageably large. Karen once worked with a team that had accumulated 5,000 backlog items! Her solution was to use data to demonstrate why such expansive backlogs are counterproductive, create filtered views showing only the highest-priority items, and eventually make it acceptable to delete irrelevant backlog items altogether.

Self-reflection Question: In your organization, does the Product Owner have true decision-making authority, or are they operating as a proxy for committee decisions?

About Karen Suarez 

Karen is a dedicated Scrum Master with a long experience driving agile transformations and fostering high-performing teams. She is passionate about continuous learning, and excels in aligning agile practices with organizational innovation.

You can link with Karen Suarez on LinkedIn.