The Counter Ruck

Does rugby need the 20-minute red card?


Listen Later

In the coming weeks, World Rugby will decide on a proposal to implement a new 20-minute red card. Already seen in the southern hemisphere and Super Rugby, the proposal allows sides to replace a red carded player after 20 minutes in order to preserve the spectacle of a contest, to not kill off games when teams are reduced to 14 players.


Critics of the move say that the measure risks admitting defeat in the battle to change player behaviour and eradicate high tackles as a result of poor technique. The impending decision has been pitted as a battle of philosophies, of attitudes of leniency towards high shots both sides of the equator.


Owen Doyle, a former international referee and an Irish Times columnist, joins Gordon D'Arcy and Nathan Johns to discuss the potential new law and what impact it could have.


Produced by John Casey.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Counter RuckBy The Irish Times

  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4

4

8 ratings


More shows like The Counter Ruck

View all
OTB Rugby by OTB Sports

OTB Rugby

83 Listeners

The Second Captains Podcast by Second Captains

The Second Captains Podcast

175 Listeners

The EggChasers Rugby Podcast by Tim Cocker, JB, Phil

The EggChasers Rugby Podcast

171 Listeners

RTÉ Rugby Podcast by RTÉ

RTÉ Rugby Podcast

16 Listeners

Inside Politics with Hugh Linehan by The Irish Times

Inside Politics with Hugh Linehan

143 Listeners

Irish Times Inside Business by The Irish Times

Irish Times Inside Business

14 Listeners

The Irish Times Books Podcast by The Irish Times Books Podcast

The Irish Times Books Podcast

15 Listeners

Ross O'Carroll-Kelly by The Irish Times

Ross O'Carroll-Kelly

41 Listeners

The Women's Podcast by The Irish Times

The Women's Podcast

122 Listeners

The Rugby Pod by The Ringer

The Rugby Pod

342 Listeners

The Telegraph Rugby Podcast by The Telegraph

The Telegraph Rugby Podcast

38 Listeners

Rugby Union Weekly by BBC Radio 5 Live

Rugby Union Weekly

364 Listeners

The Ruck Rugby Podcast by The Times

The Ruck Rugby Podcast

68 Listeners

The Left Wing by Irish Independent

The Left Wing

60 Listeners

The 42 Rugby Weekly by The 42 Rugby Weekly

The 42 Rugby Weekly

33 Listeners

The Good, The Bad & The Rugby by Folding Pocket

The Good, The Bad & The Rugby

275 Listeners

VMTV Rugby Pod by Virgin Media Originals

VMTV Rugby Pod

0 Listeners

In The News by The Irish Times

In The News

48 Listeners

GUBU by The Irish Times

GUBU

12 Listeners

Web 1.0 by Enda O'Dowd

Web 1.0

0 Listeners

Indo Sport by Irish Independent

Indo Sport

50 Listeners

Conversations with Parents by The Irish Times

Conversations with Parents

0 Listeners

The Offload by Tommy Bowe and Donncha O’Callaghan

The Offload

23 Listeners