March 16, 2014

DZ-02: Do the Screenplay Gurus score big at the Box Office?

1 hour 24 minutes

Listen if you need to know which guru frameworks actually deliver in Act Three.

Part 2 of our Screenplay Gurus series takes the same lens from Part 1 — Vogler, Snyder and Hauge — and points it at the two highest-grossing original films of 2013: GRAVITY and FROZEN. No franchise, no sequel. Just the two films that audiences went to see in the biggest numbers that year, and the question of what their scripts actually look like when you run them against the guru formulas.

The short answer is: both films cleave much more closely to these structures than the award-season dramas we looked at in Part 1. Which is interesting — but not as interesting as how they deviate when you look more carefully.

GRAVITY maps onto Vogler's Hero's Journey in surprising depth: the umbilical tether as threshold crossing, Matt Kowalski as Obi-Wan, the hallucinated ghost in the pod giving the "use the Force" instruction. The structure isn't just present — it's legible, almost mythological. FROZEN brings a genuine dual-protagonist puzzle (who is actually driving the story — Anna or Elsa?) and a third act that plays out under its own rules rather than anybody's formula.

What starts to emerge is that the frameworks are more useful at some points than others. Vogler has real things to say about Act 3; Snyder's "finale — finish it" turns out to be pretty thin guidance for actually generating that emotional hit. And as Chas lands at the end of the episode: the three-act model itself might not be the useful unit. Sequences might be. Though you'll have to wait quite a few episodes until we tackle them!

The craft questions in this episode:

When a framework beat is present but compressed — a half-page refusal of the call, three lines of dialogue — what is it actually doing for the story?

FROZEN has a protagonist who barely changes and a secondary character who changes enormously. Who is actually driving? Does it matter?

If the three-act model makes Act 2 and Act 3 feel like a single blob, what happens if you think in sequences instead?

We also go deep on the frameworks' different coverage of the Dark Night of the Soul — which Stu argues is less a formula beat and more a question every writer should be able to answer for their character. What is the lowest point? What does it take to get out of it? That turns out to be something these frameworks are, and aren't, equipped to help with.

As always: SPOILERS ABOUND and all copyright material used under fair use for educational purposes.

LIKE THIS EPISODE?

Send us feedback.

Thanks to our Patrons, especially Khrob, Theis, Sandra, Jesse, Randy, Paulo, Thomas, Jennifer, Malay, Alexandre and Lily.

→ Read the transcript for this episode.

———

"I think as soon as you are stretching them in any way, they're losing their value as a rigid tool." — Chas Fisher @ 00:00:57

———

CHAPTERS

00:00:00 – Cold Open

00:00:14 – Do Blockbusters Follow the Guru Formulas?

00:00:22 – › Why tentpole films suit archetypal structures better than biopics

00:02:18 – › How animation's iterative process shapes story before the page is final

00:07:20 – GRAVITY

00:10:37 – › Opening and closing images as the survival-rebirth mirror

00:14:13 – › The catalyst as herald announcement and its limits as a call to adventure

00:19:54 – › Debate sequence as escalating refusal to acknowledge danger

00:24:45 – › Where Act 1 breaks and why both Vogler and Snyder readings are valid

00:33:48 – › The mentor's tether as umbilical cord and threshold crossing

00:39:44 – › Midpoint: Ryan assumes Matt's voice and starts driving the story

00:44:12 – › All is lost, Dark Night of the Soul, and the ghost-of-Obi-Wan solution

00:48:56 – › Road back, resurrection in the water, and return with the elixir

00:54:40 – FROZEN

00:57:45 – › Who is the protagonist when the secondary character has the bigger arc

01:00:01 – › Long first act, dual characters, and the coronation as catalyst

01:04:34 – › Tests, allies, and the promise of the premise in the mountain sequence

01:07:06 – › Midpoint: Anna struck in the heart and the false peak of the plan

01:12:05 – › Where Vogler's ordeal and Snyder's bad-guys-close-in diverge

01:17:08 – › Resurrection, the act of true love, and the elixir Elsa receives

01:21:45 – Key Learnings & Wrap Up

01:23:45 – Next Episode Preview & Sign Off

FILMS

GRAVITY (2013) — (w) Alfonso Cuaron, Jonas Cuaron (d) Alfonso Cuaron

FROZEN (2013) — (w) Jennifer Lee, Chris Buck, Jennifer Lee, Shane Morris (d) Chris Buck, Jennifer Lee

SCRIPTS

Study the script: GRAVITY (2013) — Alfonso Cuaron, Jonas Cuaron

Study the script: FROZEN (2013) — Jennifer Lee, Chris Buck, Jennifer Lee, Shane Morris

LINKS

Read: The Q&A with Jeff Goldsmith: Iron Man 3 Q&A

YouTube: Framestore's jaw-dropping Gravity Show and Tell (YouTube)