Draft Zero: a screenwriting podcast

DZ-120: Subtext is Overrated!


Listen Later

Listen if you're struggling to write subtext without it feeling forced!

Or, how focusing on good drama will result in good subtext. We often hear how subtext is important for good screenwriting. We're here to tell you it isn't. Good subtext is a result of good drama, and your focus should be on creating that good drama. But how?

In this episode, Chas Fisher and Stu Willis are joined by screenwriter and teacher Tom Vaughn (Winchester) to delve into the world of subtext.

We kick off the discussion by talking through Tom's article "Why Subtext is Overrated" and break down his core idea that subtext is a byproduct of character goals, tactics and fears.

We explore this further through close examination of "the other way" scene from MICHAEL CLAYTON, "the strudel" scene from INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS (both known for their subtext) and the "new years" sequence from THE SUBSTANCE.

Inevitably discussion also turns to the relationship of subtext to emotional truth, theme, symbolism, dramatic irony and filmmaker's subtext.

As always: SPOILERS ABOUND and all copyright material used under fair use for educational purposes.

LIKE THIS EPISODE?

  • Discuss with our Patrons on Patreon.
  • Watch and comment on YouTube.
  • Send us feedback.
  • Thanks to our Patrons, especially Lily, Paulo, Alexandre, Malay, Jennifer, Thomas, Randy, Jesse, Sandra, Theis and Khrob.

    Read the transcript for this episode.

    ———

    "You can't market subtext, man." — Tom Vaughn @ 00:36:51

    ———

    CHAPTERS

    • 00:00:20 – Intro: What is Subtext?
    • 00:00:21 – Cold Open
    • 00:18:59 – MICHAEL CLAYTON
    • 00:23:18 – › How character tactics generate subtext organically
    • 00:27:26 – › Scene structure breaks down three beats of deniability
    • 00:35:25 – › Subtext requires narrative groundwork to land
    • 00:42:59 – INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS
    • 00:46:34 – › French scene structure and dramatic setup
    • 00:53:38 – › Filmmaker subtext versus character-driven tension
    • 01:08:35 – › Writing the score: action lines as emotional music
    • 01:13:48 – THE SUBSTANCE
    • 01:17:41 – › Originality vs. universality in thematic storytelling
    • 01:23:42 – › Reading the script's literal big print as filmmaker subtext
    • 01:35:46 – › Irony and denial as competing interpretations of the ending
    • 01:42:23 – › Subtext through fear: the date scene as contrast
    • 01:46:13 – Wrap up & Key Learnings
    • 01:48:00 – › Two layers of subtext: character awareness vs. filmmaker control
    • 01:49:18 – › Subtext as spectrum between explicit and implicit meaning
    • FILMS

      • MICHAEL CLAYTON (2007) — (w) Tony Gilroy
      • INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS (2009) — (w) Quentin Tarantino
      • THE SUBSTANCE (2024) — (w) Coralie Fargeat
      • SCRIPTS

        • Study the script: MICHAEL CLAYTON (2007) — Tony Gilroy
        • Study the script: INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS (2009) — Quentin Tarantino
        • Study the script: THE SUBSTANCE (2024) — Coralie Fargeat
        • LINKS

          • Read: The New Literalism Plaguing Today's Biggest Movies
          • Read: Emotional Truth Over Subtext: Unlocking Compelling Scenes in Your Screenwriting
          • Website: Story and Plot
          • YouTube: Raising the Stakes - What is Subtext?
          • RELATED EPISODES

            • DZ-40: Tactics and Scenes
            • DZ-108: The Emotional Event with Judith Weston
            • DZ-119: Final Character Choices & Great Endings
            • ———

              More Draft Zero is brought to you by our awesome Patreons.

              If you enjoy the show, please leave a review on Apple Podcasts, a rating on Spotify, or a review on Podchaser.

              We are @stuwillis, @mehlsbells and @chasffisher on Twitter. You can find @draft_zero and @_shotzero on Instagram and Twitter.

              Full show notes at: https://draft-zero.com/2025/dz-120/

              ...more
              View all episodesView all episodes
              Download on the App Store

              Draft Zero: a screenwriting podcastBy Chas Fisher and Stuart Willis

              • 4.8
              • 4.8
              • 4.8
              • 4.8
              • 4.8

              4.8

              114 ratings


              More shows like Draft Zero: a screenwriting podcast

              View all
              The Business by KCRW

              The Business

              671 Listeners

              Scriptnotes Podcast by John August and Craig Mazin

              Scriptnotes Podcast

              2,434 Listeners

              The Director’s Cut - A DGA Podcast by Directors Guild of America

              The Director’s Cut - A DGA Podcast

              749 Listeners

              Talk Easy with Sam Fragoso by Higher Ground

              Talk Easy with Sam Fragoso

              1,489 Listeners

              The Watch by The Ringer

              The Watch

              5,410 Listeners

              Blank Check with Griffin & David by Blank Check Productions

              Blank Check with Griffin & David

              6,194 Listeners

              The A24 Podcast by A24

              The A24 Podcast

              1,083 Listeners

              Unspooled by Paul Scheer & Amy Nicholson | Realm

              Unspooled

              4,757 Listeners

              The Big Picture by The Ringer

              The Big Picture

              5,715 Listeners

              The Screenwriting Life with Meg LeFauve and Lorien McKenna by Meg LeFauve & Lorien McKenna

              The Screenwriting Life with Meg LeFauve and Lorien McKenna

              977 Listeners

              Team Deakins by James Ellis Deakins, Roger Deakins

              Team Deakins

              1,123 Listeners

              SmartLess by Jason Bateman, Sean Hayes, Will Arnett

              SmartLess

              58,226 Listeners

              The Prestige TV Podcast by The Ringer

              The Prestige TV Podcast

              1,701 Listeners

              The Town with Matthew Belloni by The Ringer

              The Town with Matthew Belloni

              1,121 Listeners

              Good Hang with Amy Poehler by The Ringer

              Good Hang with Amy Poehler

              12,456 Listeners