The Rational Reminder Podcast

Episode 374: The Underperformance of Target Date Funds


Listen Later

In this episode, we’re joined by David C. Brown, Associate Professor of Finance at the University of Arizona, for a deep dive into the mechanics, performance, and pitfalls of target date funds (TDFs)—the most common investment vehicle in U.S. retirement accounts. David has spent years researching glide paths, benchmarking methods, and industry practices to uncover whether these “set it and forget it” funds actually serve investors well. We unpack why benchmarking TDFs is so difficult, what really drives their underperformance, and how tactical deviations from strategic glide paths often harm investors. David explains how fees, active management, and fund structure combine to create persistent drag—and why dispersion across TDF providers is shockingly wide. We also discuss behavioral challenges, the influence of glide path design, and whether innovations like “indexing the indexers” could improve outcomes. David also shares insights on his side project, the Microsoft Excel Collegiate Challenge, where students compete in gamified problem-solving competitions (yes, Excel on ESPN!), and reflects on his own definition of success. This conversation sheds light on a massively important—but often misunderstood—corner of the retirement landscape, giving investors and plan sponsors practical tools to demand better.

 

Key Points From This Episode:

(0:05:20) What a Qualified Default Investment Alternative (QDIA) is and why TDFs became the default in 2006.

(0:05:50) How target date funds work as “one-stop shops” for retirement savings.

(0:07:12) The glide path concept: why equity allocations decrease with age.

(0:08:04) Why comparing TDFs is hard—fund families design glide paths differently.

(0:10:37) David’s benchmarking approach: replicating TDFs with index funds.

(0:15:13) The performance gap: ~1% annual underperformance versus replicating benchmarks.

(0:15:50) Main culprits: higher fees (~55 bps) and poor active management (~45 bps).

(0:18:20) Good news: costs have declined—but dispersion across providers remains massive.

(0:20:09) Evidence of wild return differences: up to 23% in a single month across vintages.

(0:21:32) Why plan sponsors and investors aren’t reacting to poor performance.

(0:25:33) The debate over optimal glide paths—and why the jury is still out.

(0:29:15) Tactical deviations: managers shifting allocations beyond the strategic design.

(0:33:06) These tactical moves hurt performance (~10 bps on average).

(0:35:49) Evidence of return chasing in TDF management.

(0:39:07) Big picture: TDFs are a huge improvement over money market defaults, but dispersion and inefficiency remain.

(0:42:48) David’s views on Scott Cederberg’s 100% equity lifecycle portfolio research.

(0:45:22) Behavioral challenges: why defaults and illiquidity may help investors stay the course.

(0:50:57) The Microsoft Excel Collegiate Challenge—Excel as an esport.

(0:52:50) How David defines success: balance, impact, and growth.

Links From Today’s Episode: Meet with PWL Capital: https://calendly.com/d/3vm-t2j-h3p

Rational Reminder on iTunes — https://itunes.apple.com/ca/podcast/the-rational-reminder-podcast/id1426530582.

Rational Reminder Website — https://rationalreminder.ca/ 

Rational Reminder on Instagram — https://www.instagram.com/rationalreminder/

Rational Reminder on X — https://x.com/RationalRemind

Rational Reminder on TikTok — www.tiktok.com/@rationalreminder

Rational Reminder on YouTube — https://www.youtube.com/channel/

Rational Reminder Email — [email protected]

Benjamin Felix — https://pwlcapital.com/our-team/

Benjamin on X — https://x.com/benjaminwfelix

Benjamin on LinkedIn — https://www.linkedin.com/in/benjaminwfelix/

Cameron Passmore — https://pwlcapital.com/our-team/

Cameron on X — https://x.com/CameronPassmore

Cameron on LinkedIn — https://www.linkedin.com/in/cameronpassmore/

 

Editing and post-production work for this episode was provided by The Podcast Consultant (https://thepodcastconsultant.com)

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Rational Reminder PodcastBy Benjamin Felix, Cameron Passmore, and Dan Bortolotti

  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9

4.9

421 ratings


More shows like The Rational Reminder Podcast

View all
Masters in Business by Bloomberg

Masters in Business

2,172 Listeners

Build Wealth Canada Podcast by Kornel Szrejber: Investor

Build Wealth Canada Podcast

16 Listeners

The Meb Faber Show - Better Investing by The Idea Farm

The Meb Faber Show - Better Investing

933 Listeners

Animal Spirits Podcast by The Compound

Animal Spirits Podcast

2,015 Listeners

Bogleheads On Investing Podcast by bogleheads

Bogleheads On Investing Podcast

609 Listeners

The Long View by Morningstar

The Long View

893 Listeners

Sound Investing by Paul Merriman

Sound Investing

340 Listeners

Excess Returns by Excess Returns

Excess Returns

79 Listeners

The Rob Berger Show by Rob Berger

The Rob Berger Show

188 Listeners

Risk Parity Radio by Frank Vasquez

Risk Parity Radio

264 Listeners

The Canadian Investor by Braden Dennis & Simon Belanger

The Canadian Investor

86 Listeners

Ask The Compound by The Compound

Ask The Compound

320 Listeners

The Morgan Housel Podcast by Morgan Housel

The Morgan Housel Podcast

1,039 Listeners

TLDR by Devin Friedman, Sarah Rieger, Matthew Karasz

TLDR

29 Listeners

The Wealthy Barber Podcast by The Wealthy Barber Inc.

The Wealthy Barber Podcast

46 Listeners