The Catholic Thing

Eucharistic Faith and the Survey


Listen Later

By Randall Smith
A disturbing 2019 Pew survey found that only a third of Catholics believe that the Eucharist is truly the Body and Blood of Christ.
The results of such surveys, of course, depend on what questions were asked and to whom. So, for example, if people were asked, "Do you believe in transubstantiation?" some might have had the same reaction I did when I was challenged recently whether I believed in "impanation."
What the heck is impanation? I looked it up. "Impanation," as it turns out, is the claim that Christ is "in" the bread and wine, but it's still bread and wine. (The "pan" part refers to "bread.") So no, I do not accept "impanation." It could have been something innocent, but it isn't. And I wasn't going to agree to it until I understood it.
Someone thought I was guilty of impanation because I had written that Christ was "truly present in the bread and wine." My focus was on His being "truly present." But strictly speaking, it is no longer bread and wine; it is the Body and Blood of Christ. It would make no sense to say that the Body and Blood of Christ are "truly present" in the Body and Blood of Christ. So as a shorthand, we say that Christ is present in the bread and wine.
A young woman once said to me, "I could never be Catholic because I just can't accept the doctrine of transubstantiation." "Wait," I said. "Let's take a step back." The doctrine of transubstantiation was an attempt to describe the "Real Presence" of Christ in the Eucharist using the categories of medieval physics. The substance is now the Body and Blood of Christ, but the accidents of bread and wine remain.
But the point of that doctrine is to express what it means to say that Christ is really present in the bread and wine - or what used to be bread and wine and still looks like bread and wine, but is now, in substance the Body and Blood of Christ. "Transubstantiation" may sound dodgy, but it actually makes a lot of sense.
My friend made the usual reply. "Well, I believe He is spiritually present." "No, hold on," I said. "That's not being really present. In the early Church, they clearly affirmed their belief that Christ was really present in the Eucharist, as present as He was during life and as present as He was when He rose from the dead."
That was not easy to accept then, and it's not easy to accept now. It's why many left Christ when He insisted "You must eat my flesh and drink my blood," an abandonment that would be hard to imagine if he had meant that you need only do this spiritually. I mean, he could have said, "Wait, I don't mean my actual body and blood; that's just gross. No, I mean this symbolically, metaphorically." That, presumably, would have solved the problem nicely. But that's not what happened.
"So, let's work backward," I said. "Do you believe that Christ lives, that He truly conquered death and was raised from the dead? Or do you think that He is only symbolically still alive - like "alive in our hearts"? "No," she said, "I believe that Christ rose from the dead and ascended to the right hand of the Father. I say it in the Creed every Sunday at church."
"Okay, do you believe that Christ really rose bodily from the dead, so that the Apostle Thomas could probe the nail marks on his hands and the spear wound in his side? Or was Christ 'present' in the room only metaphorically, because they remembered Him in love, or something of that sort?" No, she would not accept this thin gruel of "symbolically" or "metaphorically" present to the Apostles.
"So if you believe God really became Incarnate, and if you believe that Jesus Christ was God Incarnate, the Word made flesh; and if you believe that Christ truly rose from the dead, not merely 'spiritually' or 'metaphorically,' but really, as a unity of body and soul; and if you know that this was the faith of the Apostles and the early Church; and if you recognize that the doctrine of "transubstantiation" was an honest attempt to describe the Church's belief that Christ is tr...
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Catholic ThingBy The Catholic Thing

  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6

4.6

28 ratings


More shows like The Catholic Thing

View all
Dr Taylor Marshall Podcast by Dr. Taylor Marshall

Dr Taylor Marshall Podcast

4,044 Listeners

The Thomistic Institute by The Thomistic Institute

The Thomistic Institute

747 Listeners

First Things Podcast by First Things

First Things Podcast

713 Listeners

Pints With Aquinas by Matt Fradd

Pints With Aquinas

6,579 Listeners

All Things Catholic with Dr. Edward Sri by Ascension

All Things Catholic with Dr. Edward Sri

1,345 Listeners

The Catholic Current by The Station of the Cross

The Catholic Current

384 Listeners

The Road to Emmaus with Scott Hahn by Scott Hahn

The Road to Emmaus with Scott Hahn

38 Listeners

Return To Tradition by Anthony Stine

Return To Tradition

350 Listeners

American Catholic History by Noelle & Tom Crowe

American Catholic History

823 Listeners

Godsplaining by Dominican Friars Province of St. Joseph

Godsplaining

1,227 Listeners

U.S. Grace Force with Fr. Richard Heilman and Doug Barry by U.S. Grace Force

U.S. Grace Force with Fr. Richard Heilman and Doug Barry

568 Listeners

Evangelization & Culture Podcast by Word on Fire Institute

Evangelization & Culture Podcast

202 Listeners

The Pillar Podcast by The Pillar Podcast

The Pillar Podcast

650 Listeners

Catholic Saints by Augustine Institute

Catholic Saints

1,044 Listeners

The LOOPcast by CatholicVote

The LOOPcast

723 Listeners