The Catholic Thing
Download on the App Store

The Catholic Thing episodes

  • Pope Leo's Latin American Triumph – and Challenges
    By Robert Royal
    But first a note: We're moving along well in our fundraising. Still, we really need more of you to step up now if we're going to be able to continue bringing you the many different "things" - from the columns to news and commentary, to podcasts and courses, even a weekly commentary on the Catechism - produced by TCT and the Faith & Reason Institute. There's great need for all of this - and more - in both the Church and the world. We're not giving up on any of it. In fact, we're planning on doing even more in the year to come. So please, if you recognize that need, here's a chance to do something about it. Be generous, be part of the work of The Catholic Thing.
    Now for today's column...
    It's been a real pleasure this past week to watch Pope Leo's impressive trip to Latin America. If there was any question about his health, the way he only seemed to gather energy as he made his way through Uruguay and Argentina and, finally, to the cheering crowds in Peru – a 12-day schedule that would have exhausted most people half his age – has demonstrated beyond doubt that, at least for the moment, we have a very vigorous pontiff.
    The media tended to focus on stray political remarks that the pope made (universal health care in Uruguay, justice for environmentalists killed in Peru) – the usual throwaway lines. His specifically Catholic messages were more interesting: prayer and fasting for vocations in Montevideo; not ignoring doctrine for "pastoral" reasons in Buenos Aires (a corrective to Pope Francis?); and staying faithful to Jesus' Church in Peru (Protestantism is growing throughout Latin America).
    These are all good words, but it would be good to see them followed up with strong action – especially with appointments in the same vein to the Curia and in nominations to the College of Cardinals. And with attention to several challenges elsewhere in the world.
    A wise Italian friend said something to me in Rome last week that's obvious, once you think about it, though we rarely do. The Vatican is the nerve center of Christianity and, as such, tries to advance Catholic spiritual and moral/cultural goals. But it is also a state and, as such, also seeks to have good diplomatic relations with other states and even large cultural groups.
    This has its positive side – Rome can be a disinterested broker when international tensions arise and has often played that role historically. But it also has costs, if badly pursued – witness the disastrous, still "secret" accord with China, or the way the two most recent popes have ignored plain historical truth and tried to make peace with – even deny threats from – Islam.
    Just this week, the Observatory on Intolerance and Discrimination against Christians in Europe (OIDAC), in its 2026 report on anti-Christian "hate crimes" (using the European Union's own criteria) found 2,465 instances in Europe. The breakdown by country is interesting:

    It's no accident that the countries that have permitted the largest influx of illegal migration from Islamic states – France, the UK, Germany, and Austria – have the largest numbers of incidents. Islamic radicals are not responsible for all these attacks, of course, but it would be very naïve to dismiss the correlation.
    Pope Leo has spoken several times about the need to be "less afraid" of Islam. The facts on the ground – rarely reported or played down by major news sources – say that it's simply truthful to have greater concern about Islam, both for what it's doing in the secular world and for how treating Islam as just another of the "world religions" is having tangible consequences for Christians.
    Aid to the Church in Need, too, has just issued a biennial report about Christian persecution in the world. (See our podcast with the main author of the report here.) Christians are under threat in 165 countries, over 220 million worldwide. You sometimes get the impression that, like European governments and the media, the Vatican doesn't want to call attent...
    9 min
  • Reclaiming Political Prudence A unified progressive government in 2029 would possess the unchecked power to permanently alter the American constitutional order. Consider the consequences: Fiscal Insolvency Through Entitlement Expansion. Implementing singl
    By Sister Renée Mirkes, OSF
    But first a note from Robert Royal: There are likely to be many radical challenges to faith, morals, and good public order in the months and years to come. But Sr. Renee Mirkes provides us with a crucial reminder for our time and all times today: The way to face such challenges is always the same: prayer, cultivation of the virtues, recognizing the truth, striving to follow it, and trusting in God. That's a whole program that we'll be following here at TCT whoever is in power in the Church or the world. We believe you should do that as well. And we ask for your help in our end-of-the year fundraising campaign so that we can all remain steady and faithful, whatever the times may bring.
    Now for today's column...
    In the wake of the 2026 midterm elections, restoring constitutional stability and economic vitality in 2028 requires voters to recover the classical virtue of prudence – looking past immediate frustration over everyday prices to confront the historical lessons and long-term structural dangers of progressive governance.
    In classical philosophy, Aristotle and Thomas Aquinas crowned prudence as the "charioteer of the virtues." Far from common misconceptions of mere timidity or caution, prudence is right reason applied to action – the intellectual discipline that allows citizens and statesmen to align immediate decisions with enduring truth.
    Renaissance artists, notably Titian in his Allegory of Prudence (see below), captured this virtue as a figure with three faces: one looking backward into memory, one looking straight ahead at the present, and one looking forward with foresight. Beneath Titian's canvas runs a warning that reads like a civic mandate for contemporary America: "From the experience of the past, the present acts prudently, lest it spoil future actions."
    Earlier this month, millions of American voters cast their midterm ballots while looking through only one of those ways – the present. Frustrated by the lingering sting of high grocery bills, housing costs, and everyday living expenses, the electorate handed Democrats sweeping majorities in both the House of Representatives and the Senate for the incoming 120th Congress.
    Yet as the dust settles, a sober look through all three faces of prudence reveals why 2028 represents a decisive crossroads for the American republic.
    To exercise prudence today, we must first see the current political landscape clearly, with intelligentia– i.e., with neither panic nor complacency. When the 120th Congress convenes in January, the newly empowered Democratic majority will immediately push an ambitious progressive agenda.
    Congressional leaders have already signaled plans to advance sweeping labor overhauls like the PRO Act, aggressive climate and regulatory mandates, higher taxes on investment and job creators, and partisan budget reconciliation packages. Meanwhile, committee chairs are preparing a wave of subpoenas and oversight battles aimed at paralyzing the executive branch.
    For the next two years, however, the most radical elements of that legislative blueprint will hit an immovable constitutional wall: President Donald Trump's veto pen.
    Because Democrats fell well short of the two-thirds supermajorities required to override a presidential veto – and lack the 60 Senate votes needed to break a filibuster on non-budgetary bills – their sweeping proposals on policing, border enforcement, and entitlement expansion will largely remain messaging bills rather than enacted law.
    Here lies the subtle trap for the imprudent voter. Because the presidential veto will block the sharpest edges of the progressive agenda over the next twenty-four months, voters may be lulled into believing that a Democrat Congress is harmless – or worse, that the resulting legislative gridlock is the fault of the White House.
    In reality, the next two years will serve as a dress rehearsal – a blueprint of what a unified progressive government intends to enact the moment the presi...
    10 min
  • Struggling with the "Noonday Demon"
    By Zachary Naccash
    Among the Seven Deadly Sins, the sin of Sloth, or acedia in the Greek tradition, is frequently mistaken for simple laziness. The image of an indolent teenager comes to mind – not merely someone who resists work, but is also contemptuous of it. But for the ancient and medieval Christian tradition, mere laziness and Sloth are very different.
    Thomas Aquinas, following John Damascene, defines Sloth as a kind of "sorrow" for spiritual good, and explicitly distinguishes it from mere laziness. Sloth is a kind of listlessness that man feels when the good he ought to seek, rather than inspiring him to pursue it, causes him to feel more acutely his own weariness at the prospect. Far from being mere unwillingness to work, sloth is a sorrow or weariness in the very face of spiritual good.
    We have largely forgotten about sloth in the modern world, which is not only unfortunate but dangerous. Misdiagnosis of any disease leads to ineffective remedies. As Boethius observes, "If you want the physician to be of assistance to you, you must make your disease known to him."
    The world of today is chronically online. We have exchanged social life for 'social' media – replacing the spiritual goods of friendship, contemplation, and interiority with flickering images on a screen, which offer the shelter of anonymity, but inflame envy by fixing attention on material things, and spare us the discomfort of being alone with ourselves.
    Modern man has built for himself a technological Platonic cave, and our eyes have adjusted to the dark.
    While today's world may be especially suited to inducing acedia, this vice is by no means unique to our age. Among the earliest spiritual writers to treat acedia was Evagrius Ponticus, a student of St. Gregory Nazianzen and an influential fourth-century monk.
    In his Praktikos, a work composed to aid monks in pursuing a life of holiness, Evagrius offers some advice to the monk struggling with the "noonday demon" (i.e., Sloth), "who is most grievous of all."
    In the first place, Evagrius tells us to live as if we're going to die tomorrow, but to treat our bodies as though we're going to live for a long time. Meditating on death is a common theme of Christian spirituality, and care for the body is generally good advice. But both are especially pertinent to overcoming the noonday demon.

    On the one hand, meditation on death – and realizing that it could be tomorrow – spurs us to overcome the sorrow of the moment and pursue spiritual goods, rather than shrink from the effort of achieving them.
    On the other hand, acedia is a kind of sadness and, so, a passion. Like all passions, it is closely tied to the body. Evagrius' advice to take care of one's body is, therefore, a practical remedy: you need to care for your body because doing so will help keep you in good spirits. Poor diet, lack of sleep, and a lack of physical activity will all contribute to a feeling of listlessness and sadness, without the noonday demon having to lift a finger. Evagrius' advice, then, is to take good care of your body in such a way as to make the demon work hard to tempt you to sadness.
    Evagrius' second piece of advice is to remain in place. For the monks that Evagrius was addressing, there was a strong temptation to leave their cells, to wander about looking for another monk who might distract them, and to gaze up at the sun and count how many hours were left in the day.
    While we are similarly tempted, today the temptation often manifests itself in constantly pulling out a phone or glancing at a smartwatch: "What time is it and how long have I been working?" "Do I have any notifications?" "Just a couple of reels, and then I will get to work."
    The pull of the phone can be intense, distracting not merely from work but even from actual social activities. It is a common sight today to see a group of young people out together, but communally ignoring each other as they stare into their phones. Evagrius' advice here is basically: enduran...
    7 min
  • Theological Reflections on 'The Martyrs of the New Millennium'
    By Cardinal Gerhard L. Mueller
    But first a note from Robert Royal: We're delighted that Cardinal Mueller, the former prefect of the then-Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, made time to give us these reflections in Rome this week on the deep theology of martyrdom as well as its practical consequences. Frankly, we can only do things like this because of friends like him, and you. We'll pause tomorrow in our campaign for the Sabbath. All the more reason to do your bit for TCT – TODAY!
    And another note for today's column: The following is a shortened version of the Cardinal's presentation in Rome earlier this week at an event presenting the Italian translation of Robert Royal's book on recent martyrs. Now for today's column...
    The Church's unity with Christ, her Head, and the truth of Revelation are demonstrated not only in the continuing Apostolic Tradition of the depositum fidei, but also in the following of the Lord, Crucified and Risen. In the "farewell discourses" before His saving Passion, which will redeem all humanity from sin and eternal death, Jesus says to His disciples and to all Christians until his return: A servant is not greater than his master: If they have persecuted me, they will persecute you also. (John 15:20)
    The Truth of the eschatological Revelation of God in Christ, which is the only way to truth and eternal life, is demonstrated in the miracle of the steadfastness of his saints unto the death and even the bloody death of his martyrs and confessors. The Catholic martyrs of the twenty-first century are important not only because of their historical interest, but because they also belong to the theological patrimony of the Church – part of the same mission to be the universal sacrament of the salvation of the world in Christ.
    The martyrs in the first three centuries after Christ (from the beginnings until Emperor Diocletian's attempt at the total extinction of Christianity) bear resemblances to the desire for the destruction of Christianity by the atheistic and anti-human ideologies of National Socialism and Communism, and even to political (but pseudo-religious) Islamism and the neo-socialist wokism of our days. All this highlights that martyrdom does not only concern people who are simply victims because of their firm convictions, but makes it clear that every martyr is such because he is a witness to Christ, who is the Incarnate Word, the only Redeemer of humanity and the only mediator between God and man.
    The devil is the father of lies and a murderer from the beginning, and the ideologues and leaders of totalitarian states have always been his puppets. Lies and death are thus always the weapons with which the Evil One fights against God's elect. The fact that Christianity is still the most persecuted religious community in the world does not derive from the plunge of contemporary civilization back into barbarism, but from the action of the Evil One.
    Some Christians in the West, unfortunately, still confuse their faith with the achievements of the Enlightenment, thinking that they can circumvent the scandal and shame of the Cross, by contemporaries, defining Christianity only as a phenomenon that sprang from bourgeois-Christian civilization with humanist and immanentist objectives.
    If this were the case, the Church would only have the right to be recognized by any State or institution as a humanitarian aid organization, an idea that is cherished and often propagated by some information networks.
    The Church of Christ, however, has as its sole objective in its journey through time to follow God in Jesus Christ, the Master and Lord who is despised, persecuted, and shamefully executed as an evildoer by the world. This human-divine dynamic leads to a faith that overwhelms a world blinded by the temptation of power and enslaved by desires that it cannot control.
    This faith does not eliminate the natural fear of physical torture and psychological violence, of social exclusion and violent death, but ...
    16 min
  • Hell as an Expression of Mercy
    By John M. Grondelski
    But first a note from Robert Royal:
    Christianity is a complete key to life precisely because it affirms not only the truths of Revelation, but the consequences that follow from those truths. And as Dr. Grondelski says today, that means not only accepting the words in Scripture that Jesus tells us about Heaven and Hell - words many today would prefer not to hear. We also have to see deeply into the teaching because if our acts are not free or do not turn us towards real Good and Evil, our very dignity as human beings would be diminished.
    God took a big chance in making us free, and the jury is still out on how many of us will accept that challenge as He intended, which is why we need saints, doctors, scholars, and even TCT writers to remind us constantly of the great drama of human life. If you want to know more of this - and I know most of you do - we need your help. It's that time of year. Please, help us to make sure TCT is here for the rest of this year and for many years to come. Do your part towards keeping the spirit alive in our Church and our world.
    Now for today's column...
    November in the Catholic Church has a decidedly eschatological cast. The month is dedicated to praying for the souls in Purgatory, while the end-of-Ordinary-Time readings – Sundays and weekdays – focus on the "Last Things," i.e., death, judgment, heaven, and hell.
    In some sense, November's traditional eschatological focus rubs against common approaches encountered in the rest of the year in post-Vatican II Catholicism. Critics decry the almost instant canonization tone of many funeral homilies, while the lack of attention to the sacrificial nature of the Eucharist means many contemporary Catholics would be hard pressed to explain the necessity of prayers for the faithful departed.
    The ancient heresy of apocatastasis – the idea that everybody will eventually be saved – persists in a kind of "Catholic version" that skates at the edge of heresy: "dare we hope" that all will be saved?
    Yes, we hope. But the usual expressions of that hope seem to be a wink and nod that the "hope" is in fact our belief, constrained only by the continued bonds of ecclesiastical teach
    ing holding us back from full-throated affirmation. Pope Francis repeatedly veered in this direction. Yes, we concede that theoretically Hell might exist, but we really expect it to be empty.
    The practical expression comes from our pastoral refusal to talk about Hell as real, to mention Purgatory only in November, and to canonize the deceased while "celebrating their life" in our funerary rituals. It all collides with St. Paul's sober injunction to "work out your own salvation with fear and trembling." (Philippians 2:12)
    This November, let me suggest that hell is an expression of God's mercy.
    That idea is hardly novel, though likely not understandable to many today. Its usual expression involves some combination of anthropology and morality. As Heaven is not so much a "place" as a "state" of loving God, justice – towards God and towards the sinner – cannot force love out of one who chooses not to love.
    Heaven or Hell ultimately depend on taking seriously the reality of human freedom, which finds its ultimate challenge in love, and which then includes the possibility of not loving. It remains a matter of justice and love: justice in respect of one's free choice, love in the sense of God not forcing Himself unrequitedly on the one who does not love Him.
    While this explanation is traditional, it does not necessarily ring true to today's ears. Most people seem to imagine a "happily ever after" scenario where, somehow, God's persistence will ultimately triumph over human obstinacy, bringing all to true love of God.
    If human life is any indication – and many of these same people are big on "experience" – we know that a lover's diligence notwithstanding, there are cases where that love is refused and refused definitively. Partisans of this view do not explain how God somehow ...
    10 min
  • Blood in the Streets
    By Stephen P. White
    But first a note from Robert Royal: We had a strong start to our end-of-year fundraising yesterday despite the federal holiday. But we need an even stronger response from all the friends of TCT out there. Today. Not to toot our own horn, but we try every day to do our part in bringing you ideas, news, and observations about the Church and the world that you can't get anywhere else. Will you do your part? Click the button, be generous, advance the work of The Catholic Thing. Now for today's column...
    One of the maddening things about the mass media by which we are daily inundated is the way it plays on our propensity to get riled up by people or events that have very little to do with us, and over which we have no control whatsoever. The "news cycle" is, often as not, driven by an unhappy oscillation between impotence and rage.
    Occasionally, though, some news story or other really hits home. For me, the terrible events that unfolded last Saturday in Krakow, Poland were very close to home, indeed. Sorrow and contemplation are the order of the day. I have seen enough of rage, impotent or otherwise.
    For the past two decades, Krakow has been something of a summer home for me. I have gotten to know the Old Town particularly well. I have many friends there. I know the churches and cafes, the restaurants and shops, museums and markets of Krakow as well as I know those where I live in the suburbs of Washington.
    In all the years that I have been traveling to Krakow, I can remember precisely one instance of violence involving a firearm – and that was an armed robbery in which no shots were fired.
    So a mass shooting like the one which occurred last week – an act of terrorism which has, as of this writing, left six people dead and another 16 wounded – while disturbingly familiar in some places (including, alas, the United States) is utterly shocking and unheard of in a place like Krakow. More than just monstrously inhumane, the violence was decidedly un-Polish.
    It's not just that the shooting occurred in a place familiar to me, or even that I have friends and colleagues who were so close they could hear the gunfire and sirens all too clearly. I was shocked to see videos of bloodshed in the Main Square. I was moved especially by videos of the conclusion of the chase: a police officer, armed only with a pistol, staggering then kneeling through pain and loss of blood from multiple gunshot wounds, finally subduing his heavily armed and armored adversary.
    I know that place. The whole dreadful scene came to an end on the street where I live when I am in Krakow, 200 yards or so from my front door. And that intersection, where I have crossed the street on my way to breakfast hundreds of times, is now plastered across global media in a scene of both depravity and heroism. As I said, it hits very close to home.
    In the past few days I have thought more than once of Krakow's violent history. If a mass-shooting of the sort just witnessed is out of the ordinary (to commit a gross understatement) the city has known its share of wanton violence.
    One of the videos from this week shows bystanders huddling for safety in a church as the shooter raced past in a car, pursued by police. The church building where they sought shelter – St. Andrew's in Grodzka Street, survived the Mongol invasion in the thirteenth century.

    The police chase passed the Wawel Castle, over which Nazi soldiers once raised the hideous swastika. As the chase sped past the castle, it also passed St. Giles church (where for many years, the Dominicans offered Mass in English every Sunday morning). Outside St. Giles stands a stark monument to the thousands of Poles murdered by Soviet agents in the forests of Katyn.
    When the shooter was finally stopped several hundred yards later, he was about to cross into the district of Kazimierz, where, within living memory, thousands of Krakow's Jews were huddled into a ghetto before being liquidated by the Gestapo.
    Yesterday, Nove...
    8 min
  • To Set Our Lands in Order
    By Robert Royal
    But first A confession from Robert Royal: I am enthusiastic, perhaps too enthusiastic, about this whole line of thought and life because it's precisely what we have been trying to do for almost two decades here at The Catholic Thing. And in my own stumbling, piecemeal fashion, I'd earlier made my way towards these truths despite countervailing winds at various educational institutions. The need is only more urgent now. I'm convinced enough of its critical importance at this moment in history – indeed, in every age – that I feel justified in coming to you, our dear TCT readers, just a few times a year to ask for your financial support. And it's that time again.
    The coming year is going to be marked by various kinds of public chaos – all the more reason that we strive to construct every bit of personal and social order that we can, each of us, in whatever circumstances we find ourselves. Only the Catholic thing, the fullness of our tradition, is up to the task. TCT will be here, every morning, 365 days a year, for you, bringing you the best opinion and commentary, in a readable format, of which we're capable. As I always say during our funding campaigns, I know you readers understand why we're here, why you're here, and why your support is so vital. So please, do what you always do. Give generously – in whatever way is best for you – to The Catholic Thing.
    Now for today's column...
    Rome is often rainy and cold in November, but the past few days it's been mostly sunny and warm. The pope may be in Latin America, but the Eternal City continues to draw huge crowds, even in his absence – to judge by the masses in every public and private space – comparable with those he's drawing (as I write) in Uruguay and Argentina. It's a somewhat reassuring thought that whoever is running things at any given moment, the Catholic barque sails on – in Rome and the whole world. But there are also dangerous shoals below the surface.
    One of the more surprising things I've seen in Rome this trip is a whole series of one-person tents set up at night between the pillars of the colonnades at St. Peter's. This is new to me.

    No doubt the people who organized this mean well. But like the people who distribute "clean" drug paraphernalia in American cities, they're enabling the very behavior that they want to remedy. In a civilized society, or a Church that truly cares for the poor, institutions are set up – and funds found – so that people (most of whom need drug and psychological counseling) don't live on the street, to their detriment and ours.
    I'm in Rome this week for publication of the Italian translation of my book on The Martyrs of the New Millennium, but also to participate in a conference sponsored by the U.S. National Endowment for the Humanities (NEH) on "Classical Foundations and Moral Authority." The two events are not unrelated, or unrelated to social and Church reform. Without clear foundations and principles, our moral efforts – as we see all around us these days, not least in piazza San Pietro – decay into mere niceness and incoherence. And without people willing to sacrifice, suffer, even die for the truth, even the loftiest intellectual and ethical principles remain mere ideas.
    We just celebrated the feast of St. Charles Borromeo. If anyone was a Catholic Reformer, he was. He took on the lazy, the time-servers, the corrupt, and the decadent in Rome and Milan (his archdiocese); helped organize the final session of the Council of Trent; and took a major role in producing the Tridentine Catechism, which was aimed at forming priests, who in his view, were then poorly educated and, therefore unprepared, to deal with people's deepest needs.
    Though heir to the fortune of one of the noblest and richest families in Renaissance Italy, he lived simply and wasn't afraid to get his hands dirty. When the plague struck Milan in 1576, he remained in the city and organized relief efforts for tens of thousands of people, often paying for ...
    10 min
  • Holy Wars, Just Wars, and Other Wars
    By Luis E. Lugo
    In his recent video message to participants at the World Day of Prayer for Peace held in Assisi, Italy, Pope Leo strongly condemned religious justifications for war. As he stated, "War can never be waged in the name of God," which is why, he explained, "there is no such thing as a holy war."
    The pope left unclear at whom he was directing his remarks. Was it Muslim jihadists, who, following the example of the prophet Mohammed, view war as a legitimate means of extending the boundaries of Islam? Or perhaps Patriarch Kirill and the Russian Orthodox Church's assertion that "from the spiritual and moral point of view, the Special Military Operation [the Kremlin's preferred euphemism for its invasion of Ukraine] is a Holy War"?
    Be that as it may, some will be inclined to see the pope's remarks as an indirect swipe at the just war tradition. That would be in keeping with the way some put a pacifist gloss on the pope's statement in Magnifica humanitas that the just war tradition is "outdated." That reading is very misleading, as I have argued before in this space.
    One would think that Pope Leo laid to rest such speculations with his address to the delegation of the Military Ordinariate of Portugal, which he delivered just two months after issuing his encyclical. On that occasion, the pope praised the military's "noble mission" of defending the sovereignty of their homeland and ensuring the security of their fellow citizens. Referencing Jesus's encounter with the Roman centurion in Capernaum, he offered high praise for the values of military service: obedience, discipline, renunciation, loyalty, comradeship, dedication, responsibility, and courage.
    Nevertheless, some concerns along these lines are not entirely unfounded. At times Pope Leo has made statements that lend themselves to a pacifist interpretation. Moreover, the views of his predecessor on this issue cast a long shadow on the current pontificate and continue to engender suspicion.
    A fair assessment of Pope Francis's words and actions strongly suggests that he intended to move the Church in a pacifist direction. In his 2020 encyclical Fratelli tutti, for example, he wrote that given the brutality of modern combat, it had now become "very difficult" for countries to invoke just war principles to justify engaging in violent conflict.
    Then, in a March 2022 video call with Russian Orthodox Patriarch Kirill to discuss the war in Ukraine, the Holy Father went from "very difficult" to outright denying the possibility of a just war. As he affirmed during the call, "there was a time, even in our Churches, when people spoke of a holy war or a just war. Today we cannot speak in this manner."

    As if to leave no doubt about his meaning, Pope Francis emphatically declared that "wars are always unjust. . . .War is never the way." Any impartial observer would have to conclude that the pope had come to espouse a functional, if not yet a principled, pacifist position.
    It is instructive to note how Pope Francis juxtaposed the terms holy wars and just wars in the above quotation. It is generally understood that holy wars are undertaken on religious grounds and for explicitly religious purposes. By contrast, just wars follow the requirements of the natural law and aim at the more modest goal of ensuring the well-ordered peace of the temporal city, its tranquillitas ordinis, in St. Augustine's famous formulation.
    Is the idea of a just war to be rejected because it is holy war "adjacent," to borrow a phrase from woke ideology? We see an analogous situation today in the way some people use the words proselytizing and evangelizing interchangeably. By so conflating them, they subtly impute the coercive, manipulative connotations of the former to the latter's entirely legitimate (and God-ordained) efforts at conversion.
    It's also worth recalling the context in which Pope Francis uttered those words – a Russian invasion of Ukraine that the pope himself described as a clear-cut case of ...
    8 min
  • The View From Above All Religion
    By Randall Smith
    Although I will be referring to a comment made by a political candidate, my point is religious, not political. For this reason, I delayed submitting this article until after the election.
    Senator-elect James Talarico has made, in the name of his "Christianity," any number of comments that would be offensive to orthodox Catholics and many other Christians. But to be fair, so do many other politicians. Misrepresenting Christian teaching for one's own political ends is almost as common as political attack ads.
    And most of what candidate Talarico has said about his brand of Christianity has been reported widely and is, by now, well-trodden ground. So allow me to draw our attention instead to something he said that, at least at first glance, seems much less offensive. As we will see, however, appearances can be deceiving. And the statement is worthy of comment because the sentiment is more common.
    In one interview, Mr. Talarico mentioned that he thinks of all the religions as forming a circle around a central something. Each one sees that something in its own way, but they aren't always aware that they are all looking at the same thing. What Mr. Talarico and those who share his view don't seem to understand is how presumptuous and offensive this is to each one of the devoted religious believers in that circle – not just Christians, but Jews, Muslims, Hindus, Jains, Buddhists, Confucians, and all the rest.
    As usual, G.K. Chesterton identified the problem. In Orthodoxy, he notes: "There is a phrase of facile liberality uttered again and again at ethical societies and parliaments of religion: 'the religions of the earth differ in rites and forms, but they are the same in what they teach.' It is false; it is the opposite of the fact. The religions of the earth do not greatly differ in rites and forms; they do greatly differ in what they teach."
    Almost every great religion, points out Chesterton, works with "priests, scriptures, altars, sworn brotherhoods. . . .They agree in the mode of teaching; what they differ about is the thing to be taught." To update Chesterton's example, saying that all religions teach the same thing would be like saying Fox News and CNN have the same viewpoint because both have news anchors behind a desk.
    The claim that all religions are essentially the same ignores what each faith actually asserts to be true about God, human nature, history, and salvation. In short, it is a view based on ignorance.

    And yet, plenty of people are ignorant about religious traditions they do not share. This, in itself, is not offensive. What is offensive is to be told that one is blinded from seeing the whole truth because of one's religious tradition by someone offering a view "from above" all religions. Because it is only "from above" that one could presume to look down upon "the circle" in which all religious believers sit and from that "higher perspective" lecture them on the unity they fail to see.
    Such a person is saying, in effect, "I can see what all you people below me in your individual religions fail to see. You have a partial view; whereas I have a view of the whole." Since each religious tradition claims to have a holistic vision, the claim that there is a higher, more inclusive perspective that relativizes each religion cannot help but offend the devoted adherents of all of them.
    Those of us who have devoted our lives to a religious tradition can look at each other and understand the devotion other religious believers show in a way that those who lack that kind of devotion will never really understand or respect. As a Christian, I can respect Jews or Muslims or Confucians for the things in their religious traditions that overlap with mine.
    Similarly, a Jewish rabbi might look at me and say, "Well, at least he is devoted to the one God and to keeping the Ten Commandments." I admire Confucians for the same reason I admire Stoics: because they commit themselves to living in accord with the cosmic ord...
    7 min
  • Humanity, Please
    By Anthony Esolen
    The other day I saw a photo of some homework a schoolboy did, marked wrong by the teacher. The question asked, "Which is greater, 0.2 or 0.14?" The boy correctly said it was 0.2. But the teacher wrote, "0.14 has more digits! Please study." I hardly know where to begin. A schoolteacher who does not know what decimals mean? I suppose she would have thought that 0.20 was greater than 0.2, and 0.2000 much greater than both!
    I also had occasion to write about the Gerard Manley Hopkins poem, "Hurrahing in Harvest," and because I'm away from home and my books, I had to look it up online. The first site that came up featured a brief analysis, under copyright. It was the work of AI, clotted with stupidity and incoherence. But how can an algorithm know what it is like to behold the clouds in a bright and windy autumn sky, much less to know what it is like to think or to praise God?
    The work of the human manager of the site, introducing Hopkins, was no better. I fear that though Western man may no longer heed the loving command in Genesis, "Increase and multiply," stupidity does, and will continue to do so in those who have no real education to shield them from it.
    Then I happened on a clip of the podcaster Ben Shapiro interviewing the popular promoter of science and despiser of religion, Neil deGrasse Tyson. The subject was liberty, and the apparently insoluble conundrum – insoluble only if you deny reality – of men pretending to be female and barging in on women's sports. "It's a free country," said Tyson, concluding that that means you should be permitted to do whatever you like sexually, because freedom, as he saw it, was a mere negative: barring obvious material harm, no one may prohibit you from your favorite source of pleasure.
    I remarked that not one of the ancient pagan philosophers, not even Epicurus, would have agreed with him. They all understood the difference between liberty and license. They all warned that license enslaves.
    Christians agreed. Here is the archangel Michael, replying to Adam in Paradise Lost, after Adam has expressed his displeasure to hear that one of his descendants, Nimrod, will be the first tyrant, a "mighty hunter":
    Yet know withal,
    Since thy original lapse true liberty
    Is lost, which always with right reason dwells
    Twinned, and from her hath no dividual being.
    Reason in man obscured or not obeyed,
    Immediately inordinate desires
    And upstart passions catch the government
    From reason, and to servitude reduce
    Man till then free. Since therefore he permits
    Within himself unworthy powers to reign
    Over free reason, God in judgment just
    Submits him from without to violent lords
    Who oft as undeservedly enthrall
    His outward freedom: tyranny must be,
    Though to the tyrant thereby no excuse.
    A licentious nation is also a stupid one. Its enthrallment is inevitable. So too for all human groups – churches and schools are by no means immune – and for individual persons.
    You will notice that I used for examples three things I found online. I am wary of it, because I feel the mighty pull to swim in that lagoon of information and deformation, where passions are kept ever simmering, to raise a constant dermatitis of the soul. You may also notice that I possessed in each case a counterweight, some means to judge what I saw, or to break free of the magnetic force.
    But it is wearying both ways. And if I find it so, how much more will it be for young people who do not have Hopkins or Milton at their fingertips or in their hearts, or even the simplest facts of arithmetic?

    Older generations could not be so distracted, because the means was lacking; nor could they be so stupid, because the near and pressing demands of life forbade it. For confirmation, I happened to open at random an old book on the nightstand while I lay sick in bed, and there read a speech delivered in the Senate by John Sherman, the younger brother of the celebrated general William Sherman, on gold and silver currency, their relative val...
    8 min

About The Catholic Thing

From the publisher's feed

The Catholic Thing is a daily column rooted in the richest cultural tradition in the world, i.e., the concrete historical reality of Catholicism.

Best of The Catholic Thing

Ranked by our users in the last 21 days

More shows like The Catholic Thing

Catholic Stuff You Should Know by J. 10 Initiative

Catholic Stuff You Should Know

3,827 Listeners

Bishop Barron’s Sunday Sermons - Catholic Preaching and Homilies by Bishop Robert Barron

Bishop Barron’s Sunday Sermons - Catholic Preaching and Homilies

4,966 Listeners

The Word on Fire Show - Catholic Faith and Culture by Bishop Robert Barron

The Word on Fire Show - Catholic Faith and Culture

5,701 Listeners

Dr Taylor Marshall Podcast by Dr. Taylor Marshall

Dr Taylor Marshall Podcast

4,054 Listeners

The Thomistic Institute by The Thomistic Institute

The Thomistic Institute

809 Listeners

First Things Podcast by First Things

First Things Podcast

717 Listeners

Pints With Aquinas by Matt Fradd

Pints With Aquinas

6,755 Listeners

The Counsel of Trent by Catholic Answers

The Counsel of Trent

2,745 Listeners

The Road to Emmaus with Scott Hahn by Scott Hahn

The Road to Emmaus with Scott Hahn

22 Listeners

Godsplaining by Dominican Friars Province of St. Joseph

Godsplaining

1,282 Listeners

The Catholic Gentleman by John Heinen, Devin Schadt

The Catholic Gentleman

446 Listeners

Catholic Saints by Augustine Institute

Catholic Saints

1,363 Listeners

Chris Stefanick Catholic Show by Chris Stefanick | Real Life Catholic

Chris Stefanick Catholic Show

442 Listeners

The LOOPcast by CatholicVote

The LOOPcast

750 Listeners

Arroyo Grande with Raymond Arroyo by iHeartPodcasts

Arroyo Grande with Raymond Arroyo

159 Listeners