The Book Club Review

George Saunders' Vigil: The Book Club Debate


Listen Later

George Saunders is back with Vigil, his first novel since Lincoln in the Bardo. In this episode, Kate is joined by fellow book podcasters Jenny King and Sarah Kemp from The Bookcast Club to discuss it

Given his back catalogue, does Vigil live up to the high expectations we have Saunders, one of America's most admired contemporary writers? Why is he so fond of writing about ghosts? Do death, redemption, capitalism and climate change make for an enjoyable read? Do we want novels to be enjoyable? Or do we want them to make a point?

We're also exploring Leo Tolstoy's classic novella The Death of Ivan Ilyich, cited by Saunders as a key influence on Vigil, and asks what both books reveal about how we live, how we die, and whether it's ever too late to change.

Along the way, Kate, Jenny and Sarah share recent reads, their love of a Kobo e-reader, and recommend books (and one film) following on from our book club read.

Books discussed

Vigil by George Saunders

The Death of Ivan Ilyich by Leo Tolstoy

Transcription by Ben Lerner

Almost Life by Kiran Millwood Hargrave

Once There Were Wolves by Charlotte McConaghy

Beautyland by Marie-Helene Bertino

North Woods by Daniel Mason

Storyland by Catherine McKinnon

Plus a recommendation for the film Palm Springs.

Patreon

Access extra episodes, join the pod book club and support the show at Patreon.com/bookclubreview

Follow on Instagram @bookclubreviewpodcast

email [email protected]

Timestamps

1:26 Recent Reads & Kobos – Bookshelf chat, Kobo e-reader enthusiasm, and current reads including Ben Lerner's Transcription and Kiran Millwood Hargrave's Almost Life.

11:54 About The Bookcast Club

14:41 Patreon Break

16:17 What Is Vigil? – Spiritual guide Jill escorts a remorseless fossil fuel tycoon toward death. Audiobook excerpt included.

22:16 Discussing Jill

28:22 Climate & KJ Boon

31:21 A Christmas Carol Parallels

34:16 Broader Reflections – Kate wonders if great writers can no longer make moral judgments in today's climate; Transcription raises similar questions.

35:54 Verdict on Vigil

38:30 The Death of Ivan Ilyich – Tolstoy's novella discussed as Saunders' cited influence.

43:00 Tolstoy the Man

48:36 Recommendations

52:42 Wrap-up

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Book Club ReviewBy The Book Club Review

  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6

4.6

125 ratings


More shows like The Book Club Review

View all
The Book Review by The New York Times

The Book Review

3,970 Listeners

Ask Penguin by Penguin Books UK

Ask Penguin

146 Listeners

All the Books! by Book Riot

All the Books!

1,220 Listeners

Book Riot - The Podcast by Book Riot

Book Riot - The Podcast

1,022 Listeners

Well-Read by Ann Cox and Halle Carlson

Well-Read

240 Listeners

Backlisted by Backlisted

Backlisted

582 Listeners

Made In Chafford by W!ZARD Studios

Made In Chafford

3 Listeners

The Waterstones Podcast by Waterstones

The Waterstones Podcast

43 Listeners

Throne of Glass - The Podcast by W!ZARD Studios

Throne of Glass - The Podcast

18 Listeners

Sarah's Bookshelves Live by Sarah Dickinson | Sarah's Bookshelves

Sarah's Bookshelves Live

787 Listeners

Bookshelfie: Women’s Prize Podcast by Women’s Prize Podcast/ Bird Lime Media

Bookshelfie: Women’s Prize Podcast

43 Listeners

It’s a Fandom Thing by W!ZARD Studios

It’s a Fandom Thing

28 Listeners

Literally Reading by Literally Reading

Literally Reading

287 Listeners

Great Pop Culture Debate by W!ZARD Studios

Great Pop Culture Debate

72 Listeners

More Than A Muse by Sadie Anderson, Stauney Hansen

More Than A Muse

21 Listeners

Books N' Betches by Books N' Betches

Books N' Betches

169 Listeners

The AA Meeting by Abby and Amy

The AA Meeting

10 Listeners

Book Talk, etc. by Tina @tbretc and Hannah @hanpickedbooks

Book Talk, etc.

640 Listeners

Weekly Dose of Wicked: A Humorous True Crime Podcast by Ashley Runkles & Sierra Roberson

Weekly Dose of Wicked: A Humorous True Crime Podcast

94 Listeners

Jamie All Over by W!ZARD Studios

Jamie All Over

333 Listeners

Sara & Cariad's Weirdos Book Club by Plosive

Sara & Cariad's Weirdos Book Club

63 Listeners

Call To Stage with Amber Davies by Amber Davies/W!ZARD Studios

Call To Stage with Amber Davies

6 Listeners

I'm Telling Mum by W!ZARD Studios

I'm Telling Mum

0 Listeners

Talk Of The Townsends by Talk Of The Townsends

Talk Of The Townsends

7 Listeners

The Chamber of Secret Books Podcast by W!ZARD Studios

The Chamber of Secret Books Podcast

5 Listeners

A Suite Life by As You Are Creative/W!ZARD Studios

A Suite Life

32 Listeners

The Nathan Eckersley Podcast by W!ZARD Studios

The Nathan Eckersley Podcast

0 Listeners

Life With No Warning by W!ZARD Studios

Life With No Warning

0 Listeners

The Pieces with Bimini by Bimini/W!ZARD Studios

The Pieces with Bimini

4 Listeners

The Radio 2 Book Club by BBC Radio 2

The Radio 2 Book Club

6 Listeners

I Said What I Said with Loulou O-Ren by Loulou O-Ren/W!ZARD Studios

I Said What I Said with Loulou O-Ren

0 Listeners

Take Four Books by BBC Radio 4

Take Four Books

7 Listeners

Stay Hydrated with Chris and Lizzie by Stay Hydrated/W!ZARD Studios

Stay Hydrated with Chris and Lizzie

9 Listeners

A Good Read by BBC Radio 4

A Good Read

43 Listeners

Game Changer with Shay Murphy by Shay Murphy/W!ZARD Studios

Game Changer with Shay Murphy

0 Listeners