In July of 2015, Tiffany Valiante wandered off into the night after an argument with her mother and a friend. Hours later, Tiffany’s body would be found - she had been hit by a train and didn’t survive her injuries. Authorities were quick to rule her death a suicide, but is that what really happened? Tiffany’s family thinks otherwise and after today’s episode, you might too!

Important Links:

* Petition to Reopen Tiffany’s Case: https://www.change.org/p/reopen-2015-tiffany-valiante-death-investigation

* Netflix Unsolved Mysteries - Season 3 Episode 1 “Mile Marker 45”

* Netflix Bonus Material: https://www.dropbox.com/sh/p2iv4fl5965x0dm/AABJ5Ehop19oBZdL1QdmM3lAa?dl=0

* D’Amato Law Firm: https://damatolawfirm.com/tiffany-valiante

* Report tips related to Tiffany’s death:

* 800-277-2427 (NJ Criminal Justice Hotline)

* [email protected]

* unsolved.com/tips

In 2014, the Broaddus family purchased their dream home at 657 Boulevard in Westfield, New Jersey. Derek and Maria Broaddus were excited to move in with their 3 children after the renovations were complete. But everything changed when Derek checked the mail at their new home and found a white card shaped envelope with thick handwriting addressed to “the new owner.” Inside, the envelope contained a letter signed by “The Watcher” and the Broaddus family’s dream home quickly became a nightmare.

On February 13th, 2017 in Delphi, Indiana, 14-year-old Libby German and 13-year-old Abby Williams decided to enjoy the unseasonably warm day by walking the trails in their town, like they had plenty of times before. But when Libby’s father arrived to pick them up, they were nowhere to be found. A town-wide manhunt uncovered their bodies in a nearby ravine, but what makes this case truly unbelievable is, in the words of the Indiana State Police, “We have a video, we have a still photograph, we have sound, and we don’t know who this person is.”

Full audio clip: https://soundcloud.com/shannon-mccarthy-antinori/new-delphi-murders-audio

Video clip (no sound): https://www.in.gov/isp/files/Delphi_MotionFix.mp4

FBI tip line: (844)-459-5786 or email [email protected]

Memorial park: http://abbyandlibbymemorialpark.org

HAPPY HALLOWEEN!! It seems like every year, news outlets report on the dangers that may be lurking in your child’s Halloween candy. But has there ever been a confirmed case of a child receiving and ingesting poisoned Halloween candy from a stranger? Or is this nothing more than an urban legend that’s been perpetuated throughout the years? In today’s episode, Colby dives into the history of events surrounding tainted candy, with a particular focus on a case out of Texas that unfortunately claimed the life of 8 year old Timothy O’Bryan.

In 1996, 19 year old Kristin Smart was at a college house party when she stumbled outside and passed out on the lawn. Kristin was unable to stand on her own and was helped up by two classmates who began to walk her home. At the same time, another classmate, Paul Flores, emerged from the shadows and offered to help, taking over and putting an arm around Kristin’s waist. After a short walk and a brief exchange, Kristin was left alone with Paul, about 40 yards from her dorm. Kristin was never seen again.

In this episode, Marina discusses Kristin’s disappearance and the 26 years of investigation that followed, leading to the arrest and prosecution of Paul Flores and his father, Ruben Flores.

When a woman and her children are viciously attacked in their home in a quiet Rhode Island neighborhood, the community reeled, their confident sense of security violently shaken. They knew they were looking for a cold-blooded killer, but they could never imagine the face behind the evil lurking right in their backyards. Tune in to this week’s episode to hear Laura tell us about Craig Price, the Warwick Slasher.

SURPRISE!! We know we left you hanging at the end of this week’s episode so we decided to release part 2 a little early for you!

In our conclusion, Colby tells us Dennis’ side of the story. What happened to each of our co-conspirators? Listen in to find out!

There is a fine line between love and obsession and in the summer of 1987, Dennis Coleman stepped right over that line! When his 16 year old girlfriend, Karin Aparo’s, mother, Joyce Aparo, is found murdered, Dennis quickly finds himself at the center of the investigation. The story that unfolds reveals a conspiracy plot with the mastermind as none other than Joyce’s daughter herself. This is one you’re gonna have to hear to believe!

Grimmlin Suggestions is an episode for you by you! There is no case too small and every story deserves to be told.

In this episode, Marina discusses the heartbreaking murder of Samantha Josephson that occurred at the hands of a man she mistook for her Uber driver and how her family continues to keep her memory alive while trying to protect others from the same fate with the #whatsmyname movement.

Then Laura tells us about the dramatic circumstances leading up to the altercation between Olympic equestrian Michael Barisone and his student, Lauren Kanerek.

To support Michael: https://gofund.me/e873ca1d

Growing up, Karl Tanzler had seen the vision of a woman who told him that he was destined to be with a dark-haired beauty. When he first laid eyes on Maria Elena Milagro de Hoyos, he knew that his destiny had been fulfilled. In this episode, Marina discusses how Karl’s triumph in finding Elena turned to tragedy, causing Karl to take actions that would make his love story infamous.

Shout out to the Corpse Bride episode by “Stuff You Missed in History Class” for some juicy details.