This episode features a deep, nuanced conversation between Daniella Mestyanek Young and Rebecca about whiteness, power, community, cultural disconnection, and the complicated dynamics of speaking about social issues publicly. They explore how race, gender, and perceived authority shape who is "allowed" to say what, and how society reacts differently depending on the identity of the speaker. Their discussion spans topics such as the weaponization of "niceness," internal policing within white communities, the loss of joy in white American culture, the effects of cult-like systems, excommunication and belonging, cultural appropriation versus cultural inheritance, family structures, consumerism, and community care.

They also delve into how white people often center themselves even in conversations about harm, the dangers of nostalgia in healing from narcissistic systems, and the structural reasons why many white Americans lack the skills of communal living and mutual aid. Rebecca and Daniella reflect on their own identities, histories, and complexities — including Daniella's upbringing in Brazil and a cult, and Rebecca's experiences navigating whiteness as a Black Jewish woman — while interrogating the pressure to "fit" into expected cultural norms.

Connect with Rebecca at:

Website

Patreon

TikTok

Connect with Daniella at:

Daniella's Patreon

TikTok

Instagram

Website

Youtube

KnittingCultLady Store

Preorder for Culting of America: The Culting of America PRE-SALE (SHIPS BY JANUARY 20, 2026) – Knitting Cult Lady

Uncultured by Daniella Mestyanek Young

• From Bookshop.org

• Autographed

• UnAMERICAN Videobook

Key Takeaways

• Identity shapes how messages are received, especially around race; white men can say things without risk that women or people of color cannot.

• White women often police one another to maintain perceived safety, conformity, and social order within whiteness.

• Passing, conformity, and "basic white girl" scripts are forms of survival that create long-term opportunity costs for white women seeking cultural self-understanding.

• Joy was systematically removed from white culture, often in direct opposition to Black joy, and reclaiming joy requires conscious work without appropriating Black resistance frameworks.

• Cultural practices like dancing, extended family structures, and community care have been stripped or flattened in white American culture but are thriving elsewhere.

• White discomfort at being excluded from conversations often masks entitlement to oversight and control rather than genuine curiosity.

• Community care is underdeveloped in many white American spaces, leaving people unprepared when systems fail them.

• Exiting harmful systems has "exit costs," including the loss of community — even when that community was not healthy.

• Nostalgia can obscure the realities of harmful dynamics, especially when leaving cults, whiteness, or tightly policed identity groups.

• Book clubs and structured discussion spaces can offer safer environments for people doing personal or collective deconstruction work.

• Appropriation vs. inheritance: reclaiming cultural elements (dance, language, music) from one's heritage differs from adopting something not your own.

• White insistence on conceptual thinking (vs. presence and relational curiosity) limits connection and reinforces distancing.

• "What are you?" asked by white people is classification; asked within communities of color, it's relational.

• Joy is resistance is a Black concept; white people can learn from it without co-opting it.

• Consumerism as identity (e.g., commercial Christmas) distracts from communal practices and meaning.

• Whiteness confuses individualism with safety, leading to scarcity thinking and overreliance on systems rather than people.

Chapters

00:00 The Power of Identity in Conversations 02:54 Navigating Conversations on Race and Gender 05:38 The Impact of White Voices in Social Discourse 08:30 Cultural Differences in Community Care 11:14 The Fear of White America 13:58 Understanding Familial Language and Boundaries 23:20 Understanding Family Structures 25:59 Challenging Consumerism and Community Building 29:43 The Complexity of Joy and Resistance 33:24 Cultural Appropriation and Identity 41:28 Navigating Community and Belonging 45:58 Navigating Exit Costs and Opportunity Costs 48:29 Exploring Cultural Identity and Nostalgia 51:22 The Complexity of Cultural Conversations 54:47 Building Inclusive Spaces in Book Clubs 58:37 Anticipating Attention and Navigating Identity 01:08:07 The Impact of Evangelical Backgrounds 01:11:52 Cultural Identity and Deconstruction 01:13:29 The Emotional Toll of Leaving Cultures 01:17:59 Systemic Issues and Personal Reflection 01:22:40 Navigating Relationships and Awareness 01:28:03 Community and Ongoing Learning

Produced by Haley Phillips