Angry Planet

How Many Nukes Does It Take to Win a War? (Trick Question)


Listen Later

Listen to this episode commercial free at https://angryplanetpod.com


The world is living with a Cold War hangover. The logic of deterrence, which dominates the minds of the people who plan nuclear wars, means that America must have enough nuclear weapons to credibly threaten to destroy the world should someone launch nukes at it. That thinking led to a world with tens of thousands of nuclear weapons, and that was just when the U.S. had the Soviet Union to think about. Now it’s facing the twin threats of Russia and China. Does that mean America needs twice the nukes to handle twice the threats?


Some in the Pentagon seem to think so, and the world is embarking on a radical and expensive nuclear build up the likes of which it hasn’t seen in a generation.

What if there’s another way? James Acton is here to pitch us on a world where Optimal Deterrence does not mean spending trillions of dollars on new world-ending weapons just to make sure everyone else doesn’t use theirs.

Acton is a co-director of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace’s Nuclear Policy Program and the author of a new article that outlines the 21st century nuclear arms race and a new plan to stop it.


  • Podcasting from an iPhone in a closet
  • The apocryphal camera lens story
  • The nuclear tease
  • What are nuclear weapons pointed at?
  • How to win a three-way nuclear war
  • The dread logic of counterforce targeting
  • Trump’s nuclear reticence
  • How many nukes are there anyway?
  • How to spend a trillion dollars on nuclear weapons upgrades
  • Acton’s big idea
  • “I don’t think we lose much by ceasing to target an adversary’s nuclear forces.”
  • “It doesn’t matter if they believe it or not.”


Optimal Deterrence


Russia’s nuclear torpedo


Carnegie Endowment for International Peace

Support this show http://supporter.acast.com/warcollege.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Angry PlanetBy Matthew Gault and Jason Fields

  • 4.2
  • 4.2
  • 4.2
  • 4.2
  • 4.2

4.2

792 ratings


More shows like Angry Planet

View all
The Truth of the Matter by CSIS | Center for Strategic and International Studies

The Truth of the Matter

256 Listeners

War on the Rocks by Ryan Evans

War on the Rocks

1,078 Listeners

Arms Control Wonk by Jeffrey Lewis & Aaron Stein

Arms Control Wonk

409 Listeners

The Big View by Reuters

The Big View

29 Listeners

Viewsroom by Reuters

Viewsroom

44 Listeners

Modern War Institute by Modern War Institute at West Point

Modern War Institute

767 Listeners

Russian Roulette by Center for Strategic and International Studies

Russian Roulette

144 Listeners

The Proceedings Podcast by U.S. Naval Institute

The Proceedings Podcast

210 Listeners

Popular Front by Jake Hanrahan

Popular Front

789 Listeners

On The Case by Reuters

On The Case

24 Listeners

Net Assessment by War on the Rocks

Net Assessment

402 Listeners

The Red Line by The Red Line

The Red Line

359 Listeners

In Moscow's Shadows by Mark Galeotti

In Moscow's Shadows

364 Listeners

Irregular Warfare Podcast by Irregular Warfare Initiative

Irregular Warfare Podcast

394 Listeners

Global Security Briefing by The Royal United Services Institute

Global Security Briefing

20 Listeners

School of War by Nebulous Media

School of War

411 Listeners

Geopolitics Decanted with Dmitri Alperovitch by Silverado Policy Accelerator

Geopolitics Decanted with Dmitri Alperovitch

153 Listeners

NatSec Matters by Beacon Global Strategies LLC

NatSec Matters

256 Listeners