A horrifying crime was committed in Robin Faulk's small town and she has to confront her husband's dark side.

This Week’s Sponsors:

Function Health - Learn more and use our link at functionhealth.com/ITHINKNOT 

Miracle Made - Go to trymiracle.com/THINKNOT and use the code THINKNOT to claim your free 3 piece towel set and save over 40% off

IQ Bar - Get twenty percent off all IQBAR products, plus get free shipping. To get your twenty percent off, just text think to 64000. Message and data rates may apply. See terms for details.

Joey and Ellyn are popping in for just a quick rundown on the upcoming tour dates before they head out on the road, plus an overview on Apple subscription. 

Donna met a good-looking Jim in college and they instantly clicked; after two decades of marriage and two beautiful children, Donna discovers a shocking secret about her husband that threatens to destroy everything.

This Week’s Sponsors:

BetterHelp - This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/ithinknot today to get 10% off your first month and talk it out with BetterHelp

SKIMS - Shop your favorite bras and underwear at SKIMS.com If you haven't yet, be sure to let them know we sent you! After you place your order, select "podcast" in the survey and select I Think Not in the dropdown menu that follows

Function Health - Visit functionhealth.com/ITHINKNOT and use giftcode ITHINKNOT100 at sign-up. The first 1000 get a $100 credit toward their membership 

On this episode of the Rundown, Joey and Ellyn switch gears to the recent sentencing in a new trial. Bryan Kohberger was sentenced to life in prison without parole for the murders of four University of Idaho students. Listen and break it all down on this week’s Rundown

As a Playboy Bunny, Jackie Hendrickson is forbidden from fraternizing with her customers; Atlanta plastic surgeon Dr. Warren Brown is impossible to resist, and their illicit affair sets off a deadly chain of events.

This Week’s Sponsors:

Function Health - Visit functionhealth.com/ITHINKNOT and use giftcode ITHINKNOT100 at sign-up. The first 1000 get a $100 credit toward their membership 

Remi - Head to shopremi.com/THINK and use code THINK to save up to 50% off

Miracle Made - Go to trymiracle.com/THINKNOT and use the code THINKNOT to claim your free 3 piece towel set and save over 40% off

IQ Bar - Get twenty percent off all IQBAR products, plus get free shipping. To get your twenty percent off, just text think to 64000. Message and data rates may apply. See terms for details.

Wildgrain - Visit wildgrain.com/THINK to get $30 off your first box plus free croissants in every box 

Actress Melonie Haller is poised for stardom after appearing in the television series "Welcome Back, Kotter" and a pictorial in the March 1980 edition of Playboy; eager for her next role, she goes to a party in the Hamptons that takes a violent turn.

This Week’s Sponsors:

Quince - Go to Quince.com/think for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns

Function Health - Visit functionhealth.com/ITHINK and use giftcode ITHINKNOT100 at sign-up. The first 1000 get a $100 credit toward their membership 

Pacagen - Head to pacagen.com/THINK and use promo code THINK for an extra 15% off and an exclusive gift at checkout. 

Blissy - Go to blissy.com/ITHINKNOTPOD and use code ITHINKNOTPOD to get 60 nights risk-free and an additional 30% off! 

HungryRoot - Head to hungryroot.com/ithinknot and use code ITHINKNOT to get 40% off your first box and a free item of your choice for life. 

Ellyn is joined by Emily Pelphrey, a former criminal prosecutor at the County, State and Federal levels. Ellyn does a quick Karen Read update before they dive into the Diddy trial and the recent verdict reached. Emily notably was the prosecutor on the Richard Beasley trial -- the Ohio Craiglist Killer who, prior to the escalation, authorities were building a human trafficking case against. There are a number of similarities between both trials, and they look at the system through the lense of Emily's prosecution experience.

Emily is the co-host of the new podcast God Hook and, together with award-winning journalist Carol Costello, they delve into the complex case of the Ohio Craigslist Killings, and in doing so, unearth the untold story of the crimes that preceded the murders – and the victims who’ve never received justice.

Kerissa Fare is thrilled to be September 2000's Playmate of the Month; just as the magazine is about to hit newsstands, a mysterious man from her past becomes a suspect in multiple murders, and investigators want to talk to her.

This Week’s Sponsors:

Fay Nutrition - Listeners of I Think Not can qualify to see a registered dietitian for as little as $0 by visiting faynutrition.com/THINK 

Miracle Made - Go to trymiracle.com/THINKNOT and use the code THINKNOT to claim your free 3 piece towel set and save over 40% off

IQ Bar - Get twenty percent off all IQBAR products, plus get free shipping. To get your twenty percent off, just text think to 64000. Message and data rates may apply. See terms for details.

ZBiotics - Go to zbiotics.com/think to get 15% off your first order when you use code THINK at checkout. 

BetterHelp - This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/ithinknot today to get 10% off your first month and get on your way to being your best self

Detective Sergeant Anthony Rykowski joins Ellyn and Joey for a discussion about Karen Read, corruption in law enforcement, police ethics and more! We first met Anthony when we were recapping "Disappeared". He was featured on Episode 111 - Lost Angel: The Disappearance of Angel Garcia. We were taken with his strong commitment to the case and justice.  Since then, he’s become the go-to for every question we have about that law and trust us - we have a lot. So naturally he had many thoughts on the awful investigation the Canton Police did on the death of John O'Keefe. We are so grateful to hear his thoughts on what SHOULD have happened that night. 

As part of our dark week due to the holiday, we have a special surprise for you all! This is a bonus episode, previously exclusive to our Patreon page and originally published on 2/27/25. Join now and get 9 episodes of How I Caught My Killer, plus a ton of other bonus content, at patreon.com/ithinknot or join Apple Subscriptions and get all of our bonus content directly on the app! 

When police find Atlanta rapper Rahim Grant gunned down in his apartment along with the critically injured mother of his child, the only way to learn who pulled the trigger - and why - could be locked in a series of shocking videos on Rahim's phone.