In this episode, the Main Creeps try a few items that tie in wonderfully with the theme. The goodies were found while attending the Appalachian Paracon convention. We tried Cryptid Confections of Bigfoot and Mothman themed caramel chocolates made by The Sow Good Market, LLC out of Masontown, WV. You can find their homemade goods in pharmacies around Morgantown, Reedsville, Arthurdale, please visit their page for more information. Facebook.com/groups/616232969301446/

Matt tells the legend of the Grafton Monster, a bulky headless cryptid creature that was spotted around Riverside Drive in Grafton, WV in the 1960s. Matt professes his love of pecans. The Creeps discuss the varied textures of peanut butter fillings, more weird candy bars for Kelsey to try later, and what monsters feel like when you pet them.

This episode's food selection is from Crystal Cafe

Located at 402 Market St. in Parkersburg, WV.

Here's what we ordered: West Virginia style hot dog, Turkey Reuben, Ranch Roast Beef, Cajun burger, broccoli salad, Homemade corned beef hash, cinnamon rolls, cookies

In this episode, we ate at a local institution of Parkersburg - a lunch counter that has served downtown since 1948. We found it while attending the first ever Appalachian Paracon convention at the Blennerhasset Hotel. Kelsey gives us a continuation of her coverage of the Colorado Springs killings of the 70s. The Creeps get sassy and each get their own cookie.

In this episode, the Main Creeps try a new flavor of Twix bar with a cookie dough flavored confection that has replaced the caramel layer. They discuss their favorite candy bars, Matt mentions Go-Mart again and makes a new verb. Kelsey begs the universe to give us back the 3 Musketeers Truffle Crisp bar.

Matt's very excited to give you a conspiracy theory surrounding one of the most prolific serial killers the eastern seaboard has ever known. This killer terrorized Maine throughout the 80s and early 90s. Happy April Fools, everyone.

This is a part 2 continuation of our foodie excursion to Helvetia for the Fasnacht event, but a part 1 of Kelsey covering a huge case. Apologies if we mispronounce anything or misuse umlauts. Our hosts switch places at the beginning, we have fun here...

For Fasnacht, we first visited the Hütte restaurant for lunch and had their special event platter. You can find them at 1 Main St, Helvetia, WV, check their facebook for current hours. Here's what we ordered:

A curated selection of Morgan Henalie Chicken, Bratwurst, ("Our Own Sausage"), Parsley Potatoes, Buttered Green Beans, Sauerkraut, Bread, Cheese, Peach Cobbler With Cream, Iced Tea, Coffee

This episode is part one of our host Kelsey covering the spree of serial killings that took place in Colorado Springs in 1975, and the case's connection to actor Kelsey Grammer.

The Main Creeps try Mr. Beast chocolate in the Quinoa Crunch flavor variety, discussing when celebrities venture into branded foods. The also profess their trashy love of smoked beef snacks that aren't pickle flavored.

Matt covers a solved cold case, of a murder that occurred in in 1993 in Huntington, WV. The case involved a young woman killed by lacerations to her face and a gunshot wound. 

This episode's special food selection is from the annual Fasnacht holiday event in the preserved Swiss village of Helvetia, WV. Here's what we ordered:

Bratwurst sandwich with spicy mustard and sauerkraut, vegetarian chili, assorted potato donuts from Downstate Donuts, homemade traditional hosablatz pastry, ale and stout from Mountain State Brewing

This time, the Main Creeps are live! They are joined by their spouses Michael and Britt, for a special trip to Helvetia, WV for the Fasnacht celebration. We tried assorted snacks, watched a parade of folks in masks and costumes, and participated in a bonfire to signify the ending of winter. It's an interesting experience we highly recommend. Kelsey tried beer!  "This place is a winter wonderland of delicious food and I'm here for it." - Matt

For this episode, Matt covers what was known as the Texarkana Phantom Killer and their spree of murders occurring in 1946 around Texarkana, Arkansas. He details how these killings relate to the movie The Town That Dreaded Sundown, and that the murders are unsolved to this day. The Creeps also share their thoughts on the name of the town itself.

The kids selling donuts at the event in Helvetia are raising money for the Karen Beasley Sea Turtle Rescue and Rehabilitation Center, which you can donate to by going to seaturtlehospital.org. You can also benefit the village by going to helvetiawv.com where you can plan a visit or donate directly to the Helvetia Restoration and Development Organization.

For this episode's tasting review, Kelsey selected the Atomic Garden blend of coffee from Green Day's Oakland Coffee Company. Atomic Garden is an Organic Medium Dark Roast, and the Main Creeps try this coffee with three different methods - drip, French press, and pour over. Tune in to hear pretty pouring.

Matt talks about a cold case, involving the discovery of the body of Jeremiah Watkins, a boy who was murdered in 1985 in Terra Alta, WV. If you have any information regarding the case, contact Captain Tichnell at 304-329-1611, ext. 2152. Original article credit: WBOY

This episode's food selection is from Parkette Family Restaurant, located at 2022 E Pike St, Clarksburg, WV. Open Tue-Sat 11 AM-9 PM, Sun 11 AM-3:30 PM.

Here's what we ordered:

In this episode, Matt covers two brothers who are considered some of the earliest known serial killers in US history, discussing their exploits in the early frontier regions of Appalachia. The main creeps also talk about a preference for mayo and which foods should be dry. The crimes discussed in this episode are graphic, discretion advised.

No food today, the Creeps didn't feel like snacking.

If you have any information that might help in solving the case covered on the show, you can contact the Lawrence County Sherriff's Office Anonymous Tipline at 740-532-3525 or email at [email protected].

If you would like more information about the DNA Doe Project, visit DNADoeProject.org.

DNA Doe Project

In this episode, the Main Creeps try out the food inside a US military MRE food ration. They try barbecue protein puffs, applesauce, coffee, lemonade, barbecue beef, crackers with jelly. Tune in to see if trying this makes them happy or angry. There's a lot of chewing, and they talk about what kind of trades they would make for the good stuff.

Matt covers another cult, this one is known as The House of Prayer church. They been allegedly accused of stealing money from veterans education organizations. Hey, don't scam people.