
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


This week, our hosts try a the third coffee in our series of drinking Folk Hero Coffee, This roast is wonderfully Grafton Monster themed, gifted to us by the wonderful people at Folk Hero Coffee, from Buckhannon, WV, who can be reached at FolkHeroCoffee.com. Kelsey brewed up a flight, she used the techniques of pour over, French press, drip coffee pot, and her new moka pot.
In this episode, Matt tells Kelsey about the Bath School massacre, in which Andrew Kehoe attacked a school in the late 20's in Michigan. This case is very graphic and detailed, involving the deaths of multiple children, discretion advised.
You read that title right, Kelsey found new Snickerdoodle Pop-Tarts to try. Matt gets pretty excited about it.
Then, Matt shares a story of Ohio fugitive Donald "Chip" Pugh, a man wanted for dui, and person of interest in potential vandalism, who wanted a nicer angle on his mugshot, an improved image, a better look at his mug. So he sends in a selfie to police in Florida, because of course this happened in Florida. Ohio police already had the image and posted it to Facebook, because of course they did.
The Creeps also talk about untoasted pop-tart preference, and cinnamon levels. Kelsey shares a dark, long held, baking secret.
Note: Our editor would like to let listeners know, Britt is not the one underbaking cinnamon rolls, but she is the one eating underbaked brownies with a spoon along with Kelsey.
This week, our hosts try a themed John Brown coffee that was gifted to us by the wonderful people at Folk Hero Coffee, from Buckhannon, WV, who can be reached at FolkHeroCoffee.com. This is a continuation of our sampling of three different coffees. For this one, Kelsey brewed up a flight, she used the techniques of pour over, French press, drip coffee pot, and her new moka pot.
In this episode, Kelsey tells us the story Jaleayah Davis, whose 2011 death and closed case is the topic of debate in the Parkersburg, WV/Marietta, OH area. Her family has since started the Facebook page “Justice for Jaleayah” hoping to get her case reopened.
The Creeps also talk about being nosy, scones, buying coffee making supplies, and the history of noted abolitionist John Brown, Harpers Ferry, the catalyst that led to the American Civil War.
This episode contains graphic details of a case, discretion advised.
This week, the Creeps try a coffee that was gifted to us by the wonderful people at Folk Hero Coffee, from Buckhannon, WV, who can be reached at FolkHeroCoffee.com. We will be sampling three different coffees from their delightfully decorated Cryptid Collection across the next few episodes. For this one, Kelsey brewed up a flight using some of Folk Hero's Bridge Monster Dark Roast, she used the techniques of pour over, French press, drip coffee pot, and her new moka pot.
In this episode, Matt covers the history of illegal pirates taking over the radio and television airwaves in the 80s, also known as broadcast signal intrusion, culminating in the infamous Max Headroom incident.
The Creeps also talk about needing a cozy pick-me-up on a gloomy winter evening, cup fights, waking up with Mothman, Kelsey's love of gadgets, Matt's preference to drink something lava hot.
This week, our Creeps are trying beer from Greenbrier Valley Brewing, Mothman Black IPA. Kelsey (not a fan of hoppy beer or beer in general) says she’s trying beer against her will. We swear we did not tie her to a chair in the basement for this.
Then, Kelsey tells the story of a harrowing 911 call regarding a possible intruder in a woman’s home.
In this episode, Kelsey's mom gave us a new Pop Tart flavor to try, with Matt not knowing what flavor he's about to eat. Thanks to the Pop-Tarts Bowl, now that sacrificing a beloved mascot and consuming Pop-Tart flesh has become a New Year's seasonal occasion, we will try to have another flavor next year.
Then, Kelsey takes us back to the wild winter of 1992, so much swirling chaos, and America concerns itself with a beloved White House pet pup who maybe indulged in too many treats. Do not feed Ranger.
The Creeps also talk about their favorite Pop-tart flavors and whether they like to eat them cold or toasted, buying discount snacks, coworker betrayal, and how Matt is still pretty bummed out about Hall and Oates.
For this episode, we made homemade cookies to try. Kelsey made her family's favorites and Britt made hers and Matt's.
Here's what we tried: Cream cheese candy, peanut butter cookies, chocolate no-bakes, 1939 chocolate chip cookies.
In this holiday special, Matt tells a ghost story for Christmas. Gather around the fire, toast with some holiday cheer, and tune in to hear this year's tale, one of a game of hide and seek, titled Smee, written by A. M. Burrage.
In this episode, the Main Creeps try a very fun candy, Beny Locochas hard candy in the Mango Flavor with a chili center. We maybe also didn't inform Kelsey beforehand that the candy is filled with a sort of chili powder, so enjoy listening to her reaction.
Then, Matt gives us a wild story about Santa renting a Helicopter in Brazil, in November of 2015. There is still no word on what happened to his reindeer.
The Creeps also talk about hard candy flavors, the importance of Family, believing in the spirit of Christmas, and Matt sheds a tear for Hall and Oates again.
If you or someone you know needs help or wants to talk, reach out to hotlines such as the 988 crisis lifeline.
This week, for our usual December Holiday recipe time, the Creeps try Kelsey's homemade spiced Carrot Cake with chopped pecans, which is one of Matt's favorite types of cake. Measure the spices and nuts with your heart.
In this episode, Kelsey delivers part two of the story of Christine Moody and Jeremy Moody, going into further detail of their crimes, the impeccable police work that led to warrants for their arrest, and the further investigation and trial of this heinous couple. This includes details of the interrogations and confessions.
The Creeps also talk about dessert nut preference and getting right with the Lord. Let us know on social media if you're interested in more featured recipes on the show.
Shoutout to Max Miller and his YouTube show Tasting History, credit to him and his episode about the history of Carrot Cake and the use of rations to make it during WWII. For more information, you can watch his video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zeNXOL5YiLw
This week, the Creeps try Pies & Pints, a local chain with several locations. We tried the one at 1002 Suncrest Towne Centre Dr., Morgantown, WV. Open Sun-Thurs 11 AM-10 PM, Fri & Sat 11 AM-11 PM. Here's what we ordered:
Grape & Gorgonzola Pizza with Fresh Rosemary; and White Pizza with Mozzarella, Provolone, Ricotta, & Parmesan Cheeses, Roasted Garlic, Olive Oil, & Fresh Herbs.
In this episode, Kelsey details part one of the story of Christine Moody and Jeremy Moody, a horrid couple who remorselessly committed various crimes, including kidnapping and killing a registered sex offender and the man's wife, in South Carolina.
Also, the hosts talk about not wanting to do paperwork, enhancing surveillance video, specific walking patterns, not destroying evidence - and they also lay in to the editor for eating an entire Dill Pickle Slim Jim. They're not sorry about it.
From the publisher's feed