It’s 10:23 p.m. and Owen is freaking out because one of his childhood icons has joined him in bed—the angelic Holly Madison! Owen and Holly talk about The Girls Next Door (duh), Holly’s beginnings in Alaska (sometimes without running water), and the hardest hikes in LA. Then, Holly discusses her love of horror and the next season of her true crime series, The Playboy Murders (S3 starts May 5!). Holly also informs Owen of Benjamin Franklin’s ho phase (that apparently lasted his entire life) before discussing Hugh Hefner’s will, why she turned down Traitors, and her real-life connection to a murder case. After you’re done watching this episode, would someone mind creating a change.org petition to abolish April Fools’ Day?

Follow and connect with all things @InYourDreams across Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube.