Listen to the podcast:
Watch:
Read:
This week, I’m excited to launch the very first Mindful15 subscriber Q and A episode where I’ll answer a collection of questions submitted by Mindful15 listeners. Let’s get right to it.
Question 1: Is it alright to move during meditation, or am I supposed to sit absolutely still, even if my legs are numb or I’m in pain?
Answer: The reason you’re taught to sit still in meditation is that sitting still helps you focus your full attention on the breath, but there’s nothing wrong with moving if you feel the need to. Don’t just move, though. Move mindfully.
Before moving, take a minute or two to attend to the discomfort that is motivating you to move. Gently take your attention away from your breath and place it on the discomfort.
Locate the place in the body that feels uncomfortable or painful, and observe how it feels. Notice whether the discomfort is solid, or whether it ebbs and flows. Pain, for example, is often a collection of moving, changing sensations that sometimes recede and sometimes grow stronger.
Don’t try to get rid of the pain or discomfort. Just witness it for a few minutes. Also witness any habitual reactions you may have to the pain or discomfort. Put your focus on those reactions and just notice them without trying to get rid of them.
After a while, if you still feel the need to move, go ahead and do so. Put your attention on the movement of the body. Move slowly and deliberately.
Once your body is in its new position, sit with your attention on the sensations of the body in this new position. After a few breaths, gently bring your attention back to your breath, again.
This Week's Peaceful Moment: A Varied Thrush in My St. Albert, Alberta GardenThis image is protected by copyright and used with permission
Question 2: To help myself focus on my breathing, I talk myself through the breath: “Now I am breathing in. And now the breath is paused.” I do this silently, of course. Is this still meditation?
Answer: Yes, talking yourself through the phases of the breath is perfectly fine. In fact, some meditation teachers coach beginners to do exactly what you’re doing. Thich Nhat Hanh, for example, uses phrases such as “breathing in, I am aware that I am breathing in.”
Once you’re focused on the breath, you can try shortening your phrases. Say just “in,” and “out,” for example. And, once you become very settled, you may let go of them altogether, bringing them back whenever you need them.
Question 3: I like to meditate with a group, but one of our group members thinks he’s supposed to be breathing very deeply. His breathing is loud and distracting. Should I tell him his breathing is supposed to be quiet?
Answer: I’m not sure that correcting your fellow practitioner’s meditation style is the right choice, here. We do advise meditators not to manipulate their breath and it’s true that, as one settles into meditation, the breath tends to get softer and quieter. Is it up to you, though, to educate your friend?
You could, without blaming him or suggesting that he’s doing anything wrong, tell him that you find yourself distracted by even small noises. You could ask him if it is possible for him to breathe more quietly. Alternately, you could sit further away from him.
But, have you considered that there’s something for you to learn from this situation? While it’s true that you want to look for a quiet place to meditate, the long-term goal is to learn to bring your mindfulness out of meditation and into daily life where distractions abound.
You don’t need absolute quiet to meditate. Furthermore, it’s your responsibility, not your friend’s,