Anthony and Dave dissect the latest late-inning bullpen meltdowns against the Mets, forcing an urgent debate over who actually belongs in the "Circle of Trust." The guys turn their attention to the hard-fought Toronto series, tracking the lineup's production and grading the offense's ability to manufacture runs against a tough Blue Jays pitching staff.

​Panic or Can It?: The fellas play another round of their signature game, separating genuine concerns from minor, mid-May blips on the radar.

​With Gerrit Cole’s rehab assignment winding down, the hosts break down the major roster crunch looming in the Bronx and who gets the boot when the reigning Cy Young winner reclaims his throne.

The episode wraps on a lighter note as Dave checks in with updates of his adventures down in Nashville.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices