Anthony and Dave dissect the latest late-inning bullpen meltdowns against the Mets, forcing an urgent debate over who actually belongs in the "Circle of Trust." The guys turn their attention to the hard-fought Toronto series, tracking the lineup's production and grading the offense's ability to manufacture runs against a tough Blue Jays pitching staff.

​Panic or Can It?: The fellas play another round of their signature game, separating genuine concerns from minor, mid-May blips on the radar.

​With Gerrit Cole’s rehab assignment winding down, the hosts break down the major roster crunch looming in the Bronx and who gets the boot when the reigning Cy Young winner reclaims his throne.

The episode wraps on a lighter note as Dave checks in with updates of his adventures down in Nashville.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Anthony and Dave break down a difficult stretch for the Bronx Bombers, dissecting the rough weekend in Milwaukee and the series loss to the Orioles that has fans questioning the team’s momentum.

​The guys discuss the mounting concern surrounding Max Fried’s health and what Anthony Volpe’s official return from Scranton means for the lineup’s spark.

​With recent late-inning struggles, the fellas debate which arms in the bullpen they actually trust when the game is on the line.

​Panic or Can It?: The hosts play a high-stakes game of "Panic or Can It," deciding which recent team trends are genuine causes for alarm and which are just mid-May blips on the radar.

​The episode wraps with a deep dive into the upcoming clash with the Mets, highlighting the key matchups and storylines as the crosstown rivalry takes center stage.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Anthony from the Monument Pod and Brian from Home Run Applesauce are joined by Apple TV+'s Heidi Watney to preview tonight's Game 1 of the Subway Series. Follow Heidi on Instagram and Twitter @HeidiWatney, and thanks as always for listening.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Anthony and Dave break down the absolute clinic the Yankees just put on, sweeping the Orioles and securing a home series win against the Rangers.

The guys discuss the surprising decision to option Anthony Volpe to Triple-A following his rehab assignment and what the arrival of Spencer Jones—replacing an injured Jasson Domínguez—means for the outfield depth.

The episode turns heartfelt as Anthony and Dave pay tribute to the legendary John Sterling after his passing this week. The fellas share their favorite "Sterling-isms" and recount the signature calls that defined their lives as fans, reflecting on how the broadcast booth will never sound quite the same.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

​Anthony and Dave break down the Yankees' recent tear, including a satisfying sweep in Boston and series wins against the Astros and Rangers.

​The guys fawn over the dominant starting rotation and highlight rookie Cam Schlittler, who has been the early season’s biggest revelation. 

The conversation shifts to the impending return of Gerrit Cole and Carlos Rodón and how their presence will reshape an already elite rotation.

​The fellas discuss the massive shake-up in the AL East following the Red Sox’s decision to fire Alex Cora and most of his staff.  

​Producer Brian joins the show to share the agony of being a Mets fan, as the guys track the struggles of former Yankees who defected to the team across town. With Carlos Mendoza on the hot seat, Anthony, Brian, and Dave discuss potential fits for the Mets' dugout and other looming managerial changes around MLB.

​The hosts dive into recent Yankees moves, including Luis Gil’s demotion, George Lombard’s promotion to Scranton, the impact of Giancarlo Stanton’s move to the IL and the return of SS Anthony Volpe.

​The episode wraps with a look at Star Wars Weekend at Yankee Stadium and all the themed food and merchandise hitting the Bronx.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Anthony and Dave break down the polar-opposite vibes of a chaotic Angels series and a dominant, business-like sweep of the Royals.

The guys recap the awkward Betances-Ottavino rain delay broadcast and debate which Yankees legends could actually survive three hours of dead air.

The fellas reminisce about David Cone’s legendary baseball IQ and wonder if he’ll ever trade the broadcast booth for the dugout.

Anthony and Dave analyze the first month of the season to identify exactly who has earned a spot in Aaron Boone’s "Circle of Trust."

The hosts wrap things up by sharing their reactions to the news of the Yankees finally adopting a third jersey and what it means for team tradition.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

As ​Dave returns from his time off the grid to a five-game skid, Anthony breaks down the highs and the lows of the first 15 games of the season. They try to diagnose the slump and figure out the cure to what ails the Bronx Bombers.

​Anthony recaps his Home Opener highlights as they pivot from the box score to the menu, scouting the best new Yankee Stadium eats. Finally, the guys do a deep-dive into the state of the game to discuss the ABS rollout and fan engagement.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

We recap the Opening Night theatrics on Netflix. We discuss why the "Future of Baseball" felt like a bit of a production glitch despite the Yankees' 7-0 statement win.

Arm-ed and Dangerous: The rotation is sizzling. We break down the rotation's dominant start and how the bullpen has silenced the preseason doubters through the first series.

Lineup Temperature Check: It’s a game of peaks and valleys. We talk about the early-season "ups" and "downs".

From the lights to the music, we talk closer entrances and try to come up with some of our own.

Home Sweet Home: Anthony takes us through his essential rituals for the Yankee Stadium Home Opener and debate the ultimate question: Which Stadium bar is the superior pre-game destination?

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

​Opening Day Roster Deep Dive: Anthony and Dave break down the finalized 26-man roster heading to San Francisco.

​The 4-Man Gamble: What does this mean for Luis Gil's future?

​Bullpen decisions: With names like Cade Winquest and Brent Headrick snatching the final spots, the guys debate who Boone trusts in high-leverage situations.

​The "Best Bench in a Decade": A look at the veteran depth with Paul Goldschmidt, Randal Grichuk, and Amed Rosario ready to pinch-hit in big spots.

Will Warren officially switched #29. We remember some guys who wore the number while in pinstripes.

​AL East Preview Finale: Toronto Blue Jays: The preview series wraps up with the reigning American League Champions.

​Final Division Predictions: It’s time to put it on paper. Anthony and Dave give their official 1-through-5 AL East standings. Who takes the crown, and who is destined for a Wild Card scrap?

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

WBC Finale Heartbreak: Anthony and Dave discuss the 3-2 thriller in Miami that saw Venezuela capture its first-ever WBC title over Team USA and how the U.S. bats went cold when it mattered most.

The Judge Jury: Following an 0-for-4 performance in the final, the "clutch" debate surrounding Aaron Judge has reignited online. The fellas weigh in on the social media criticism, comparing his struggles in big game moments to his regular season success, and ask: Is the "big moment" narrative fair or just lazy?

AL East Preview: Boston Red Sox: The series continues with a look at the 2026 Sox. A sneaky-good rotation anchored by Ranger Suárez and Garrett Crochet, plus the defensive spark of Caleb Durbin could propel this team to a 90 win season. But, questions about bullpen depth and whether their young core can handle the high-pressure environment of Fenway for a full 162 may lead this team to another 3rd place or worse finish.

Whip Around Yankees Camp: Aaron Boone has officially confirmed Maf Fried is the Opening Night starter. Giancarlo Stanton is still crushing (another HR against Baltimore this week), proving that despite the "elbow" talk, the swing is still there. A quick update on Gerrit Cole’s recovery as he continues to ramp up toward a June return.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices