www.marktreichel.com

https://www.linkedin.com/in/mark-treichel/

NCUA in Limbo: What the Board Shakeup Means for Credit Unions

Episode Date: July 28, 2025
Host: Mark Treichel

Episode Summary

The NCUA board is in complete chaos following President Trump's firing of board members Todd Harper and Tanya Otsuka, their court-ordered reinstatement, and subsequent legal stay. Mark breaks down the dramatic week of legal battles, analyzes what happened during last Thursday's awkward board meeting, and predicts the 80% chance Harper and Otsuka won't return permanently.

Key Topics Covered

The Legal Drama Timeline

• Trump's firing of Harper and Otsuka
• Federal court ruling that Trump violated the Federal Credit Union Act
• Wednesday court decision ordering immediate reinstatement
• Weekend stay blocking their return
• Likely Supreme Court appeal ahead

Last Thursday's Board Meeting Analysis

• Harper and Otsuka's awkward return (Harper via video, Otsuka in person)
• Three "safe" briefings: AI, CLF, and the new Ombudsman office
• The "500-pound elephant in the room" that everyone avoided
• Why staff is in an impossible position

What's Next for the Board

• 80% odds Harper and Otsuka don't return permanently
• Kyle Huffman's term expires next month
• Possibility of Trump appointing 2-3 new board members before year-end
• Impact of onboarding multiple new board members simultaneously

Inspector General Report Bombshell

• Critical Infrastructure Division Director scandal exposed
• False statements on background investigations
• Sending sensitive NCUA documents to personal email
• Unauthorized outside employment while at NCUA
• Possible connection to unauthorized AI usage

Budget Implications

• Two-year budget cycle hanging in limbo
• No mid-year budget briefing despite historical precedent
• How a Republican board majority might cut costs to credit unions
• August board meeting hiatus continues tradition

Notable Quotes

"The 500 pound elephant in the room relative to the whole issue, all three sides avoided."

"I would say 80% chance that they do not come back and that the places will be filled before the end of the year."

"The professionalism of staff is well above average. And while they're going through all these things, it's chaotic."

Upcoming Content

Mark announces the OCC Risk Report series - breaking down his longer three-person discussion with Dennis, Steve, and Todd into shorter Thursday episodes throughout the summer. These will explore OCC findings and their implications for credit union examinations.